you cannot call Surf's Up a proper surfing game.. u hardly even get to ride on a wave. i would love a new surfing game that is really realisitic. For example there is an actually line up, not all waves are the same, some waves will just close out on you, so wave selection actually becomes an element of the game play. Also i think a cool thing would be the option to paddle out from the beach for each surf, but also having a button to quickly morph to the line up. With the current technology, there is potiential for a really good surf game to be made.