Games I love to go back and replay include Portal 2, Gears 3, Dead Space 2, and Arkham City, which I didn't like as much as Arkham Asylum at first, then I went back and watched old 90s Batman animated series and then played Arkham City again and had much greater appreciation for the wealth of the universe they utilized, whereas I only played Asylum with minimal exposure to franchise mainly through films.
It's a toss-up right now between Dead Space 2 and Arkham Knight, both were substantial improvements over the original. I lean on greater appreciation for Dead Space though because series is over. Then again I still love Arkham games, even Knight, despite the gaming universe being done with it since Origins.
I didn't care for Deus Ex, about only redeeming quality is its cyberpunk setting, but as an RPG I hated main character, found universe was too constrained, thought them promoting choice was misleading as game discourages anything that isn't non-lethal stealth, and choice amounts to a Fable style end of game choice ending. I understand people had great appreciation for original game(s) and I have to think that's what carried this game's praise, because I found it pretty unremarkable by itself.
Skyrim is another I did not like nearly as much as everyone else. I love TES games, even the much hated Oblivion, Skyrim was a great improvement on mechanics but the game lacked the series signature quest content that I loved, instead they relied on cookie cutter auto-generated quests. I miss the well crafted quests with variable ways of accomplishing them that are fun to explore, didn't feel we has that with Skyrim. Haven't bothered with modern definitive edition yet, though picked it up while back for $10, hoping any new content makes me change my mind.
No other game not listed comes to mind, except maybe Bulletstorm, loved it, but not a GOTY contender IMO.
Log in to comment