Metacritic: Xbox had no highly rated exclusives in 2018

Avatar image for XVision84
#1 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

Source: https://gamerant.com/metacritic-best-xbox-one-exclusives-2018/

I'm sorry system warriors, console exclusives aren't exclusives. PC is a platform in the competition.

Avatar image for davillain-
#2 Posted by DaVillain- (34925 posts) -

To be fair, at least Forza Horizon 4 got some solid hits in Metacritic but yeah, this isn't saying much but it's better then nothing right?

Even Phil Spencer admitted "we could do better" during VGA and really, he wasn't trying to sway his way out of it, MS really didn't deliver with Sea of Thieves & State of Decay 2 despite that game was alot better then Sea of Thieves.

Avatar image for subspecies
#3 Posted by Subspecies (137 posts) -

Lems will still defend it.

Avatar image for davillain-
#4 Posted by DaVillain- (34925 posts) -

@subspecies said:

Lems will still defend it.

Which is sad indeed.

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#5 Posted by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

That's weird! I just saw an article about how Forza Horizon 4 finished in the top 5 for Meta Critic scores for last year.

Maybe Cows don't consider Racing Games "Games" because they are lucky to get 2 for the whole generation and when they do they suck.

Avatar image for XVision84
#6 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@davillain- said:

To be fair, at least Forza Horizon 4 got some solid hits in Metacritic but yeah, this isn't saying much but it's better then nothing right?

Even Phil Spencer admitted "we could do better" during VGA and really, he wasn't trying to sway his way out of it, MS really didn't deliver with Sea of Thieves & State of Decay 2 despite that game was alot better then Sea of Thieves.

Phil Spencer has done a good job in picking up the Xbox One after Mattrick left. Really hope they blow it out of the water this E3.

Avatar image for XVision84
#7 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@the-a-baum said:

That's weird! I just saw an article about how Forza Horizon 4 finished in the top 5 for Meta Critic scores for last year.

Maybe Cows don't consider Racing Games "Games" because they are lucky to get 2 for the whole generation and when they do they suck.

Forza Horizon 4 is on PC :)

Avatar image for BenjaminBanklin
#8 Posted by BenjaminBanklin (4091 posts) -
@the-a-baum said:

That's weird! I just saw an article about how Forza Horizon 4 finished in the top 5 for Meta Critic scores for last year.

Maybe Cows don't consider Racing Games "Games" because they are lucky to get 2 for the whole generation and when they do they suck.

At least Sony isn't so pathetic that the only good games it has are from a dying niche genre. And they're overrated out of pity because the gaming media knows that Xbox's output is sad. Forza's AI is trash. If it weren't for the UK, Forza games wouldn't even have an audience.

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#9 Posted by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@XVision84 said:
@the-a-baum said:

That's weird! I just saw an article about how Forza Horizon 4 finished in the top 5 for Meta Critic scores for last year.

Maybe Cows don't consider Racing Games "Games" because they are lucky to get 2 for the whole generation and when they do they suck.

Forza Horizon 4 is on PC :)

That's great because Xbox and Microsoft makes both! You playing on Linux or Mac?

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#10 Posted by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@BenjaminBanklin said:
@the-a-baum said:

That's weird! I just saw an article about how Forza Horizon 4 finished in the top 5 for Meta Critic scores for last year.

Maybe Cows don't consider Racing Games "Games" because they are lucky to get 2 for the whole generation and when they do they suck.

At least Sony isn't so pathetic that the only good games it has are from a dying niche genre. And they're overrated out of pity because the gaming media knows that Xbox's output is sad. Forza's AI is trash. If it weren't for the UK, Forza games wouldn't even have an audience.

Typical. It's only dying because you don't have it or one in general.

Avatar image for BenjaminBanklin
#11 Posted by BenjaminBanklin (4091 posts) -
@the-a-baum said:

Typical. It's only dying because you don't have it or one in general.

I played FH4. It's good, but in the end it's just a racing game. You're either on the road or off, doing challenges and races and buying crap with in-game currency. Repeat cycle. There's a reason that no one wants to give a racing game overall GotY. They're limited as hell. There's nothing else this genre can do to invigorate itself.

I didn't even touch GTS. Racing games can be solid, but they're as dull as dishwater now.

Avatar image for XVision84
#12 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

@the-a-baum: It's a competing system with its own pros/cons.

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#13 Posted by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@BenjaminBanklin said:
@the-a-baum said:

Typical. It's only dying because you don't have it or one in general.

I played FH4. It's good, but in the end it's just a racing game. You're either on the road or off, doing challenges and races and buying crap with in-game currency. Repeat cycle. There's a reason that no one wants to give a racing game overall GotY. They're limited as hell. There's nothing else this genre can do to invigorate itself.

I didn't even touch GTS. Racing games can be solid, but they're as dull as dishwater now.

Fair enough. I have heard others say things about all the other top rated games as well. Spiderman just being a more up to date Spiderman game but similar to the the ones before, Red Dead 2 being too slow at times, God of War copying too much of other games and troll combat fatigue(But it made some guy a better father), etc we could go on.

Xbox does not have a MLB game but hard to argue there is not a market for it. Same with Racing. There are even more of Die hards for racing and Xbox is just doing it best lately. No reason to be mad.

I don't normally go out of my way for these games but really am loving the Horizon series. They are just fun and not a sim.

I like when we can talk like normal gamers.

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#14 Edited by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

@the-a-baum: It's a competing system with its own pros/cons.

Sorry to break it to you but MS probably made more $ off your PC then they would if you bought an Xbox. And even more by you playing games on it.

Avatar image for PCgameruk
#15 Posted by PCgameruk (2240 posts) -

Multi-platform games are better than the exclusives on any platform.

Avatar image for Random_Matt
#16 Posted by Random_Matt (3776 posts) -

Cannot say I really care.

Avatar image for XVision84
#17 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

@the-a-baum: Why would that bother me? I have nothing against Microsoft.

Avatar image for XVision84
#18 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

@PCgameruk: I disagree with that, although I enjoy multiplats, God of War and Spiderman were the most fun I had all year in gaming.

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#19 Posted by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

@the-a-baum: Why would that bother me? I have nothing against Microsoft.

Maybe I was misinterpreting you, but I thought you made it (Smugly) seem there is no reason to patronize (That means be a consumer of)MS.

Avatar image for Sevenizz
#20 Posted by Sevenizz (3136 posts) -

Still better than the alternatives. The ps4 is littered with japanese shovelware, movie games, and lacklustre online, the Switch is a WiiU port machine with little decent 3rd party support, and PC requires heavy configuration to play basic games.

No thanks, I’ll stick with Xbox. It’s the best for my gaming needs!

Avatar image for the-a-baum
#21 Edited by The-A-Baum (1317 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

@PCgameruk: I disagree with that, although I enjoy multiplats, God of War and Spiderman were the most fun I had all year in gaming.

I am guessing this is aimed at me. Glad you enjoyed them some don't . Some really like Forza Horizon 4 some don't does not make it more or less a great game.

this year is going to be sparse for Sony and it happens to all consoles. Stop acting like Xbox has no games is all I am saying.

Sony has all time 4 GOTY and Xbox has 2. So hardly running away with anything.

Avatar image for neutrinoworks
#22 Posted by NeutrinoWorks (75 posts) -

Neither did PC

Avatar image for robert_sparkes
#23 Posted by robert_sparkes (2561 posts) -

Hoping for a better year with gears 5 and possibly the new project from ninja theory. It certainly can't get any worse.

Avatar image for navyguy21
#24 Posted by navyguy21 (15199 posts) -

I dont understand the logic.

If Microsoft is releasing their own games on PC, they clearly dont care if the games are exclusive to the console.

I dont expect that to change, even with the NextBox.

Games being on PC shouldnt exclude them for being included with Xbox.

Xbox/PC games published by MS are still lacking in both quality and quantity, but excluding them just because they are on PC is asinine.

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#25 Posted by lundy86_4 (51999 posts) -

Why is this still news-worthy? MS have moved away from full system-exclusives with PA. There will literally be minimal to zero exclusives going forward...

Avatar image for boxrekt
#26 Posted by BoxRekt (787 posts) -

Going by my Dreams is Sony's Crackdown 3 thread, xbox fans believe Crackdown 3 will be a better game than Dreams and are excited to play that, so MS fans are expecting 2019 to start off better than 2018 ended.

Avatar image for davillain-
#27 Posted by DaVillain- (34925 posts) -

@XVision84 said:
@davillain- said:

To be fair, at least Forza Horizon 4 got some solid hits in Metacritic but yeah, this isn't saying much but it's better then nothing right?

Even Phil Spencer admitted "we could do better" during VGA and really, he wasn't trying to sway his way out of it, MS really didn't deliver with Sea of Thieves & State of Decay 2 despite that game was alot better then Sea of Thieves.

Phil Spencer has done a good job in picking up the Xbox One after Mattrick left. Really hope they blow it out of the water this E3.

For Phil Spencer's sake, let's hope he surprise everyone what Xbox Scarlet can deliver.

Avatar image for XVision84
#28 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@the-a-baum said:
@XVision84 said:

@the-a-baum: Why would that bother me? I have nothing against Microsoft.

Maybe I was misinterpreting you, but I thought you made it (Smugly) seem there is no reason to patronize (That means be a consumer of)MS.

Nope, just explaining why I don't think Forza Horizon 4 counts as an exclusive.

Avatar image for XVision84
#29 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@the-a-baum said:
@XVision84 said:

@PCgameruk: I disagree with that, although I enjoy multiplats, God of War and Spiderman were the most fun I had all year in gaming.

I am guessing this is aimed at me. Glad you enjoyed them some don't . Some really like Forza Horizon 4 some don't does not make it more or less a great game.

this year is going to be sparse for Sony and it happens to all consoles. Stop acting like Xbox has no games is all I am saying.

Sony has all time 4 GOTY and Xbox has 2. So hardly running away with anything.

If it was aimed at you, then I would have just quoted you or mentioned you. He said multiplats were better than exclusives, I said that I preferred the exclusives this year. It has nothing to do with you.

I never said Xbox has no games, I put in the OP that Xbox didn't have any exclusives in 2018. I don't see 2019 as sparse for Sony because I'm looking forward to Ghost of Tsushima, The Last of Us 2, and Death Stranding (if they come out this year).

If you like your Xbox One then all the power to you, it's just that I (alongside other media outlets, as the source suggests) don't think it's a good look for Xbox consoles that they don't have a truly exclusive selling point at the moment.

Avatar image for XVision84
#30 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

@navyguy21: @navyguy21: It does seem like Microsoft has stopped caring about it, but that doesn't mean that it doesn't influence consumers as a whole. I would argue their decision does carry over weight with it, at least in the transition period where people expect exclusives from Xbox consoles. It isn't breaking news, I agree with you, but it's worth mentioning seeing as this is System Wars and Metacritic's yearly review is relevant here. I am curious what they'll do with the console line because I don't think they'll just make mini-PC's, they might add some other incentives/innovation with Xbox Scarlet.

Avatar image for kali-b1rd
#31 Posted by Kali-B1rd (1857 posts) -
@Sevenizz said:

Still better than the alternatives. The ps4 is littered with japanese shovelware, movie games, and lacklustre online, the Switch is a WiiU port machine with little decent 3rd party support, and PC requires heavy configuration to play basic games.

No thanks, I’ll stick with Xbox. It’s the best for my gaming needs!

lmao, you were struggling for content here aye?

Heavy configuration!

Purchase Game

Download Game

Run Game

Avatar image for i_p_daily
#32 Posted by I_P_Daily (10713 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

Source: https://gamerant.com/metacritic-best-xbox-one-exclusives-2018/

I'm sorry system warriors, console exclusives aren't exclusives. PC is a platform in the competition.

Did you just come out of a coma or come out from under your rock?

MS hasn't had exclusives for a while now so your thread is pointless, having said that I would rather play FH4 on my X than watch anything Sony has produced last year.

Avatar image for Pedro
#33 Posted by Pedro (33339 posts) -

@lundy86_4 said:

Why is this still news-worthy? MS have moved away from full system-exclusives with PA. There will literally be minimal to zero exclusives going forward...

This has been the case for over a year going on two years yet people still act as if its news and act as if its going to change.

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#34 Posted by lundy86_4 (51999 posts) -

@Pedro said:
@lundy86_4 said:

Why is this still news-worthy? MS have moved away from full system-exclusives with PA. There will literally be minimal to zero exclusives going forward...

This has been the case for over a year going on two years yet people still act as if its news and act as if its going to change.

It's genuinely mind-boggling. I guess factions need their "wins."

Avatar image for XVision84
#35 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@i_p_daily said:
@XVision84 said:

Source: https://gamerant.com/metacritic-best-xbox-one-exclusives-2018/

I'm sorry system warriors, console exclusives aren't exclusives. PC is a platform in the competition.

Did you just come out of a coma or come out from under your rock?

MS hasn't had exclusives for a while now so your thread is pointless, having said that I would rather play FH4 on my X than watch anything Sony has produced last year.

That must have been one hell of a coma/rock for me to be posting on the internet all this time ;).

My thread isn't pointless, it's pointing out that Metacritic states that Xbox didn't have any highly rated exclusives in 2018. An argument can be made that it isn't surprising, but I don't see anywhere in the news saying that's a prerequisite for a thread :).

Also why are you bringing up Sony? I haven't defended them nor did I say I was a Sony fan.

Avatar image for XVision84
#36 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@lundy86_4 said:
@Pedro said:
@lundy86_4 said:

Why is this still news-worthy? MS have moved away from full system-exclusives with PA. There will literally be minimal to zero exclusives going forward...

This has been the case for over a year going on two years yet people still act as if its news and act as if its going to change.

It's genuinely mind-boggling. I guess factions need their "wins."

It shouldn't be mind boggling, you've been on here long enough to know that people like to argue over systems.

Avatar image for Sevenizz
#37 Posted by Sevenizz (3136 posts) -

@kali-b1rd: If you don’t understand what I meant, why reply with that rubbish?

Obviously I was referring to the consultant upgrading PC gaming requires in order to play the most current of games.

Avatar image for Pedro
#38 Posted by Pedro (33339 posts) -

This thread is equivalent to saying "Despite the success of God of War, it received no accolades for its multiplayer features."

Avatar image for XVision84
#39 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@Pedro said:

This thread is equivalent to saying "Despite the success of God of War, it received no accolades for its multiplayer features."

I'm sorry Pedro, I don't see the connection. However, Xbox is similar to God of War in one way: Just like God of War has no multiplayer mode, Xbox has no high scoring exclusives in 2018.

Avatar image for i_p_daily
#40 Posted by I_P_Daily (10713 posts) -

@XVision84 said:
@i_p_daily said:
@XVision84 said:

Source: https://gamerant.com/metacritic-best-xbox-one-exclusives-2018/

I'm sorry system warriors, console exclusives aren't exclusives. PC is a platform in the competition.

Did you just come out of a coma or come out from under your rock?

MS hasn't had exclusives for a while now so your thread is pointless, having said that I would rather play FH4 on my X than watch anything Sony has produced last year.

That must have been one hell of a coma/rock for me to be posting on the internet all this time ;).

My thread isn't pointless, it's pointing out that Metacritic states that Xbox didn't have any highly rated exclusives in 2018. An argument can be made that it isn't surprising, but I don't see anywhere in the news saying that's a prerequisite for a thread :).

Also why are you bringing up Sony? I haven't defended them nor did I say I was a Sony fan.

Xbox doesn't have exclusives and hasn't for some time where as you're acting like this is a new thing, you can't bring in Metashitic stating that there hasn't been a highly rated exclusive when exclusives don't exist.

Are you saying you're not a Sony fan?

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#41 Edited by lundy86_4 (51999 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

It shouldn't be mind boggling, you've been on here long enough to know that people like to argue over systems.

Yup. Repeating something ad nauseam is something in which this board also excels. The Xbox has not received an exclusive in quite a while, nor will it receive any in the future... I'm not sure why we need to tread water.

Avatar image for X_CAPCOM_X
#42 Posted by X_CAPCOM_X (8405 posts) -

Uh oh are the quality of the threads on gamespot in need of new standards? @XVision84

@Sevenizz said:

@kali-b1rd: If you don’t understand what I meant, why reply with that rubbish?

Obviously I was referring to the consultant upgrading PC gaming requires in order to play the most current of games.

I won't have to update my PC for years. More than a console generation. I will still do it at an earlier time point though.

Avatar image for Archangel3371
#43 Posted by Archangel3371 (27143 posts) -

Oh noes! How ever am I going to sleep at night?

Spoiler: Just fine.

Avatar image for Pedro
#44 Posted by Pedro (33339 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

I'm sorry Pedro, I don't see the connection. However, Xbox is similar to God of War in one way: Just like God of War has no multiplayer mode, Xbox has no high scoring exclusives in 2018.

It can't have high scoring exclusives because they don't make exclusives since 2017. Thus the reason this thread is dumb. You don't point out the obvious as a new discovery hence the reason I used God of War lack of multiplayer as an example. If someone made a thread stating "God of War received no awards for multiplayer in 2018", that thread would be a dumb thread much like this.

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#45 Posted by lundy86_4 (51999 posts) -

@Sevenizz said:

@kali-b1rd: If you don’t understand what I meant, why reply with that rubbish?

Obviously I was referring to the consultant upgrading PC gaming requires in order to play the most current of games.

How often must you upgrade to achieve a baseline of gameplay/graphics quality?

Avatar image for XVision84
#46 Posted by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@i_p_daily said:
@XVision84 said:
@i_p_daily said:
@XVision84 said:

Source: https://gamerant.com/metacritic-best-xbox-one-exclusives-2018/

I'm sorry system warriors, console exclusives aren't exclusives. PC is a platform in the competition.

Did you just come out of a coma or come out from under your rock?

MS hasn't had exclusives for a while now so your thread is pointless, having said that I would rather play FH4 on my X than watch anything Sony has produced last year.

That must have been one hell of a coma/rock for me to be posting on the internet all this time ;).

My thread isn't pointless, it's pointing out that Metacritic states that Xbox didn't have any highly rated exclusives in 2018. An argument can be made that it isn't surprising, but I don't see anywhere in the news saying that's a prerequisite for a thread :).

Also why are you bringing up Sony? I haven't defended them nor did I say I was a Sony fan.

Xbox doesn't have exclusives and hasn't for some time where as you're acting like this is a new thing, you can't bring in Metashitic stating that there hasn't been a highly rated exclusive when exclusives don't exist.

Are you saying you're not a Sony fan?

How am I acting like it's a new thing if I'm openly admitting this isn't surprising news?

I'm a fan insofar as they make the games I like from their first party studios. I also have a level of trust with Sony because they've done a good job so far since PS1 days. I'm not a fanboy or Sony apologist though, if they do something wrong I'll call them out on it. Me pointing out something Microsoft is doing has nothing to do with Sony.

Avatar image for XVision84
#47 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -

@X_CAPCOM_X: The next gen is coming soon, I'm sure the quality of threads will pick up afterwards. I can't promise mine will though, we'll see :P. I'll try, it'll be my new years resolution.

Avatar image for XVision84
#48 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@Pedro said:
@XVision84 said:

I'm sorry Pedro, I don't see the connection. However, Xbox is similar to God of War in one way: Just like God of War has no multiplayer mode, Xbox has no high scoring exclusives in 2018.

It can't have high scoring exclusives because they don't make exclusives since 2017. Thus the reason this thread is dumb. You don't point out the obvious as a new discovery hence the reason I used God of War lack of multiplayer as an example. If someone made a thread stating "God of War received no awards for multiplayer in 2018", that thread would be a dumb thread much like this.

Well some people argue that Forza Horizon 4 or Crackdown are exclusives despite also launching on PC. I do agree with you though, I don't know why you think I'm pointing this out as a new discovery. This entire time I've openly admitted it's unsurprising but relevant to System Wars.

Avatar image for XVision84
#49 Edited by XVision84 (15311 posts) -
@lundy86_4 said:
@XVision84 said:

It shouldn't be mind boggling, you've been on here long enough to know that people like to argue over systems.

Yup. Repeating something ad nauseam is something in which this board also excels. The Xbox has not received an exclusive in quite a while, nor will it receive any in the future... I'm not sure why we need to tread water.

No defense, I plead guilty :(.

Avatar image for lundy86_4
#50 Posted by lundy86_4 (51999 posts) -

@XVision84 said:

No defense, I plead guilty :(.

We all do it, man. SW is f*cked lol.