Should Kurt Warner make the HOF?

I know we have had this topic before, but it is an interesting subject, so let's continue. Its a tough call. There was that big gap of nothing in between the Ram and Cardinal years. But the three best performances in Super Bowl history really stick out. When you put that together with how he achieved all of the success and his humble beginnings, I have to say yes, he is HOF material.

I agree. He always was as clutch as can possibly be when his team had a chance.

i agree..but even though i think he should be in the hof he just doesnt have the rings so it may take him awhile to get in.

Only one word is needed to answer this question... "Duh"flowersjf

Agreed. He might not be a first ballot entrant but he definitely deserves a spot in the HOF.

i agree..but even though i think he should be in the hof he just doesnt have the rings so it may take him awhile to get in.

MURDA_B

this

Yeah couple plays here and there he'd have 3 rings and a lock for HOF

Not even a question in my book. YES

He definitely should get in. He isn't first ballot though.

I dont think we should we defy a hof by the rings he got. If So, Dan Marino and Charles Barkely arent hofs.PSP107

Here we go again.

I think he deserves to be. But I dont think he will be a first time ballot inductee but I do think he will get in.

How is this a "tough call?" I don't accept your premise. Warner is easily a Hall of Famer. I'm not sure that this is even debatable.

YES! Of course he should

[QUOTE="PSP107"]I dont think we should we defy a hof by the rings he got. If So, Dan Marino and Charles Barkely arent hofs.Darth_Revan_666

Here we go again.

i agree..but even though i think he should be in the hof he just doesnt have the rings so it may take him awhile to get in.

MURDA_B

in fact in many respects he is more of a HOF'er than my favourite team's QB .... the Colts Peyton Manning ....

in fact in many respects he is more of a HOF'er than my favourite team's QB .... the Colts Peyton Manning ....

[QUOTE="sixringz1"][QUOTE="DeViLzzz"]

in fact in many respects he is more of a HOF'er than my favourite team's QB .... the Colts Peyton Manning ....

monkeytoes61

Umitas was kind of overrated, Elway was labbeled a choker by people of your kind at the stage of the career Manning is in right now and Graham played in a completely different era.

[QUOTE="monkeytoes61"][QUOTE="sixringz1"] That is just absurd. Manning has more yds, wins, completions, touchdowns, mvp's, etc. They have the same amount of SB rings. When it's all said and done people will argue whether Manning is the best qb ever, and although Warner definitely deserves to be in the hall of fame, NOBODY will ever argue that for himDarth_Revan_666

Umitas was kind of overrated, Elway was labbeled a choker by people of your kind at the stage of the career Manning is in right now and Graham played in a completely different era.

Assuming longevity is not a requirement for the football HOF, yes.

Assuming longevity is not a requirement for the football HOF, yes.