W00t w00t! The future Hall of Famer bagged his third MVP(tied with only Brett Favre for most, though his were consecutive) today. Peyton received 32 of the 50 votes finishing above Pennington and Turner. Next up: another Super Bowl ring.
Link.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
W00t w00t! The future Hall of Famer bagged his third MVP(tied with only Brett Favre for most, though his were consecutive) today. Peyton received 32 of the 50 votes finishing above Pennington and Turner. Next up: another Super Bowl ring.
Link.
Harrison deserved it more for the season he had but Peyton is a nice guy so I don't mind it going to himJaysonguy
When you said Harrison, I first thought you meant Marvin Harrison and thought you've gone completely off the deep end...then I thought about it for a little while and realized you meant the linebacker from the Steelers. Oops.
And wait, Chad Pennington came in second? :| Sure he had a nice year...but second in MVP voting? Seriously?
[QUOTE="Jaysonguy"]Harrison deserved it more for the season he had but Peyton is a nice guy so I don't mind it going to himJML897
When you said Harrison, I first thought you meant Marvin Harrison and thought you've gone completely off the deep end...then I thought about it for a little while and realized you meant the linebacker from the Steelers. Oops.
And wait, Chad Pennington came in second? :| Sure he had a nice year...but second in MVP voting? Seriously?
Because the Dolphins went from 1-15 a year ago to making the playoffs this year and he was the main reason. Had Pennington not been their QB, I doubt they would have even won 5-6 games this year. He really meant a lot to that team.[QUOTE="senses_fail_06"]tied with only Brett Favre for mostOleg_Huzwog
Jim Brown and Johnny Unitas both have three.
Oh I honestly didn't look the stat up. I was just listening to ESPN on TV...interesting why the other two weren't even mentioned.i really don't think peyton should've gotten the mvp, i think chad pennington should've won it. to me going from 1-15 to 11-5 is more impressive than going from i think 4-4 to 12-4
[QUOTE="Oleg_Huzwog"][QUOTE="senses_fail_06"]tied with only Brett Favre for mostsenses_fail_06
Jim Brown and Johnny Unitas both have three.
Oh I honestly didn't look the stat up. I was just listening to ESPN on TV...interesting why the other two weren't even mentioned.Perhaps they only count awards that came after the AFL-NFL merger?
[QUOTE="senses_fail_06"][QUOTE="Oleg_Huzwog"]Oh I honestly didn't look the stat up. I was just listening to ESPN on TV...interesting why the other two weren't even mentioned.Jim Brown and Johnny Unitas both have three.
Oleg_Huzwog
Perhaps they only count awards that came after the AFL-NFL merger?
Correct. Favre and Manning are the only 2 players to win the NFL AP MVP award 3 times.I really thought this year we were finally not going to see a QB win the award.
"O look guys, Manning threw touchdowns this year! Yea! MVP!"
Such a shallow award.
Peyton Manning is good. He will probably become one of the greatest QBs in history. He deserves it, well done.monkeytoes61I agree.
But he still has that terrible haircut...i really don't think peyton should've gotten the mvp, i think chad pennington should've won it. to me going from 1-15 to 11-5 is more impressive than going from i think 4-4 to 12-4
squitsquat
[QUOTE="Oleg_Huzwog"][QUOTE="senses_fail_06"]Oh I honestly didn't look the stat up. I was just listening to ESPN on TV...interesting why the other two weren't even mentioned.limpbizkit818
Perhaps they only count awards that came after the AFL-NFL merger?
Correct. Favre and Manning are the only 2 players to win the NFL AP MVP award 3 times.I really thought this year we were finally not going to see a QB win the award.
"O look guys, Manning threw touchdowns this year! Yea! MVP!"
Such a shallow award.
Football is a sport where it's extremely hard for someone other than QB to win the MVP and justifiably so. QB is by far the most important position in the NFL. A great QB can impact a team much more than a great player in other positions. A non-QB player would have to play beyond superman caliber football to have the impact of a great QB. MVP is always a QB b/c the most valuable athlete in football is actually always a QB.
Pennington has a running game and defense manning has no running game Has no defense He threw 17 TDs and only 3 picks in that 9 game winning streak. I think Peyton was more impresive.i really don't think peyton should've gotten the mvp, i think chad pennington should've won it. to me going from 1-15 to 11-5 is more impressive than going from i think 4-4 to 12-4
squitsquat
[QUOTE="Oleg_Huzwog"][QUOTE="senses_fail_06"]Oh I honestly didn't look the stat up. I was just listening to ESPN on TV...interesting why the other two weren't even mentioned.limpbizkit818
Perhaps they only count awards that came after the AFL-NFL merger?
Correct. Favre and Manning are the only 2 players to win the NFL AP MVP award 3 times.I really thought this year we were finally not going to see a QB win the award.
"O look guys, Manning threw touchdowns this year! Yea! MVP!"
Such a shallow award.
I'm sorry what? Manning took a team that was next to last on running the football and a hurt O-Line and a banged up defense. If Manning was not playing QB, that team would have never been 12-4 or 9-7.As a Steeler fan I would have loved to see James Harrison win it, but hey congrats to Peyton, he's still one of the best players in the league.ganon546This is where people are missing on Harrison vs Manning. Manning had to do it himself. He had no running game, it was him and his wr's/te. Manning did what most can't do, teams prepared for the pass and couldn't stop, teams like Jags/Ravens couldn't stop his pass but dominated the run. Manning was that offense, he made the right calls to keep the chains moving and beat teams with his mind (short passes for the run and etc). Manning deserves it more because if they didn't have Manning they would have never been a playoff team. Where as Pitts has : Big Ben That back turned out great (moore or something) Hines Ward Holmes Sweed (growing rookie) Miller (one of the better te's) Not to mention your rookie rb with Parker for the future. Your defense is the main example, Harrison could be gone and your defense would still be OMG worthy. Harrison did have a break out season, but that defense is already great. He could have been gone and they most likely would have won. AKA when the Titans didn't have Haynesworth/KVB they still dominated on defense. 1 guy on those 2 defense wouldn't change the results, they help but not MVP worthy. Where as if Manning was not there, to be their to LEAD his team to wins (since the run game was crap.). That's why he won the award.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment