SW Rewind: revisiting the classic Sony flop, The Order 1886

  • 57 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for SolidGame_basic
Posted by SolidGame_basic (24260 posts) 13 days, 21 hours ago

Poll: SW Rewind: revisiting the classic Sony flop, The Order 1886 (82 votes)

It's one of the worst flops ever. 44%
It's actually not that bad. 56%

On paper, The Order 1886 had a great selling point; third person steampunk game taking place in alternate history 1886 London featuring badass high tech gadgets, the Knights of the Round Table, and werewolves (even vampires too). The hype was building for a game that I think at the time was being compared to Uncharted, or at least a cooler version of it. But then the game launched, and it quickly became the stuff that Sony haters have come to call the "movie game". Lots of cut scenes, lots of walking around, and very linear gameplay. Oh, and the boss fight was an exact copy of the same boss fight that you had midgame. Now granted, the game did have some positives. It had pretty amazing graphics, and the gun mechanics were pretty fun (with some pretty intense shooting). So it wasn't all that terrible, but it did miss the mark.

So where do you stand on this game, SW? Did you try? Beat it? (it's pretty short) Throw it out the window? And most importantly, where does it stand as a flop in flop history?

Oh, and shout out to @cainetao11 who inspired this thread.

Avatar image for Pedro
#1 Posted by Pedro (34907 posts) -

I couldn't deal with the frequency of cutscenes. It was just too much. If they make a sequel with more focus on the player at the cost of pushing the cinematic narrative, I will be all in. :)

Avatar image for calvincfb
#2 Posted by Calvincfb (1590 posts) -

Ryse exists and its MC score is even lower than The Order's. I couldn't care less about those games tbh, they're more like tech demos than anything.

Avatar image for Pedro
#3 Edited by Pedro (34907 posts) -

@calvincfb said:

Ryse exists and its MC score is even lower than The Order's. I couldn't care less about those games tbh, they're more like tech demos than anything.

I made it through Ryse, couldn't make it through The Order. Anytime a game refuses to have meaningful interactions with a certain time frame my gameplay A.D.D kicks in. My most recent poison was Hellblade the movie. :)

Avatar image for phbz
#4 Posted by phbz (4497 posts) -

The game was ok. Had cool mustaches.

Avatar image for MonsieurX
#5 Posted by MonsieurX (39127 posts) -

Enjoyed it on Youtube

Avatar image for hrt_rulz01
#6 Edited by hrt_rulz01 (18974 posts) -

@calvincfb: Who said anything about Ryse? Salty much? Lol.

And Ryse is the better game, because atleast there is actually gameplay.

Avatar image for goldenelementxl
#7 Edited by GoldenElementXL (3241 posts) -

The story was kinda neat, but you can tell it was rushed. The boss fights were beyond stupid, though. As for the visuals, the design was good but the film grain and motion blur were very aggressive. My favorite part about The Order 1886 were the resolution threads. Fighting with @tormentos and others about how the game wasn't native 1080p because of the black bars was pretty fun. That was one of the most creative goal post moves I've seen by cows on this board.

Avatar image for goldenelementxl
#8 Posted by GoldenElementXL (3241 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Who said anything about Ryse? Salty much? Lol.

And Ryse is the better game, because atleast there is actually gameplay.

Very true. I got the platinum in The Order 1886 in under 6 hours I think. A single playthrough and then I had to redo the very beginning of a chapter to pick up a collectible I missed. Ryse had far better gameplay than The Order imo. I think Ryse got a bad rap for whatever reason. People killed the combat for the QTE/color cues, yet every 3rd person action game has used some sort of a variation since. I hate to be the conspiracy theorist here, but the gaming press kinda had it out for the Xbox One at launch. Ryse was better than The Order in every way...

Avatar image for Rockman999
#9 Posted by Rockman999 (7508 posts) -

The Order 1886 was a classic Sony flop?

Did ya kids forget about Lair? Or what about that shooter from Ubisoft with the drugged out super soldiers with black and yellow suits? Or MAG?

Avatar image for alexxanderozzy
#10 Edited by AlexxanderOzzy (3 posts) -

A 6 out of 10 for me. I bought it for $6 during a PSN sale. I found it to be somewhat entertaining. The story was a little predictable, there was too many QTE prompts and too little shooting. But as a tech demo of sorts, I thought it was okay. Nowhere worth the initial $60 retail price. And yes, Ryse was better. I would give that Xbox launch title a 7 out of 10.

Avatar image for alexxanderozzy
#11 Posted by AlexxanderOzzy (3 posts) -

@Rockman999: Very good point. Those three games you mentioned were probably worse than Order 1886.

Avatar image for BenjaminBanklin
#12 Posted by BenjaminBanklin (4740 posts) -

Never played it. It just never really appealed to me.

Avatar image for Nike_Air
#13 Edited by Nike_Air (19310 posts) -

7/10. Would love to get a sequel. Scott Rohde and Shu Yoshida probably didn't greenlight it because people like Colin and Greg kept on excessively bashing it. It is one of the things I dislike about Sony this gen. They should have doubled-down on the IP and made it better. But hey , maybe they greenlit Spider-Man instead. Who knows.

Avatar image for Telekill
#14 Edited by Telekill (8484 posts) -

I was actually planning to replay it soon. I regret buying the $80 collectors edition but the game was solid. Great setting. Fun gameplay. I believe the game was initially said to be a co-op based game so it was a let down not to be able to roam that universe with a friend. Other than that though, I really enjoyed it.

Avatar image for ellos
#15 Posted by ellos (2036 posts) -

It was actually shitty at everything but the game length focus was too much. I believe that controversy caused UC4 to be delayed and stretched out.

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#16 Edited by lundy86_4 (53359 posts) -

Excellent setting with terrible cutscene-to-gameplay ratio, as well as being blurry as all Hell. A sequel based upon the setting, with how we've seen Sony studios grow... That would be great.

Avatar image for sakaixx
#17 Posted by sakaiXx (5662 posts) -

Loved the game. Hope we gets a sequel cause damn world building in this game is so good! I dislike the american setting for next game if there is, should have stayed in london.

Avatar image for BassMan
#18 Edited by BassMan (10366 posts) -

The Blur: 1886 was a blurfest. So, it is all a blur to me now as it was back then. hehe ;)

Avatar image for robbie23
#19 Posted by Robbie23 (367 posts) -

I actually really enjoyed the order, however I only paid 10 bucks for the game. I do not mind cut scenes in games.

Avatar image for robbie23
#20 Posted by Robbie23 (367 posts) -

@Rockman999: I thought MAG was awesome.

Avatar image for xantufrog
#21 Edited by xantufrog (11506 posts) -

I'd give it an honest 6/10. A "fair". It's definitely NOT "good", but it's got redeeming qualities. Most notably, the world and gadgets hint at a good game that could have been. The biggest problem for me is it was so SO short, that literally every cool gadget was a one-off use and every cool location or hint of lore was also one-and-done. There was no opportunity to grow attached to the characters, or learn to use the gadgets, or decided to use them to tackle different problems, or...

shallow as puddle, but it had the right ingredients to be quite deep and engrossing. I hope they get another shot to do something way way way more involved with it.

Avatar image for ellos
#22 Edited by ellos (2036 posts) -

@goldenelementxl said:
@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Who said anything about Ryse? Salty much? Lol.

And Ryse is the better game, because atleast there is actually gameplay.

Very true. I got the platinum in The Order 1886 in under 6 hours I think. A single playthrough and then I had to redo the very beginning of a chapter to pick up a collectible I missed. Ryse had far better gameplay than The Order imo. I think Ryse got a bad rap for whatever reason. People killed the combat for the QTE/color cues, yet every 3rd person action game has used some sort of a variation since. I hate to be the conspiracy theorist here, but the gaming press kinda had it out for the Xbox One at launch. Ryse was better than The Order in every way...

Nah it got average scores because it was an average cinematic combat game. Far more basic then even the basic combat games of today. At least the average games of today include some details for players to express themselves. The use of qte are not its problems. Did not invent or even popularize qte mechanics in any form this gen. Absolutely no cred should be given to it, not even close. I agree its a better game to play then The Order. Beatiful and you can actually enjoy the ride nothing wrong with that. There are other games to cry out xbox is a victim then Ryse IMO.

Avatar image for pyro1245
#23 Posted by pyro1245 (5051 posts) -

I don't really care about game length. 4 hours is a good length, though maybe not for $60.

I never played it because the game play looked very flat. I was into the setting.

I always forget about this game when talking about PS4 exclusives. Maybe when the PS5 comes out and I can grab a digital copy for $5 I'll try it. Probably not though. Just doesn't seem like my thing in the game play dept.

Avatar image for heirren
#24 Posted by Heirren (1447 posts) -

@pyro1245:

Its the slow walking around that can be tedious.

The shooting is on the much better side. It doesnt feel as light as most tps. It feels like it has weight or momentum to both the player character and ai. Its rather difficult to describe, but it has a pop to it. Better than Uncharted and Gears in this respect.

Avatar image for scatteh316
#25 Posted by scatteh316 (10252 posts) -

A little short but I enjoyed it............ graphically it looks amazing with one of the most realistic lighting and PBR material systems ever put in to a game.

In fact, off the top of my head I can't think of a single game that has a more realistic PBR implementation.

Avatar image for scatteh316
#26 Edited by scatteh316 (10252 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Who said anything about Ryse? Salty much? Lol.

And Ryse is the better game, because atleast there is actually gameplay.

Now is that you being a dumb ass fan boy or is that you having actually played both?

Because I've played both and that comment is retarded.

Avatar image for hrt_rulz01
#27 Posted by hrt_rulz01 (18974 posts) -

@scatteh316: Yes I have played both... and I had zero desire to finish The Order. Might as well just watch a movie.

And just because you disagree with it because it gets your fanboy panties in a bunch, doesn't mean it's "retarded".

Avatar image for scatteh316
#28 Posted by scatteh316 (10252 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:

@scatteh316: Yes I have played both... and I had zero desire to finish The Order. Might as well just watch a movie.

And just because you disagree with it because it gets your fanboy panties in a bunch, doesn't mean it's "retarded".

So you've had a quick 5 minutes on it.....hardly a good basis for an opinion...... I only played Odyssey for a short while and it was shit...... Horizion (which I completed) is the far superior game.

Avatar image for saltslasher
#29 Posted by SaltSlasher (1141 posts) -

I went to GS to buy Uncharted 4 for $10, but it was 4 for $20, and only thing I could find worth a damn was 1886, Division and Yooka.

So I figured $5 each. For that cost, it was fine, but I get why people thought it was a bust, and obviously not in same realm as later PS4 exclusives.

Avatar image for mclarenmaster18
#30 Posted by MclarenMaster18 (1558 posts) -

I'm glad that I avoided buying 1886 The Order because this game has boring gameplay, bad characters and short length.

Avatar image for hrt_rulz01
#31 Posted by hrt_rulz01 (18974 posts) -

@scatteh316: You have no idea how long I played it for... But hey, whatever makes you feel better.

And as for Odyssey and Horizon, good for you. I couldn't care less :)

Avatar image for R4gn4r0k
#32 Posted by R4gn4r0k (31188 posts) -

I enjoyed both Ryse and The Order. I've played far worse launch games.

Avatar image for nethernova
#33 Posted by nethernova (5699 posts) -

@goldenelementxl said:

People killed the combat for the QTE/color cues, yet every 3rd person action game has used some sort of a variation since.

The difference being that QTEs in Ryse were completely pointless. You couldn't fail them. Even if you didn't press a button at all you killed the enemy.

Avatar image for raining51
#34 Posted by Raining51 (1124 posts) -

@Pedro said:

I couldn't deal with the frequency of cutscenes. It was just too much. If they make a sequel with more focus on the player at the cost of pushing the cinematic narrative, I will be all in. :)

Avatar image for _Matt_
#35 Posted by _Matt_ (10490 posts) -

I really enjoyed it. I admittedly went in with tempered expectations but it delivered. The story was great, and the gameplay solid.

It is flawed, and its far from a goty, but I enjoyed what I played

Avatar image for calvincfb
#36 Edited by Calvincfb (1590 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Who said anything about Ryse? Salty much? Lol.

And Ryse is the better game, because atleast there is actually gameplay.

You missed my point entirely.

Both games were hyped then flopped.

Both are bad games, but they're more like tech demos than games.

Still, The Order sold more and has a higher MC than Ryse.

I have a ps4, a switch and a 3ds, unlike you, sad xbox owned, I have games available to play, I'm not salty.

Next time, think before you write so you can spare yourself from some ownage.

Avatar image for hrt_rulz01
#37 Posted by hrt_rulz01 (18974 posts) -

@calvincfb: Lmao... this is the dumbest post I've read on here in a while. Congrats.

Avatar image for Zero_epyon
#38 Posted by Zero_epyon (13289 posts) -

I didn't like the film grain. I hate film grain in games.

Avatar image for Willy105
#39 Posted by Willy105 (24836 posts) -

It's a forgettable release, like most of Sony's 1st party games that aren't Naughty Dog.

Avatar image for calvincfb
#40 Edited by Calvincfb (1590 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Lmao... this is the dumbest post I've read on here in a while. Congrats.

Comeback with a good counterpoint to what I said, stay owned till then.

Avatar image for hrt_rulz01
#41 Posted by hrt_rulz01 (18974 posts) -

@calvincfb said:
@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Lmao... this is the dumbest post I've read on here in a while. Congrats.

Comeback with a good counterpoint to what I said, stay owned till then.

It doesn't deserve a good counterpoint... if you don't know why, then that says it all.

Have a nice day :)

Avatar image for Macutchi
#42 Posted by Macutchi (6791 posts) -
@Pedro said:

I couldn't deal with the frequency of cutscenes. It was just too much.

yeah same.

it was choc full of mechanics and cliches that i hate in gaming. constantly wrestling control from the player. qte central. hand holding. ultra linearity. limited mechanics. "interactive" cut scenes.

returned to it a year later to see if i was being unfair initially. i wasn't. disliked it more second time round

Avatar image for calvincfb
#43 Posted by Calvincfb (1590 posts) -

@hrt_rulz01 said:
@calvincfb said:
@hrt_rulz01 said:

@calvincfb: Lmao... this is the dumbest post I've read on here in a while. Congrats.

Comeback with a good counterpoint to what I said, stay owned till then.

It doesn't deserve a good counterpoint... if you don't know why, then that says it all.

Have a nice day :)

I do know why: because you're a sad owned lem. lmao

Avatar image for pdogg93
#44 Posted by pdogg93 (1600 posts) -

I enjoyed this game for what it was. Worth $5 to me

Avatar image for r-gamer
#45 Edited by R-Gamer (211 posts) -

I actually really enjoyed it. It wasn't perfect but I would have liked to see a sequel.

Avatar image for ButDuuude
#46 Edited by ButDuuude (1345 posts) -

Both have nice graphics and mediocre gameplay. I played The Order 1886 the most and got the platinum trophy for it and Ryse I didn’t even finish it.

Avatar image for princessgomez92
#47 Posted by PrincessGomez92 (5730 posts) -

I actually enjoyed it a lot and beat it a couple times. It had its issues, but I thought the story was great and the gameplay was solid, and I loved the setting and atmosphere. I'd give it like an 8.

Avatar image for Fuhrer_D
#48 Posted by Fuhrer_D (874 posts) -

I was off work sick the day if came out; so I watched the whole thing on Twitch, decent, but I wouldn't have been happy paying for it.

Avatar image for wiiboxstation
#49 Posted by Wiiboxstation (1386 posts) -

18.86 should have been the price.

It flopped for the price. 60 bucks and like 3 hours of gameplay.

Avatar image for pc_rocks
#50 Posted by PC_Rocks (2472 posts) -

@goldenelementxl said:

The story was kinda neat, but you can tell it was rushed. The boss fights were beyond stupid, though. As for the visuals, the design was good but the film grain and motion blur were very aggressive. My favorite part about The Order 1886 were the resolution threads. Fighting with @tormentos and others about how the game wasn't native 1080p because of the black bars was pretty fun. That was one of the most creative goal post moves I've seen by cows on this board.

Ummm....you serious? Unless you're talking about the idea or setting I don't see how story was even remotely 'neat'.