Dark Souls Knight Laurtrec of Carim

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Thomasdeleo
#1 Posted by Thomasdeleo (1978 posts) -

I hear if you let this guy out of the cell he will kill all the npc's at firelink shrine, should I go and kill him there before he does this?

Avatar image for JoKeR_421
#2 Posted by JoKeR_421 (8920 posts) -
if hes going to kill the NPC then u should just kill him then. i know there was something like that in demons souls, u saved someone and he said i have a surprise for u later. and i ended up going to nexus later on and found everyone dead! so since im close to him ( just famring for souls ) once i free him ill kill that bastard lol
Avatar image for BoxingTheStars
#3 Posted by BoxingTheStars (1241 posts) -

let him do his thing. He only kills the lady in the cave who won't speak, but will upgrade you estus flask. but after he kills her you can find him somewhere else and kill him and get an item to bring the women back to life and then she will talk to you

Avatar image for ryrulez
#4 Posted by ryrulez (11605 posts) -
I killed him when you find him. His laugh was too maniacal. You get a cool ring, and a bunch of Humanity.
Avatar image for JoKeR_421
#5 Posted by JoKeR_421 (8920 posts) -
so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?
Avatar image for Rezze16
#6 Posted by Rezze16 (124 posts) -

Kill him asp if you dont want to deal with the dead girl (who upgrades the flasks). Let him kill her and you will find him later and fight him. This will allow you to revive the girl again and obtain his armor.

Avatar image for MLBknights58
#7 Posted by MLBknights58 (5016 posts) -

so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?JoKeR_421

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

Avatar image for NaughtyRag
#8 Posted by NaughtyRag (2309 posts) -

[QUOTE="JoKeR_421"]so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?MLBknights58

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

which is the better choice, i think.
Avatar image for JoKeR_421
#9 Posted by JoKeR_421 (8920 posts) -

[QUOTE="JoKeR_421"]so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?MLBknights58

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

yea ima do that. although, right before i fought the gargoyle i was going to open the door but decided to come back later. after beating the gargoyle i went back to him and the gate was still locked BUT he wasnt there. next thing u know on my way to the fire shrine or w.e its called at the beginning and he was sitting across the girl who dont speak and he tellin me to leave him alone he has nothin to say to me lol. so i guess i might have a different outcome? but if he does kill her i will avenge her!

Avatar image for kupo1705
#10 Posted by kupo1705 (64 posts) -

At what point in the game is he supposed to kill her?

Avatar image for i1-Palazzo
#11 Posted by i1-Palazzo (25 posts) -
Let him kill her, then get him after. You get the armour, too.
Avatar image for BoxingTheStars
#12 Posted by BoxingTheStars (1241 posts) -

At what point in the game is he supposed to kill her?

kupo1705

i think it is after you beat the depths

Avatar image for contaminated
#13 Posted by contaminated (5373 posts) -
Also the mute lady talks as well after you bring her back to life giving you interesting dialouge.
Avatar image for kupo1705
#14 Posted by kupo1705 (64 posts) -

[QUOTE="kupo1705"]

At what point in the game is he supposed to kill her?

BoxingTheStars

i think it is after you beat the depths

I completed the deths but she's still alive and he's still sitting there.

Does that include blighttown?

Avatar image for Thomasdeleo
#15 Posted by Thomasdeleo (1978 posts) -
Let him kill her, then get him after. You get the armour, too.i1-Palazzo
Thats what I'll do then, thanks everyone.
Avatar image for thecreechxxx
#16 Posted by thecreechxxx (737 posts) -
I'm sure that just like in Demon's Souls, you'll have to play the game through more than once if you want all the items and story options. I wouldn't sweat how you complete your first play through.
Avatar image for Tropicalshower
#17 Posted by Tropicalshower (10813 posts) -

let him do his thing. He only kills the lady in the cave who won't speak, but will upgrade you estus flask. but after he kills her you can find him somewhere else and kill him and get an item to bring the women back to life and then she will talk to you

BoxingTheStars
This, plus you can get his armor set.
Avatar image for BoxingTheStars
#18 Posted by BoxingTheStars (1241 posts) -

[QUOTE="BoxingTheStars"]

[QUOTE="kupo1705"]

At what point in the game is he supposed to kill her?

kupo1705

i think it is after you beat the depths

I completed the deths but she's still alive and he's still sitting there.

Does that include blighttown?

never mind just found out he kills her after you ring the 2nd bell of awakening

Avatar image for MLBknights58
#19 Posted by MLBknights58 (5016 posts) -

[QUOTE="JoKeR_421"]so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?MLBknights58

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

I basically copy and pasted that from a Dark Souls website I visited a while back. I can confirm today that I killed Lauretec and did not obtain his armour, and I confronted him in Anor Londo. Weird. Also my woman in the cave is not back to life. And uhh I did obtain the armour set but it was not after killing him, it was lying around after I beat the zone's boss. So Idk really.. seems like a bum deal to let him kill the old lady.

Avatar image for JoKeR_421
#20 Posted by JoKeR_421 (8920 posts) -

[QUOTE="MLBknights58"]

[QUOTE="JoKeR_421"]so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?MLBknights58

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

I basically copy and pasted that from a Dark Souls website I visited a while back. I can confirm today that I killed Lauretec and did not obtain his armour, and I confronted him in Anor Londo. Weird. Also my woman in the cave is not back to life. And uhh I did obtain the armour set but it was not after killing him, it was lying around after I beat the zone's boss. So Idk really.. seems like a bum deal to let him kill the old lady.

there are few things i was confused about. u see those black knights? at undead burg? well if u kill him without u being hit u get his sword an armor, same thing with that boar, if he dont hit u, u get boars helmet for ur character...my point is did he damage u or hit u? seems most enemies give u rare weapons/items if u kill em certain way and dont get hit
Avatar image for Gemini_Red
#21 Posted by Gemini_Red (3290 posts) -

[QUOTE="JoKeR_421"]so wait kill him asap? or should u kill him after he kills the lady who dont speak?MLBknights58

If you kill him immediately, the Fire Keeper will live, and you will receive humanity and another goody I think. However, if you let him live and kill the Fire Keeper, you will receive an item called.. Black Eye (something, can't remember). After beating the bosses in New Londo Ruins, the Black Eye will resonate, allowing you to invade Lauretec's world. After a battle with Lauretec, if you are victorious, you will revive the Fire Keeper, obtain more humanity, his entire armour set, and a ring.

I let him kill her.

lol, see I didn't know that. After freeing him and talking to him a few times, one word popped into my mind; Yurt. I killed him on the spot.

Avatar image for LoG-Sacrament
#22 Posted by LoG-Sacrament (20397 posts) -
i wasnt too interested in his armor, so i just killed him as he was eyeing the fire keeper. his ring is good and im not complaining about the humanity either.
Avatar image for zekere
#23 Posted by zekere (2531 posts) -

LOL, I had Yurt visions too, but I let him live. he's sitting peacefully in the Fire Shrine...opposite the quiet lady, he gave me some amulet, i used the sun soul to upgrade my health flasks anyway...