LA Noire - Replay Value?

I just got a copy of it, and so far has only played up to "Buyer Beware".

Out of curiosity I checked out the walkthrough for this game (up to where I played), and apparently, it appears to have a 'linear' storyline.

If I were to play it again once I finish it, would the evidence and interrogation questions (and answers) be the same for all the cases? Where would the replay value (if any) come in for this game?

Nothing changes for a second time around after you beat it. It was a very good idea for a game, but it just falls flat once you realize everything is the same. Not much replay value once you beat it, at least for me.

there isnt much unless your a completionist La noire is really the type of game you shouldn't play witha guide it defeats the whole purpose of the game really. I can promise you if you do a legit blind playthrough you will miss a ton of stuff and then there is replay value in going back to the cases you didnt perfect. The game is of a good length though on a single playthrough especially if you have all the dlc cases ala the complete edition. Theres also the collectible stuff if your a completionist so yeah its replay value may not be that strong but you get your monies worth imo. You could easily spend 20 hours on a single playthrough maybe more depending on if you go after the side stuff too.

there isnt much unless your a completionist La noire is really the type of game you shouldn't play witha guide it defeats the whole purpose of the game really. I can promise you if you do a legit blind playthrough you will miss a ton of stuff and then there is replay value in going back to the cases you didnt perfect. The game is of a good length though on a single playthrough especially if you have all the dlc cases ala the complete edition. Theres also the collectible stuff if your a completionist so yeah its replay value may not be that strong but you get your monies worth imo. You could easily spend 20 hours on a single playthrough maybe more depending on if you go after the side stuff too.

Gen007

Forget replay value, if you're anything like me you will have trouble just getting to the end. It gets mind numbingly repetitive as you go on. The cases get longer and longer, even though you keep doing the same 3 or 4 things (drive here, walk around clumsily till you here the "ding" for something of interest, interrogate, repeat). Was an interesting game experience for me since I was blown away by it in the beginning and hated it by the end.

Forget replay value, if you're anything like me you will have trouble just getting to the end. It gets mind numbingly repetitive as you go on. The cases get longer and longer, even though you keep doing the same 3 or 4 things (drive here, walk around clumsily till you here the "ding" for something of interest, interrogate, repeat). Was an interesting game experience for me since I was blown away by it in the beginning and hated it by the end.

willsoonbegone

Halfway through I got bored of doing exactly the same thing over and over, and stopped playing. WIll come back some day though as I don't like having unfinished games :P

There are some mini missions you get through the radio throughout but other than that there is no replay value.

One and done.

Once you finish it you might as well trade it it not much to do after you beat it

Just finished it last night - including the DLC - but will not be playing through it again......

I did love the game - thought it had amazing attention to detail and a great atmosphere - I do understand the cricitism about it being repeative - I must admit if I had had to do another 'desk' round of cases I would have got pretty bored - for me it was just the right length.....

I did miss out on a few achievements - but I won't be replaying it just to get them - time to move onto another game.....

but I did give it a 8.5 or 9 out of 10 simply for it's uniqueness and attention to details (I didn't mind the slow type of game play)

:)