[QUOTE="RuprechtMonkey"] I would rather them began production on HL3 right after HL2, rather than making small Episodes every two years. Gabe's vision of Episodic content has been a failure. The reason he originally set down that path was so he could get them out faster, he promised fans that because they weren't developing full-fledged sequels (and continuing to use the same basic engine as in HL2) they could get them out much faster- hasn't been the case. Now we're having to wait years just to get a small episode's worth of content.
If they had began HL3 after HL2 we would be seeing a full, awesome sequel with a new version of Source soon. Now because they haven't we'll have to wait more and more years until HL3. It will be almost a decade between HL2 and HL3. That's not acceptable. I don't mind "Waiting a few years" either, waiting a decade is another matter.
sonicmj1
Why is it a failure?
If you think of the episodes collectively as a kind of Half-Life 3 (as has been suggested by Valve), you're getting content about equal to a full game, at very high quality, spread out over the time it would have taken them to release it as a single product. Have you already forgotten that it took Valve six years to make a sequel to Half-Life 1?
While the episodes haven't quite delivered in terms of cutting down development time, they're still coming significantly faster than if Valve had waited to make a full retail product, and they've all been uniformly excellent. I don't see what the problem here is.
You aren't going 10 years without a new game. You're getting one every year and a half, which is downright incredible given Valve's development cycles.
Because while the Episodes have been good, a full fleshed out sequel they are not - even combined. And in my opinion Episode One was compartively weak.
If they had done this after the original HL, HL2 would have been released in small sections over 6 years and it would look virtually identical to HL1... and it would've been of a much smaller scale than the HL2 as we know it. That would've been awful. Think about that.
These are not "new games." They are tiny expansions that take two years. It has not been worth it, this brand of Episodic content has been a complete failure.
How are they coming out faster than a full retail product?!?!! Episode 3 will have been more than 5 full years since HL2 when it finally comes out, maybe closer to six. They could've made HL3 in that time.
So Half Life 3 is the relatively small-scale cousin of Half Life 2?
I really don't want that to be true. Half Life 2 was the culmination of all current-gen technology up until that point. Half Life 3 should have that same effect.
Like really, Valve should blow our minds again single-handedly with one game.
FrozenLiquid
Exactly.
Log in to comment