It's Official : PS3 NCAA 08 = X360 NCAA 08

so what's the excuse for x360 to score the same as the PS3 version despite running double the speed? is it:

a) EA managed to get the PS3 version to run @ 60FPS.

b) It's teh new GS score system

c) X360 has higher standards.

d) other

* puts "according to GS" flame shield *

look at ign score

the 360 scored much better then the ps3 version.

much better.

look at ign score

the 360 scored much better then the ps3 version.

much better.

ginglejangle

what do you think of the new scoring system? is it more / less informative for consumers to make a purchasing decision?

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

look at ign score

the 360 scored much better then the ps3 version.

much better.

Mystery_Writer

what do you think of the new scoring system? is it more / less informative for consumers to make a purchasing decision?

[QUOTE="ginglejangle"]

look at ign score

the 360 scored much better then the ps3 version.

much better.

Mystery_Writer

what do you think of the new scoring system? is it more / less informative for consumers to make a purchasing decision?

I played the ps3 version of it as well and thought it was exacltly the same.

so yea the review was fine.

the only difference they mention between the two versions is "Thanks to a faster, smoother frame rate and better-looking player shadows, the 360 version of the game gets the nod over the PS3, which struggles to run smoothly even at half the frame rate."CaseyWegner

Yep, was about to use the same quote.

Basically with the new review system being less flexible and more general a few points of difference won't be reflected in the final score.

the only difference they mention between the two versions is "Thanks to a faster, smoother frame rate and better-looking player shadows, the 360 version of the game gets the nod over the PS3, which struggles to run smoothly even at half the frame rate."CaseyWegner

I was all for the new review system.....but stuff like this...as well as other multiplats in which they barely even compare the two versions (The Bigs and The Darkness) makes me think that the new Review System is Weaksauce and is too darn soft.

The New GS Rating system is absolutely Terrible. Completely Inferior.

the only difference they mention between the two versions is "Thanks to a faster, smoother frame rate and better-looking player shadows, the 360 version of the game gets the nod over the PS3, which struggles to run smoothly even at half the frame rate."CaseyWegner

Just end the thread now, thank you Casey.