I recently beat Nier Replicant. Achieved all endings except for D (just YouTube'd it lol). Honest opinion - 6/10. If it wasn't for the repetition - 8/10. Loved the story and characters, but compared to Nier Automata, combat wasn't as satisfying, common enemies lacked variety, and the amount of grinding that needs to be done to complete missions and achieve the endings is awful lol. Nier Automata did it better. As for positives - boss fights were interesting, writing was great, and the lore establishes the link between Replicant and Automata (especially with ending E). Nonetheless, I love this game, but the flaws impacted my score greatly.
How about you, SW? What was the last game you beat and what you would rate it?