Which RPG?

So basically I need an rpg that came out within the last few years to play.

Should I get NWN 2, The Witcher, Two Wolrds, or Gothic 3?

I enjoyed morrowind and baldur's gate alot.

I have Oblivion, but don't really play it anymore.

Feel free to add in some rpg's if I missed any good ones.

Out of those, The Witcher is the best.

I'd probably rank them: The Witcher > NWN2 = Gothic 3 > Two Worlds.

I don't think you'd go far wrong in working you way through Bioware's back catalogue if you say you already like Baldur's Gate. So that would be any of the following:

Baldur's Gate 2

Planescape: Torment - very good!!!

Neverwinter Nights

Neverwinter Nights 2

Or from their newer stuff, and if you fancy a change from the Dungeons & Dragons setting:

Knights of the Old Republic - highly recommended

Knights of the Old Republic 2

Jade Empire - haven't played it myself

Then there's always Diablo/Diablo 2, much more hack & slash, less engrossing story-wise, but good fun nonetheles.

If The Witcher doesn't win this poll then there's something wrong.

Out of those?

The Witcher > Neverwinter Nights 2 > Gothic 3 > Two Worlds

Well, before trying the more recents...you may want to consider playing planescape and fallout before...after it will be hard to revert back to older graphics.

NWN2 is the best deal in the list you offered, but avoid the expansion like the plague.

IMO the Witcher isn't worth your time, or the label of a RPG, but that is personnal and I understand that peoples have different tastes, just like some peoples like action games and shooters.

Well, before trying the more recents...you may want to consider playing planescape and fallout before...after it will be hard to revert back to older graphics.

NWN2 is the best deal in the list you offered, but avoid the expansion like the plague.

IMO the Witcher isn't worth your time, or the label of a RPG, but that is personnal and I understand that peoples have different tastes, just like some peoples like action games and shooters.

Anofalye

The Witcher was so bleh, I have no idea why people sing praises for it. Maybe the genre is so desperate for new life anything will give you that crack-a-lacking high of an RPG.

BGII / Arcanum / Morrowind are my all time favourites.

two worlds is not that bad ...
it was worth 20$ during the steam's x-mas sales, a pretty good 20$ value