Should Persona 5 have a more Action-RPG Feel?

As a fan of gaming, i can accept change. Saints Row 2 to Saints Row 3, Any of the Final Fantasy compaired to its sequals and beyond. Now if you read the title, its not that i dont like the current Persona Combat System, i like it alot, but if you play Persona 2 then go to Persona 3, their Combat systems are diffrent, so here's what im trying to say. Persona 1 and 2 had the same system, Persona 3 and 4 changed from the orginals, but what if Persona 5 and 6 had an Action RPG feel (Kingdom Hearts, Dragon's Dogma for some Examples).

Like when you go into a dungeon you'd encounter enemies as you would in Persona 4 and you go into the battle area, but now you can move your character around, summon your Persona's, order your team to roles and much more. For Example, say theirs MC (You), Naoto, Yukiko and Kanji on your team (Throwing out examples, dont know if they would be in) You could Order Kanji to be the main damage dealer along with you (If you chose to be one), Naoto would be more of a long range fighter with her gun doing damage from a distance and of course Yukiko as your main healer. all that would be accessable in a "Roles" tab somewhere, and you can change your Roles Instantly in a Final Fantasy XIII Esque sort of way, so when you would change, MC would be a Healer (Assuming they make MC a Wlid Card in Persona 5) Yukiko Switches to long range fighter with her Fire Attacks and Naoto and Kanji as the Main Damage Dealers.

Persona's would be Accessed in a "Persona" tab, there you can Select your persona (Again, Assuming MC is a Wild Card) this would be like the "Summons" Tab from Kingdom Hearts. and in order to use your Persona's Abilities, there would be an "Abilities" Tab the would give you your skills that you can use.

Im not saying 'This Should Be in the game" Rather its an idea that popped into my head and thought i would share it, i would be happy if they stayed with the Current with just some tweeks, but i would also welcome a change in formula. Thank you for Reading

Absolutely not. What you describe reminds me of FFXIII and the thought of that game has brought flecks of vomit into my mouth. I want to input every command for every spell or action directly as in past games, in a turn-based order, and anything other than this would leave me disappointed.

Honestly I would rather see them evolve the battle system from 4 to 5 about as much as it changed from 3 to 4. Slight improvements.

I like action RPGs, but there are plenty of them out there. In fact the good rehashed versions of the battle planning style of the old school JRPGs is actually becoming harder to find on the home consoles as each generation goes by. Persona has managed to retain an older gamestyle by making it require players to utilize strategy to survive combat instead of simply level grinding. For me Persona 3 and 4 combat was more about developing battle plans on fly (a little like chess) than it was about finding that win all weapon or level. Everything was about discovering strengths and weaknesses, sure leveling gave you an edge, but not much of one.

I liked that type of challenge and it's why I consider Persona a good game. I think that diving into another action RPG set up would be what makes Persona lose it's edge. Sure we still might get a crazy awesome story, but I would miss the paranoia of battle planning. :)

It should have an ak-47, imo...

How many ARPGs came out last year. How many JRPGs came out last year.

Why would you want to make a small, shrinking genre smaller by changing a top tier member of that genre into a game better fitting for a huge, growing genre? This isn't turning a mediocre game in a new direction, this would have been like making Civilization 5 into an RTS... It just doesn't make any sense.