[QUOTE="ronvalencia"]
[QUOTE="04dcarraher"] Another one..... lets ignore TDP usage, and the fact that all these results are from europe and the fact it includes POV manufacturer a big Nvidia supplier , which that brand had the highest sales and the highest failure rate. The high GTX280 failure rate probably is directly related to Point of View failure rate. Also . It seems that the data from this sample might not be statistically significant based on the sample size. Two cards sold more than 100 units in the dataset being analysed and had a return rate of 10%+.
Xtasy26
Â
On the otherhand, Sapphire is known to be the largest seller for ATI/AMD type GPUs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sapphire_Technology
Gainward's parent company is Palit.
Â
NVIDIA "bumpate" related legal battles still persist in 2012 http://www.seattlerex.com/seattle-rex-vs-apple-the-verdict-is-in/
Â
Â
What an awesome find rova! Thanks for posting. I am glad the guy won. While my 17" Gaming laptop with the defective nVidia GPU didn't cost $4000 like this guy's 17" MacBook Pro it did cause me a lot of grief and cost me money.Â
Funny story, I sent nVidia an e-mail and told them about their defective 7600/8600 GPU's and told them this wouldn't have happened if I brought an ATI GPU and demanded that they do a replacement, they responded with a one liner that they don't do replacement.Â
What's astonishing about this article is that Apple sent two lawyers to fight this guys when they could have simply got a replacement laptop, after all, it's not Apple that pays for the replacement laptop it's actually nVidia since it's their defective GPU as the Apple lawyer put it:
"Apple guys said Oh, it wouldnt have cost us anything, Nvidia foots the bill for each board we replace. What a douche. Nvidia was also acting like douche bags when they simply sent a  BIOS fix to Dell and other laptop makers that had the defective 8600\7600 GPU's where it would run the GPU fans faster in order to cool the GPU's more until the "warranty" runs out in that way they wouldn't be responsible for replacing the laptop.Â
I am glad I switched over to AMD, I have been doing gaming on this laptop for nearly 4 years and it hasn't been a problem so far. And Dell weren't a bunch of d!cks. When I had a burned pixel on my 17" laptop they replaced the entire screen with a brand new screen. After they installed the screen the laptop wouldn't start up so they replaced the entire MB with a brand new mother board (which means I got a brand new Radeon 3650 because the GPU is built into the mother board (whoot!) not to mention I got a new back covering and bezels. In other words, after a year of use esentially got a brand new laptop. Awesome service from Dell I must say and great GPU form AMD.
It to be fair, ASUS replaced my ASUS G1S (GeForce 8600M) GT into G1SN (GeForce 9500M GS) model. Some ASUS G1S owners has G50 (GeForce 9700M) replacement laptop. My beef is with my other ASUS N80VN (GeForce 9650M GT) 14 inch laptop i.e. after replacing the motherboard, ASUS refused to fix Windows X64 BSOD NVIDIA issues and told me to stay with 32bit Windows.. After that incident, I switch to Sony Vaio VGN-FW45 laptop with Radeon HD 4650M and it's all Radeon HDs after that. I bought my Dell laptop for warranty reasons i.e. our company has an assigned Dell account manager and they have pretty good business service.
Log in to comment