@JimB said:
They never stopped their work on atomic bombs. This was an extremely bad deal fro the west all the signatories could see were dollar signs they were going to make on selling planes and equipment to Iran. again appeasement never works. It didn't work for Neville Chamberlain with Germany. It didn't work for Bill Clinton with North Korea, and it won't work with Iran.
Oh where to begin?
The IAEA, the foremost authority on the matter, has repeatedly deemed Iran in compliance with the nuclear deal. The State Department has also certified the Islamic Republic is holding up its end of the bargain, and a host of experts affirmed these definitive findings.
However, the IAEA did report two instances where Iran barely -- and briefly -- exceeded its supply of a nuclear reactor component known as "heavy water."
But experts said this minor breach posed no practical risk of moving Iran closer to developing a nuclear weapon, and added that such infractions should not be interpreted to mean Iran has not complied with terms of the deal.
Politifact
IAEA says Iran is complying with the deal. LINK
Jim Mattis supports staying in the deal. LINK
The fact is that Iran was complying with the deal and its capability to develop a nuclear weapon became limited in that they couldn't. Withdrawing from the deal has now potentially made it easier for Iran to develop nuclear weapons, if it wants to. Where you're getting your information from, I don't know.
As for Neville Chamberlain, you lack an understanding of history and have the benefit of hindsight. Great Britain was in the midst of its own Great Depression, a lack of support to go to war in the first place, and its military forces depleted. Neville Chamberlain did was he could at the time due to its weakened military and economic depression and sought to buy itself time in order to rebuild its military might. Even then, the British military put out a report that even if they declared war, they would have lost and Germany would still obtain the Czech Republic. LINK
But even then, diplomacy has worked: Egypt-Israeli peace accords, the START treaties between the USSR and USA. Before the nuclear deal, Iran was close to obtaining nuclear weapons despite sanctions. Sanctions did not and will not work. And if you're suggesting that war will somehow stop Iran, then sign up. I don't want another war in the Middle East so to fulfill the apocalyptic ideologues like Trump, Bolton, and Pompeo. You literally had Mattis, McMaster, and Tillerson argue against withdrawal from the deal.
Log in to comment