Ryse: Son of Rome getting Rave reviews from Amazon Customers

  • 105 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for slader236
#1 Edited by slader236 (52 posts) -

You can see the Amazon reviews here: http://www.amazon.com/Ryse-Son-Rome-Day-Edition-Xbox/product-reviews/B00CMQTU74/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

The game is also scoring great on the Xbox store with 4.5/5, the same as Forza 5 with almost as many people rating it: http://store.xbox.com/en-CA/xbox-one/games/Ryse/02670f2e-1054-42c2-b16e-2dcf67d2c147

Some go even so far as saying this being the best game they've ever played and calling it a masterpiece, not only because of the unreal movielike graphics. People can't believe how this game scored so badly from pro reviewers. I guess Kotaku giving the game a YES doesn't sound so wrong anymore;)

I don't know what went wrong with the reviews of this game. Was it Sony's great PR? Reviewers that don't like fighting games? Were these guys simply rushing through the game so as to get over with it? Are they afraid of being called dumb if they would give a great score to this game, because every other review has a low score?

Gamespot giving the game a 4, this is just wrong. Even if you don't like the gameplay mechanics and perceived repetitiveness of it. Games like Call of Duty and even better scored games can be perceived as repetitive. Isn't Call of Duty shooting one dude after another? In Ryse you simply slash and stab one dude after another, but boy with what style.

The game has extreme production values, with great sound and voice acting, and the graphics and animations are second to none. The fighting mechanics are also closer to reality than let's say God of War. Why are some reviewers even comparing the game to GoW, apart from the Roman setting that is similar to GoW's setting of old Greece they share almost nothing in common. Are reviewers scoring it that low because they think if a game has swords it has to play like GoW? Has a game like GoW that sugar coats it's gameplay with endless combos that are so distanced from reality really better gameplay than Ryse which relies on precise timing with a limited set of reality grounded attacks?

I call bias on Gamespot's review of Ryse. They give scores of 5 or 6 to games that are a bug-ridden mess with horrible gameplay, and yet when a game like Ryse tries to introduce a new gameplay style to gamers and excels in some categories they punish it with a 4. In the meantime, games like Call of Duty, Killzone: Shadow Fall and God of War that rehash the same old gameplay get scores of 7, 8 or even 9.

Trolls that haven't played Ryse and only think that they know everything about the game from reviews need not apply;)

Avatar image for lamprey263
#3 Edited by lamprey263 (34425 posts) -

I watched quite a bit of gameplay on the 24 hour marathon feed and it looked pretty darn cool, if I get an X1 I'll definitely be picking this up.

Avatar image for Chutebox
#4 Edited by Chutebox (43134 posts) -

I guess there is bias against Knack too since it has 4 stars with more reviews.

Wait, did he say new gameplay?

Avatar image for _Matt_
#5 Edited by _Matt_ (10433 posts) -

Is that you, Thunder?

Avatar image for Shewgenja
#6 Posted by Shewgenja (18997 posts) -

So, a bunch of people who bought a $500 TV remote happened to think a game is underrated?

Wow, stop the press!

Avatar image for MlauTheDaft
#7 Posted by MlauTheDaft (5189 posts) -

It looks incredibly repetetive and has way to much slow motion.

Personally, I'm not all that impressed with the graphics either, but most reviewers are and still directly adress the mind numbing combat.

Avatar image for NFJSupreme
#8 Edited by NFJSupreme (6491 posts) -

Lol ryse

Lol amazon reviewers

Only on system wars is this worth a thread.

Avatar image for XxR3m1xInHDn3D
#9 Edited by XxR3m1xInHDn3D (2365 posts) -

Looks like a fun game to play through once and never again

Avatar image for MBirdy88
#10 Posted by MBirdy88 (12135 posts) -

I know quite a few freinds on facebook that "love it" . but tahts just it, casual gamers might love it, people who play games constantly probably won't because it has no depth, no challenge... its just a flashy interactive experiance. but then that sums up a large ammount of AAA games as of later.

Avatar image for cainetao11
#11 Edited by cainetao11 (32487 posts) -

@slader236: While I agree there some stupid instances of reviews using the repetitive or more of the same excuse, I cant help but wonder if Ryse is as good as you claim in the OP. Dude, I wante the game to be good, hell I want every game to be. Don't see the sense in hoping a game is bad, if you're a gamer. Arkham origins got dinged for being more of the same, then a few weeks later COD and BF4 get 8's for being, well COD and BF. It is ridiculous. But I get the feeling Ryse will be fun for a play through, as a rental. I cant see spending $60 on it. I am a sucker for gory blade kills, but reading the reviews I have, it just doesn't seem to be anything special other than graphics. I'll find out and post when I play it.

Avatar image for Szminsky
#12 Edited by Szminsky (1471 posts) -

I watched a playthrough of the game.. You encounter the same frickin 3 types of enemies throughout the entire game with the occasional goat head. Repetitive to say the least.

Avatar image for Nonstop-Madness
#13 Posted by Nonstop-Madness (9845 posts) -

The vast majority of people want a next gen game with next gen graphics. Ryse delivers in that sense but from reviews, that's pretty much all it delivers.

Avatar image for Newhopes
#14 Edited by Newhopes (4756 posts) -

From what I've seen and the short period I play it it's a fun game but I can see it getting very repetitive after a few hours.

Avatar image for foxhound_fox
#15 Posted by foxhound_fox (96695 posts) -

lol user reviews

Avatar image for JohnF111
#16 Posted by JohnF111 (14187 posts) -

Haha lems going through a breakdown.

Avatar image for Heil68
#17 Posted by Heil68 (57720 posts) -

The first part to the healing process is to accept the flop, then and only then can the healing begin

Avatar image for Joedgabe
#18 Edited by Joedgabe (5134 posts) -

Should just use Gamespot user reviews..... it would be just as reliable as another site's review even if it does have the verified buyer. My point being that i believe Amazon reviews as sources is quite silly.

Avatar image for tormentos
#19 Posted by tormentos (26634 posts) -

Those MS Shill dollars in action...lol

Avatar image for Newhopes
#20 Posted by Newhopes (4756 posts) -

@JohnF111 said:

Haha lems going through a breakdown.

Borezone flop thread is that way-------------->

Avatar image for PhazonBlazer
#21 Posted by PhazonBlazer (12013 posts) -

I played it, graphics are great. Gameplay sucks.

Avatar image for JohnF111
#22 Posted by JohnF111 (14187 posts) -

@Newhopes: then you better hurry you're late!

Avatar image for GreySeal9
#23 Posted by GreySeal9 (28247 posts) -

Oh look. A whole bunch of people trying to justify their purchase on Amazon.

Avatar image for GreySeal9
#24 Posted by GreySeal9 (28247 posts) -
@JohnF111 said:

Haha lems going through a breakdown.

Any "breakdown" that the lems are going through doesn't compare to the cow meltdown when Forza got a 9.

Avatar image for ReadingRainbow4
#25 Posted by ReadingRainbow4 (18733 posts) -

Ryse fall of xbone.

Avatar image for groowagon
#26 Posted by groowagon (4560 posts) -

dumbasses calling Ryse masterpiece are ruining game industry. people who are willing to pay full price from shit are sending wrong message to publishers. they will just make more shit games.

i think people just have hard time admitting they wasted $60 to a crappy game and they are praising it for nothing.

Avatar image for Jankarcop
#27 Posted by Jankarcop (11056 posts) -

how much is M$ paying you?

Avatar image for padaporra
#28 Edited by padaporra (3508 posts) -

The game has a great story, unparalleled graphics and a simple gameplay. But in the end it is fun to play, even if it is a game you won't be playing two or three times. Reviewrs are generally just lost. Each game is judged with a different set of criteria. What can be the main cause of a game scoring a low score might be utterly ignored in another.

And as far as nextgen is concerned, I'd bet a toe that more people are happy with Ryse than with any other launch title.

Avatar image for PannicAtack
#29 Posted by PannicAtack (21040 posts) -

@padaporra: I have substantial doubts that the story is any good.

I'll watch a playthrough sometime.

Avatar image for Puckhog04
#30 Posted by Puckhog04 (22814 posts) -

This is sad. Really, the game is terrible. Just accept it and move on. If you enjoy it in your own personal opinion then great but don't contest reviews or claim "bias" on a site. Grow up.

Avatar image for KarateeeChop
#31 Posted by KarateeeChop (4666 posts) -

it's a solid 8.5 from what i've played. very good game.

Avatar image for shawn30
#32 Posted by shawn30 (4390 posts) -

@Heil68 said:

The first part to the healing process is to accept the flop, then and only then can the healing begin

Lol, well here on systems wars Ryse is a flop. But as I have the actual game, no way in the world is it a 4. Its a solid 8 with a ten in graphics. So yeah, here its a flop. But Im not surprised at all its getting good reviews from people who bought the game. And no way is it 4 damn hours. 8 to 10 at least.

Avatar image for Phazevariance
#33 Posted by Phazevariance (12141 posts) -

@groowagon said:

dumbasses calling Ryse masterpiece are ruining game industry. people who are willing to pay full price from shit are sending wrong message to publishers. they will just make more shit games.

i think people just have hard time admitting they wasted $60 to a crappy game and they are praising it for nothing.

You mad bro?

Avatar image for Dreams-Visions
#34 Edited by Dreams-Visions (26578 posts) -

It's possible to like a bad game. That's fine. I really loved some bad games last gen too. I loved Kameo and Chromehounds, for example. But I knew they were critically bad games and clearly understood why. The flaws and weaknesses were always apparent...but I simply played in spite of them.

As such, there's no need to bash someone's personal taste. Anyone saying Ryse is a "good" game is damn liar, as "good" and "bad" are objective commentaries. It's an objectively bad game just as Chromehounds was. Anyone saying they "like" Ryse is expressing a personal, subjective opinion to which everyone is entitled to. Amazon reviews should be accepted from the perspective of whether or not some people are enjoying their time with the game in spite of its many flaws, and that YOU may enjoy it too. But that doesn't mean it's objectively a good game.

Avatar image for Heil68
#35 Posted by Heil68 (57720 posts) -

@shawn30 said:

@Heil68 said:

The first part to the healing process is to accept the flop, then and only then can the healing begin

Lol, well here on systems wars Ryse is a flop. But as I have the actual game, no way in the world is it a 4. Its a solid 8 with a ten in graphics. So yeah, here its a flop. But Im not surprised at all its getting good reviews from people who bought the game. And no way is it 4 damn hours. 8 to 10 at least.

So GS didn't actually play the game? ;) It sounds like you are struggling with the flop Sean, let it go and know that Knack=Ryse and all will be well. I'm playing Knack too btw and by golly I'm having fun!

Avatar image for BluRayHiDef
#36 Edited by BluRayHiDef (10839 posts) -

@PhazonBlazer said:

I played it, graphics are great. Gameplay sucks.

I love your signature. I can't wait until inFamous: Second Son is released.

Avatar image for tdkmillsy
#37 Edited by tdkmillsy (2558 posts) -

I'm on the hunt for my next games and usually go of reviews as a good guide, but all the troll and fanboy reviews make it really hard to work out what to get yet. Ryse, Dead rising, cod or battlefield all have wide ranging reviews it's hard to tell which is legit.

Avatar image for MonsieurX
#38 Posted by MonsieurX (36760 posts) -

I don't remember the last time people used amazon reviews here

Avatar image for shawn30
#39 Posted by shawn30 (4390 posts) -

@Heil68 said:

@shawn30 said:

@Heil68 said:

The first part to the healing process is to accept the flop, then and only then can the healing begin

Lol, well here on systems wars Ryse is a flop. But as I have the actual game, no way in the world is it a 4. Its a solid 8 with a ten in graphics. So yeah, here its a flop. But Im not surprised at all its getting good reviews from people who bought the game. And no way is it 4 damn hours. 8 to 10 at least.

So GS didn't actually play the game? ;) It sounds like you are struggling with the flop Sean, let it go and know that Knack=Ryse and all will be well. I'm playing Knack too btw and by golly I'm having fun!

Silly Hell :)
GS played the game and obviously the reviewer just didn't like any of it. Shit happens, lol. But I'm honestly having a ball with the game and its multiplayer. My inner Spartacus fan is in love with it.

Avatar image for Puckhog04
#40 Edited by Puckhog04 (22814 posts) -

@MonsieurX said:

I don't remember the last time people used amazon reviews here

Desperate times call for desperate measures I suppose.

Avatar image for Heil68
#41 Posted by Heil68 (57720 posts) -

@shawn30 said:

@Heil68 said:

@shawn30 said:

@Heil68 said:

The first part to the healing process is to accept the flop, then and only then can the healing begin

Lol, well here on systems wars Ryse is a flop. But as I have the actual game, no way in the world is it a 4. Its a solid 8 with a ten in graphics. So yeah, here its a flop. But Im not surprised at all its getting good reviews from people who bought the game. And no way is it 4 damn hours. 8 to 10 at least.

So GS didn't actually play the game? ;) It sounds like you are struggling with the flop Sean, let it go and know that Knack=Ryse and all will be well. I'm playing Knack too btw and by golly I'm having fun!

Silly Hell :)

GS played the game and obviously the reviewer just didn't like any of it. Shit happens, lol. But I'm honestly having a ball with the game and its multiplayer. My inner Spartacus fan is in love with it.

Maybe we'll be playing it together in the very near future. ;)

Avatar image for YD_11
#42 Edited by YD_11 (1867 posts) -

I'm on the last level currently but I am pretty impressed with it myself. If you play on normal or easy it will not offer much resistance. I've been playing on the hardest available as the true hardest difficulty is locked until you beat it it looks like.

If you like assassins creed combat or batman this will be fun for you. And you don't have to do the executions but they can truly help you in a pinch to heal yourself a little.

its up to the gamer as to how fun it will be is the point. I play on hard and have fun mixing up my attacks with heavy and light and some power ups now and then and it's well worth it to me.

plus it is downright gorgeous with a story that gets more compelling as you go.

ultimately I would have given it a 7 at least as i haven't tried the MP yet

Avatar image for cheesie253
#43 Posted by cheesie253 (1010 posts) -

@shawn30:

I would give it a 10 for graphics too but overall I would say maybe.. Maybe a 7.

The gameplay is simple and repetitive. Not much more than a button masher with great graphics. Story so far is good. Better than a lot of other games I've played and voice acting is great.

Also don't think its a 8-10 hr game. With how far I am now I'm thinking I will finish in the 5 or 6 hr mark. Overall a fun game but in my opinion much better than a 4.

I would have brought home Lego Marvel instead launch night but the shipment wasnt in yet.

Avatar image for cainetao11
#44 Posted by cainetao11 (32487 posts) -

@Newhopes said:

From what I've seen and the short period I play it it's a fun game but I can see it getting very repetitive after a few hours.

After a few hours? I thought it only lasted a few hours!

Avatar image for applefan1991
#45 Posted by applefan1991 (3388 posts) -

I'm glad people are enjoying it. But I find it funny when Cows use metacritic and get attacked by Lems and now Lems are using Amazon user reviews for DC now. It's kinda funny lol

Avatar image for Puckhog04
#46 Posted by Puckhog04 (22814 posts) -

It sorta reminds me of Heavenly Sword at the PS3 launch (don't remember if it was exactly a launch title...but it was close). Beautiful graphics and short game. Only real difference was Heavenly Sword had fantastic gameplay.

Avatar image for Gue1
#47 Posted by Gue1 (12171 posts) -

both Killzone and Knack have higher scores than Ryse, so what's your point TC? Scrapping the barrel aren't we? XD

Avatar image for Gaming-Planet
#48 Posted by Gaming-Planet (18646 posts) -

It's true when they say Xbox users are casuals.

Avatar image for GravityX
#49 Edited by GravityX (865 posts) -

E3 really tainted the game. But I agree, a 4 should be reserved for broken games. Knack and Ryse deserve better.

Not even Gameinformer would score as low as 4 and the said dialing a phone number was more fun.

The reviewers for Knack and Ryse should be talked to and written up for such horrible reviews and doing a disservice. to gamers.

Avatar image for _Matt_
#50 Posted by _Matt_ (10433 posts) -

@GravityX said:

E3 really tainted the game. But I agree, a 4 should be reserved for broken games. Knack and Ryse deserve better.

Not even Gameinformer would score as low as 4 and the said dialing a phone number was more fun.

The reviewers for Knack and Ryse should be talked to and written up for such horrible reviews and doung a deservice to gamers.

Agreed.

Actually, I think they were both reviewed by McShea, hence why they got such low scores. I think if either were reviewed by anyone else, they would have maybe got 6 each?