I would say WiiU - the gamepad is used primarily as a Map, Options, Menu organizer in a tiny screen attached to a controller.......ALL can be done (Pre-WiiU) on a TV screen, you just have to press a button to open up a window.
Kinect at least is being offered as an OPTION and no longer shoved down consumers' throats.
Would I buy a $399 XB1? Nope, because PS4 does pretty much everything and better. Probably post E3 will help me decide.