I respect them as a company, I think they make high quality games. I also admire their passion for games, and the fact that they give so much content and put so much detail into them. But if I were to go by the hype alone, I would say they are overrated. I played Witcher 3 GOTY this past year, and the combat was just not satisfying for me. I think the series is more known for the story, writing, and characters, than the actual gameplay. And it also helped that it's based on a popular book. I think if Cyberpunk is a success, than we can talk about them being the premiere RPG maker. But for now, all they've down is Witcher, and so I'll hold my judgement.
What about you, SW? Is CD Project Red overrated, underrated, or just right?