Mafia 2 Collectors Edition or Red Dead Redemption GOTY?

I don't know which one to get.. Red Dead Redemption is considerably cheaper though.

Yeah I know, I've completed it 100% haha. I love both games though and Mafia 2 Collectors Edition is **** cool. But I just ordered Red Dead.

havent played mafia 2, but you absolutely cant pass up red dead, definitely a buy.

I have both to be honest. Mafia 2 is an exceptional story driven game, and so is Red Dead. Good choices!

I have both to be honest. Mafia 2 is an exceptional story driven game, and so is Red Dead. Good choices!

EvilSelf

I have to agree here. You don't hear about it much, but I was really emotionally engaged in Mafia, which doesn't happen often with me and video-games. Great story(aside from the obvious cliches), and well acted throughout. Just once you're done, you're pretty much done, unless you fancy another run-through.

Red Dead will keep you invested for a while though.

Red Dead Redemption

Get Red Dead asap. Awsome game

RDR definitely. The only reason why I would recommend MAfia 2 over RDR first is due to the fact that it's harder to find (Unless you go to Best Buy or Target) and the platinum Hits version comes with all 5 DLC packs which cost you about $9.99 each on Xbox Live. I highly recommend Mafia 2 as well. RDR is easily the best game this gen (As far as open world, then Skyrim and finally GTA IV + The Episodes).

If you haven't played Red Dead Redemption yet pick that up and play it ASAP. Greatest game this generation.

Red Dead.. open world, more to do and is overall a better game.

I've cleared it 100% haha.