I have just finished the game. I went fully completionist with it. 16 hours in total, but that was a hell of a ride.
South Park: Stick of the Truth is probably the best (western) JRPG in the last 8 years. Yeh I mean it.
The funniest game I have played in the long long time. The first game this year that I have completed without playing other games.
In my opinion, this game is a 9/10. Kevin Vanord, criticizing the rpg part, probably haven´t played an old school jrpg before. This game is one of the most fun jrpg I have ever played. Old school JRPGs as a genre are not great RPGs by default. But Stick of the Truth is a nice exception. Obviously, Baldur's Gate it is not.
But the story, humor and gameplay as a whole package are top notch. Seriously. I can't remember being so engaged with the story since Mass Effect (South Park-style type of a story, of course).
RPG: 6/10, but gameplay in general, 9/10
Story : 9/10
Humor, gag, references: 10/10
Graphics: like cartoon itself, almost imperceptible transition between cinematics and gameplay, 10/10
Final Score: 9/10, I want a sequel NOW.
So what is your verdict ?