rpg games vs action rpg games

OK there is 3 types of players when it comes to rpg games. people who don't like a full true rpg game. There is people who hate hack and slash rpg games. then there is people like both.

Any ways there was a debate about this some time ago on game spot. I have a video I found and would like to share to prove my case. There was a study done bout I can't find a Internet sight on this debate. however i did find this video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFOPnX0KY2U

i like both. in fact, i like all genres as long as the game is good.JnWycliffe

i like both. in fact, i like all genres as long as the game is good.JnWycliffe

but i like all kinds of rpgs....

i like full RPG's i find RPG-Action games tend to be too cinematic and take control away from the playermarkop2003

but as i said it before i like them both.

I like them both. True RPGs more.

I hate J-"RPG"s though.

[QUOTE="JnWycliffe"]i like both. in fact, i like all genres as long as the game is good.Lach0121

but i like all kinds of rpgs....

i like sports games, i find it's all about how you play them, sports games should be enjoyed with friends, racing games are the only ones that i find enjoyable by myself

[QUOTE="markop2003"]well i do have to say that for full rpg's there are a lot of cinematics... i would say generally speaking more in turn based rpg's, than in action rpgs.

Lach0121

I think you meant to say JRPG? since there aren't many turn base CRPGs; Fallouts are but no way are they *cinematic.*

and I have no idea what does *full* RPG mean.

[QUOTE="Lach0121"]

[QUOTE="markop2003"]well i do have to say that for full rpg's there are a lot of cinematics... i would say generally speaking more in turn based rpg's, than in action rpgs.

teardropmina

I think you meant to say JRPG? since there aren't many turn base CRPGs; Fallouts are but no way are they *cinematic.*

and I have no idea what does *full* RPG mean.

basically an RPG which isn't an action one, generally slower and have a more in depth story, it said on the video that oblivion and morrowind classed as full RPGs

[QUOTE="teardropmina"][QUOTE="Lach0121"]

[QUOTE="markop2003"]well i do have to say that for full rpg's there are a lot of cinematics... i would say generally speaking more in turn based rpg's, than in action rpgs.

markop2003

I think you meant to say JRPG? since there aren't many turn base CRPGs; Fallouts are but no way are they *cinematic.*

and I have no idea what does *full* RPG mean.

basically an RPG which isn't an action one, generally slower and have a more in depth story, it said on the video that oblivion and morrowind classed as full RPGs

[QUOTE="markop2003"][QUOTE="teardropmina"][QUOTE="Lach0121"]

[QUOTE="markop2003"]well i do have to say that for full rpg's there are a lot of cinematics... i would say generally speaking more in turn based rpg's, than in action rpgs.

Lach0121

I think you meant to say JRPG? since there aren't many turn base CRPGs; Fallouts are but no way are they *cinematic.*

and I have no idea what does *full* RPG mean.

basically an RPG which isn't an action one, generally slower and have a more in depth story, it said on the video that oblivion and morrowind classed as full RPGs

1 turn based has more cinematics than any of them.

2. action based has some cinematics, but generally not as much as turn based ones. although this is not the case everytime.

3. perspective rpgs hardly have cinematics except for maybe key elements in story or something... alot less than the other two.

ok umm well honestly there are 3 types of major rpgs... turn based.... action based.... and perspective base (like morrowind)

1 turn based has more cinematics than any of them.

Lach0121

*perspective* RPg, so you just make up a genre at will anyway you see fit?

also, would be nice if you give an example of cinematic *turn base* CRPG.

[QUOTE="Lach0121"]

ok umm well honestly there are 3 types of major rpgs... turn based.... action based.... and perspective base (like morrowind)

1 turn based has more cinematics than any of them.

teardropmina

*perspective* RPg, so you just make up a genre at will anyway you see fit?

also, would be nice if you give an example of cinematic *turn base* CRPG.

and that "genre" is one i named for me... im not saying thats how it is.

I like them both. True RPGs more.

I hate J-"RPG"s though.

HenriH-42

I respect all the types of RPG games, there should be a form of variation to accomodate all gamers. Personally, I like to lean more towards action RPGs. I love action on the whole I also love stopping gameplay and going deep into the RPG elements but am easily bored so I can't handle the RPG alone. Hack and slash on the whole isn't my thing, any old fool could repeatedly mash a button.8)

I wouldn't say that the regular RPG games are "true" RPG games, yes it was the first type in the RPG genre. That doesn't make it a "true" variation of the genre, we need to consider evolution of games, arcade to simulation... 2D to 3D

[QUOTE="teardropmina"]

also, would be nice if you give an example of cinematic *turn base* CRPG.

Lach0121

you're talking about JRPG; Fallouts are turn base, King's Bounty: Legend is turn base, but there aren't cinematic whatsoever.

[QUOTE="Lach0121"][QUOTE="teardropmina"]

also, would be nice if you give an example of cinematic *turn base* CRPG.

teardropmina

you're talking about JRPG; Fallouts are turn base, King's Bounty: Legend is turn base, but there aren't cinematic whatsoever.