Fun list to check through... Nintendo owns the top 10 and crappy games like uncharted fell mightily... Not sure I agree with #1, but I also recognize it's a great game. Portal 2 at #3 is also an incredible pick. P2 is as perfect a video game as I've played in the medium.
Highest scoring modern game is Botw (because it's the best open world game ever made... Ign fact.
Only one uncharted game on the list... It is officially a bottom 50 franchise. Ign fact. (lol)
Bioshock is better than Witcher 3 (Ign fact)
Also, Halo Combat evolved is Ign factually better than both minecraft and the legend of Zelda Ocarina of time.
These are Ign facts and this matter is settled.