Shadow of the Colossus or Resident Evil 4...

I'm trying to the decided between the to games which I should buy. And yes I know they are two different genres of games... XD

i would go for Resident Evil 4 its because the action is very good same as the controls xD

God of War 1 and 2...........no seriously Gow1 and 2....

I would go with resi4

Both are awesome games but I would prefer Shadow of the Colossus.Felorn

I agree. 

This is cool, I remember renting both games at once from blockbuster at one point.

I would go with Shadow of the colossus, the ps2 version of RE4, blurry to the max, it has a very muddy look to it.

You should get shadows, brilliant game, and the end boss is awesome. Also IMO the graphics are better, especially the way the colossus are rendered 

Shadow of the Colossus isn't for everyone. You either like the game or hate it. Is an original concept. If you don't like original game... Go with RE 4. For me, I think Shadow of the Colossus is better than RE 4. :PThomas-Crown

Mi advice for you is:

Both games!

Seriously, buy one and then the other, save some money its just $20 each and they are one of the best PS2 games ever.

I have both and played both, I think for you that RE4 will give you more value but SotC shall not be missed for any gamer, its just a masterpiece. 

i have both games...
and luv both of it..

Both are amazing games no doubt, I have played and completed both so my opinion isn't bias.

RE4 will appeal more to the mainstream audience, but Colossus is out of this world, it's truly one of a kind.

shadow of the colossus. its an experience like no other. thisguy51

i agree

Resident Evil 4 is great too, but Shadow of the Colossus is a unique game