Which 360 game is Overrated?

For me mine is CoD4, the game is great I liked playing it but its not as great as what they tell me it is. What is you overrated game?

cod4

oblivion

Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.resident-shell

[QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.Matt-4542

[QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.resident-shell

[QUOTE="resident-shell"][QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.Matt-4542

Oblivion. Listen, when I first bought Oblivion back in 06, it was great. It was the most amazing looking game I had ever played. The world felt so real and the characters were life like. But when someone recommends the game today I just stare puzzled. It's no longer anywhere near the best looking game, combat is pretty weak, characters are grotesque and fake, and in 2008 it just isn't the great game it was.MuffinPunk

Yeah you're right, that's why hundreds of persons still play it today, that's why i played it for 270 hours and some for even more than 1000, the game sucks.

If you dont like a game that doesnt mean its bad, have you even thought why people recommend it? BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT!!

[QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"][QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.resident-shell

[QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"][QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.resident-shell

[QUOTE="MuffinPunk"]Oblivion. Listen, when I first bought Oblivion back in 06, it was great. It was the most amazing looking game I had ever played. The world felt so real and the characters were life like. But when someone recommends the game today I just stare puzzled. It's no longer anywhere near the best looking game, combat is pretty weak, characters are grotesque and fake, and in 2008 it just isn't the great game it was.great_rulo

Yeah you're right, that's why hundreds of persons still play it today, that's why i played it for 270 hours and some for even more than 1000, the game sucks.

If you dont like a game that doesnt mean its bad, have you even thought why people recommend it? BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT!!

500,000 people probably still play it. and that game is probably still the best RPG on the 360. or 2nd to mass effect

[QUOTE="great_rulo"]

[QUOTE="MuffinPunk"]Oblivion. Listen, when I first bought Oblivion back in 06, it was great. It was the most amazing looking game I had ever played. The world felt so real and the characters were life like. But when someone recommends the game today I just stare puzzled. It's no longer anywhere near the best looking game, combat is pretty weak, characters are grotesque and fake, and in 2008 it just isn't the great game it was.CharlyMurphy

Yeah you're right, that's why hundreds of persons still play it today, that's why i played it for 270 hours and some for even more than 1000, the game sucks.

If you dont like a game that doesnt mean its bad, have you even thought why people recommend it? BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT!!

500,000 people probably still play it. and that game is probably still the best RPG on the 360. or 2nd to mass effect

i couldnt stand oblivion and i LOVED mass effect.

GTA IV is by far the most over-rated game to ever be released. Just because of its popularity it receives great review scores also. Gears of War is in no way over-rated at all, the game has the most popular and involved multiplayer available to date, just to throw that in there. A better topic would be under-rated games.

GTA4 for sure, Gears of War is also overatedhashimgillani1

IS that why your gamerpicture and last game played is gears of war

[QUOTE="hashimgillani1"]GTA4 for sure, Gears of War is also overatedCharlyMurphy

IS that why your gamerpicture and last game played is gears of war

[QUOTE="resident-shell"][QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"][QUOTE="Matt-4542"][QUOTE="resident-shell"]Halo 3. Grand Theft Auto IV is only overrated on the professional's end, most gamers underrate it or have it just right.gta4_2112

[QUOTE="MuffinPunk"]Oblivion. Listen, when I first bought Oblivion back in 06, it was great. It was the most amazing looking game I had ever played. The world felt so real and the characters were life like. But when someone recommends the game today I just stare puzzled. It's no longer anywhere near the best looking game, combat is pretty weak, characters are grotesque and fake, and in 2008 it just isn't the great game it was.great_rulo

Yeah you're right, that's why hundreds of persons still play it today, that's why i played it for 270 hours and some for even more than 1000, the game sucks.

If you dont like a game that doesnt mean its bad, have you even thought why people recommend it? BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT!!

Halo 3, GTA IV, Gears of War, CoD4. All great games in their own rights, but all equally overrated.

Halo 3! is the most overated game in the world...I bought it the first day it came out and didnt meet up to any of my expectations!

Gears of War is better....

[QUOTE="hashimgillani1"]GTA4 for sure, Gears of War is also overatedCharlyMurphy

IS that why your gamerpicture and last game played is gears of war

Based on his Gamerscore, I'm guessing he just recently got a 360 and tried it out.

halo 3

gta 4

GTAIV is overrated. It reduced the amount of guns!

Halo 3 because the gameplay could of been better. I still love the story.

Gears of War, Call of Duty 4, Grand Theft Auto IV, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, Mass Effect, Guitar Hero III.

Keep in mind that thinking somthing is over rated does not mean I dis like it. I liked most of the games I listed, I just simply think their all over rated

[QUOTE="great_rulo"]

[QUOTE="MuffinPunk"]Oblivion. Listen, when I first bought Oblivion back in 06, it was great. It was the most amazing looking game I had ever played. The world felt so real and the characters were life like. But when someone recommends the game today I just stare puzzled. It's no longer anywhere near the best looking game, combat is pretty weak, characters are grotesque and fake, and in 2008 it just isn't the great game it was.CharlyMurphy

Yeah you're right, that's why hundreds of persons still play it today, that's why i played it for 270 hours and some for even more than 1000, the game sucks.

If you dont like a game that doesnt mean its bad, have you even thought why people recommend it? BECAUSE THEY LIKE IT!!

500,000 people probably still play it. and that game is probably still the best RPG on the 360. or 2nd to mass effect

If you guys can honestly still enjoy it then kudos to you. I'm just saying that in a time when players want beautiful visuals, tight combat and an immersive detailed world, Oblivion doesn't deliver like it did in the past. Of course it's still a good game and new comers can still fully enjoy it. Like I said, I was blown away playing it back in 2006, put in well over 100 hours. But playing it today I notice all the faults that I had over looked.

GTA IV is by far the most over-rated game to ever be released. Just because of its popularity it receives great review scores also. Gears of War is in no way over-rated at all, the game has the most popular and involved multiplayer available to date, just to throw that in there. A better topic would be under-rated games.

Engage28

Gears was extremely overrated. ESPECIALLY because of the Multiplayer. Most underrated 360 game is Condemned: Criminal Origins.

Halo 3.

it's a great game and all, and I had fun playing it.

but it's just not as good as everyone says it is.