command and conquer TW or Supreme Commander?

my current games

BF2, oblivion, FEAR, Company of Heroes, baseball mogul 2007, mvp baseball 05, hoyle casino 2007, and the sims 2.

 i havn'et gotten a new PC game in a while, (latest being Company of Heroes which totally kicks butt) and i really like these strategy games.

 i had red alert 2 and the first red alert andi have to say those game were awesome. supreme commander also looks very good.

 which one is worth shelling out $50.

C&C 3.  Supreme Commander Didn't imo turn out the way intended,  The Scale is so huge but the way it turned out in design is just not fun to play imo.

 C&C 3 is just classic C&C fun.  may be same old same old but its fantastic.

yea i bought SC 2 days ago and its pretty bad... the online is buggy as hell and iv been able to get into 3 games out of 500 attempts the gameplay is alright but like a previous poster said its just not that much fun the units all seem so small and they dont react right for a game ment to have such large scale battles.

big units travel far to slow and jets even travel slow its pretty sad because it could of been great. 

Definitely c&c 3 :) sc is fun, the first half hour or so, then it simply become dead boring.

C&c 3 just delivers hours of fun. There is nothing as exiting as when 20 minutes into a game you hear the following "A nuclear launch has been detected" and its is not you own ^.^

c&c 3 i fast paced rpg action, plain fun and excitement 

My vote goes to SC as it's one of the best strategic rts of all time.It's scale is soo big that it enables lots of different strategies.You can counter everything with different tactics.

On the other hand as for me C&C is too fast.It's act first think later game.SC requires more thinking and make you feel like a real commander.

The REAL question you want to ask yourself assuming you don't already have CoH is CoH or Supcom?

CnC and Supcom are two different type of games,  CnC and CoH are much more similar and COH by far and large better then CnC3 by miles.

 Other factors you need to keep in mind for CNC 3 is the balance is complete crap right now, the pacing is wtf stupid I mean seriously getting the games best units in just 5 minutes into a game? Units that void the purpose of most early game units.

 On top of that CNC 3 uses GAMESPY and many people are having huge problems with it, those who can even get online get all kinds of problems like disconnects, desyncs super lag and more. Of the 3 people I know who bought the game none of them can get online and 2 of them sold the game already in frustration.

Supcom is a completely different type of game from either CoH or CnC, it's more macro like with a large scale, it's a very deep game and isn't exactly user friendly at first, if your looking for a casual game stay away from this, otherwise it's a good bet for you. The game doesn't have many problems as far as I know, but it basically does require you own a dual core cpu. 

The REAL question you want to ask yourself assuming you don't already have CoH is CoH or Supcom?

CnC and Supcom are two different type of games,  CnC and CoH are much more similar and COH by far and large better then CnC3 by miles.

 Other factors you need to keep in mind for CNC 3 is the balance is complete crap right now, the pacing is wtf stupid I mean seriously getting the games best units in just 5 minutes into a game? Units that void the purpose of most early game units.

 On top of that CNC 3 uses GAMESPY and many people are having huge problems with it, those who can even get online get all kinds of problems like disconnects, desyncs super lag and more. Of the 3 people I know who bought the game none of them can get online and 2 of them sold the game already in frustration.

Supcom is a completely different type of game from either CoH or CnC, it's more macro like with a large scale, it's a very deep game and isn't exactly user friendly at first, if your looking for a casual game stay away from this, otherwise it's a good bet for you. The game doesn't have many problems as far as I know, but it basically does require you own a dual core cpu. 

SirWrinkles

my current games

BF2, oblivion, FEAR, Company of Heroes, baseball mogul 2007, mvp baseball 05, hoyle casino 2007, and the sims 2.

i havn'et gotten a new PC game in a while, (latest being Company of Heroes which totally kicks butt) and i really like these strategy games.

i had red alert 2 and the first red alert andi have to say those game were awesome. supreme commander also looks very good.

which one is worth shelling out $50.

MaddenBowler10

Seriously we need a C&C3 vs Sup Com thread stickied. They are not even the same type of RTS.visceron

If you are a rich kid, get supreme commander, but I guarantee you'll get bored of it very fast because it is monotonous, changing factions to find out that the building look different, are the same in function and that only the 3 balance destroying experimental units will seperate the armies makes it worse.  But if you can stand endless boring moments and are just amused to be able to build an army that your computer may not support, then all the power to you.

C&C TW spanks it, people are right in saying they are two completely different games.  Because one sucks after 10 hours play time and C&C TW is just another excelent RTS! 

If you are a rich kid, get supreme commander, but I guarantee you'll get bored of it very fast because it is monotonous, changing factions to find out that the building look different, are the same in function and that only the 3 balance destroying experimental units will seperate the armies makes it worse. But if you can stand endless boring moments and are just amused to be able to build an army that your computer may not support, then all the power to you.

C&C TW spanks it, people are right in saying they are two completely different games. Because one sucks after 10 hours play time and C&C TW is just another excelent RTS!

_alex_

since when do you people not look at past forums, there was exactly the same post not even a day or 2 ago, wow how lazy are you just go look it up and see what people said for that guy is that so hard, if you cant make up your mind at that point dl the demos try them out, maybe then if your still undeceded go ahead and postzbiggie

i just downloaded and played the CnC3 demo and wow, it's amazing. i am def getting it ( iahven't even tried supreme commander but maybe i will try)MaddenBowler10