Mafia I VS MAfia II

I think Mafia I it was better and more Bigger than the Second one.

Yes of course, better gameplay, better graphics the second one but the story and the leght of the first one absolutely better.

Umm...doesn't this belong to the PC-board?

Its true I agree. Mafia was much better than its sequel

I never played mafia so i can't comment on that but i have played mafia 2 and its a nice looking game and its very immersive.

Anyone here comparing the PS2 or Xbox version of Mafia to Mafia II isn't really comparing the real Mafia (the PC version) to Mafia II. Personally, I thought Mafia had a better, and more realistic story, but the gameplay in Mafia II was overall more fun.

I only played the PC version of mafia but loved it. I still have yet to get mafia 2, but it is price dropping so hard that I will get it soon.

The original PC version of Mafia is a alot better than Mafia II. Love both games though

Mafia was good for it's time, but I have to say that I did enjoy Mafia 2 a bit more. I just want to see where the next game takes us & how much different it will be.