@Salt_The_Fries said:
Eurogamer said X1 d-pad is the best dpad for brawlers ever created.
That is not true by a long-shot after playing with it for hours and Killer Instinct. I can understand since you don't own an Xbone it's possible hyperbolic Xbox related quotes like that above may stick with you as you wait for Xbone to ship in your country, but as an Xbone owner and avid fighting gamer, let me give you my actual experience with the Xbone dpad. (This effort on my part regarding the Dpad may not matter because in all the years I've known you, you aren't actually a huge Dpad/fighting gamer, but still I'll leave this post for those that are heavy 2D/Fighting gamers considering Xbone Dpad gameplay since apparently Eurogamer is making terrible, exaggerated claims that need to be straightened out.)
BTW: Do you have a link to that article where that quote is made? I would like to read that for myself because it's quite shocking, although with gaming journalism today, maybe it's not so shocking. I would want to look at the writer's Killer Instinct credentials to verify they put in time with the game, but even then, they may be using the analog stick or a fighting joystick.
If I just looked at the Xbone dpad, I would say it was a good dpad definitely. It looked like a huge improvement...But after extensive playtesting the Dpad, there is no way I would qualify that statement. I would want to talk with whoever made that ridiculous statement because I have a feeling I put in more time in Killer Instinct than they ever did.
The problems with the Dpad are revealed spending hours with Killer Instinct by any gamer that has tested a variety of dpads since NES. The problem with the new Dpad is the diagonal motions don't always register. This is crucial for many moves in the game. When it works, it's wonderful, but when it doesn't that means you get a kick in the face. It's not good, but it's not a terrible dpad either. There is huge room for improvement. I find myself using the analog stick lately due to the Xbone's dpad inconsistencies, which troubles me since analog sticks don't provide precise movements. You have to pick your poison.
Here's a video on the Xbone Dpad problems made by a hardcore Xbox fan that reveals the problem many have with the new Xbone Dpad:
I'm sure some one will quote and argue, but I'll gladly play Killer Instinct with them and show them while dismantling them in the game.
The Dpad is an improvement over the Xbox and 360 imo, but the new dpad has it's faults.
Log in to comment