Outlast or Until Dawn.

Out of curiosity, which was a more frightening, terrifying video game.

I think Outlast scared me a lot more than Until Dawn did. But I enjoyed Until Dawn gameplay a lot more.

I agree. Outlast was the scarier game but until dawn is a better game. I still think p.t beats them both though.

If you want more jump scares I would say Outlast is the better game. Story-wise I think Until Dawn was the better game.

Outlast is a true horror game! It is vile and disturbing, and the dlc that came out for it pushes it to the limit. Until Dawn is a great horror game as well, but it doesn't have the Gore that outlast has.

Until Dawn is not a horror game imo. Great game, but it's an 80's slasher movie. I never found those scary, funny actually.

I haven't played either, but I heard that Outlast is nothing but cheap jump scares, I'm interested in Until Dawn though

I didn't get a chance to play Until Dawn so far however I'm still trying to make my way through the Outlast's DLC "Whistleblower" which has some horrific scenes.. At times, It's a gruesome game ;)