Scariest X360 Game?

Having a hang out with a bunch of friends and I am wanting a pretty scary game. We are looking into RE5 or FEAR 2, however we are open to suggestions. Which ones do you guys think?

In all honesty I think RE5 looks more overwhelming rather than scary, howeveer I could be proven wrong!

condemned

resident evil 5

Really? You didn't even post Dead Space, Condemned 1/2 or the original FEAR? doomsoth

FEAR 2 scary if your susceptible to japanese horror (scary dead chicks with long hair). It scared me more than the first FEAR did.

RE5 is not scary.

Dead space is mildly scary.

Condemned 2 is good, but the first condemned is the scariest game on the 360

And "scary" games are only really scary if you play them alone at night on a good tv and with surround sound blasting or with some decent earphones. In order to fully take advantage of "scary" games you ought to do this.

FEAR 1

Dead Space gives me the creeps.

RE5 is the best co-op horror game for the 360. I'd stick with that if you want to play with your friends.

With freinds: Left 4 Dead - While not a horrifying game, things get tense and tend to keep you on edge. I remember being jumpy after the first time me and my freinds gave this game an all nighter.

Alone: Katamari Damacy - Feel horror as you realize the music in this game will never come out of your head.

I'm... not going to vote yet since the only slightly "scary" game I've played so far (360 or not) is Fallout 3, which is NOT scary.DaMattGuy-360XL

[QUOTE="DaMattGuy-360XL"]I'm... not going to vote yet since the only slightly "scary" game I've played so far (360 or not) is Fallout 3, which is NOT scary.phynixblack

The first Condemned was so friggin' scary I couldn't even play it in broad daylight with friends.

[QUOTE="phynixblack"][QUOTE="DaMattGuy-360XL"]I'm... not going to vote yet since the only slightly "scary" game I've played so far (360 or not) is Fallout 3, which is NOT scary.DaMattGuy-360XL

Lol

I leaned on the remote in Oblivion while I was reading something on my laptop and jacked the volume while it was paused, unpaused it and bam wolf in my face with huge noise almost blew my speakers scared the living crap outta me.

Seriously though, go for FEAR 2.

Lol

I leaned on the remote in Oblivion while I was reading something on my laptop and jacked the volume while it was paused, unpaused it and bam wolf in my face with huge noise almost blew my speakers scared the living crap outta me.

Seriously though, go for FEAR 2.

sensfanVone

dead space..dark and scary

fear 2 is alot scarier than re5. but dead space tops them both. fl;gksdflg;sdfa

[QUOTE="DaMattGuy-360XL"]I'm... not going to vote yet since the only slightly "scary" game I've played so far (360 or not) is Fallout 3, which is NOT scary.phynixblack

From what I've played Dead Space. But I've never actually really found myself scared by a video game, I still would like to play FEAR though.

Fear 2 Definally has its moments. I usualy get scared for a second when things Pop Up at me when I don't realise it. :|

play Dead Space.

RE5 is not scary, but it does have its oh **** moments. It is a VERY tense game though if you like to sit on th edge of your seat or catch yourself holding your breath.

Really? You didn't even post Dead Space, Condemned 1/2 or the original FEAR? doomsoth

Dead Space, condemned, or the original FEAR. I didn't really find RE5 that scary ( on last chapter ) and FEAR 2 is nowhere near as scary as the original.

yeah fear2 is pretty creepy, same with Condemed 1 and 2. RE5 isnt scary at all. i think 1/2 of scary is the fact you can't see whats coming at you, RE5 is more about action than being scary.

Dead Space can be quite scary, some of the enemy models look quite disgusting which helps a bit. I played it in the middle of the night with earphones, in a daylight it's a total waste in my opinion especially if you are playing your first run. I haven't played any game which would be genuinely scary, most of the time they just have moments which will make you jump when you don't expect something.