Why is Japan still apologizing for WW2?

  • 63 results
  • 1
  • 2

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for gamerguru100
#1 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

Avatar image for muller39
#2 Posted by muller39 (14953 posts) -

They were quite ruthless.

Avatar image for Fightingfan
#3 Posted by Fightingfan (38011 posts) -
They apologize for not using their Gundam's against America.
Avatar image for VaguelyTagged
#4 Posted by VaguelyTagged (10701 posts) -

yeah it's not fair but they happened to be on the loser's side.

Avatar image for gamerguru100
#5 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -

They were quite ruthless.

muller39
So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?
Avatar image for Fightingfan
#6 Posted by Fightingfan (38011 posts) -
[QUOTE="muller39"]

They were quite ruthless.

gamerguru100
So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?

I think Germany refuses to apologize, which is why WW2 happened. IRC after WW1 Germany wasn't allowed to have a military. Nazi military go hard.
Avatar image for muller39
#7 Posted by muller39 (14953 posts) -
[QUOTE="muller39"]

They were quite ruthless.

gamerguru100
So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?

Agreed but perhaps they just want keep being on good terms.
Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#8 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -
Why is America still apologizing over Slavery and how this country was founded? Answer: The people doing it are idiots.
Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#9 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -
[QUOTE="gamerguru100"][QUOTE="muller39"]

They were quite ruthless.

muller39
So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?

Agreed but perhaps they just want keep being on good terms.

Maybe China and Korea could get over it and move on? What the rest of the world is doing.
Avatar image for FMAB_GTO
#10 Posted by FMAB_GTO (14385 posts) -
because apologizing is kawaii desu!
Avatar image for applesxc47
#11 Posted by applesxc47 (10761 posts) -

[QUOTE="gamerguru100"][QUOTE="muller39"]

They were quite ruthless.

Fightingfan

So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?

I think Germany refuses to apologize, which is why WW2 happened. IRC after WW1 Germany wasn't allowed to have a military. Nazi military go hard.

It was also because WWI economically crippled Germany and they had no chance of recovering without...doing something drastic :P

Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#12 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -

[QUOTE="Fightingfan"][QUOTE="gamerguru100"] So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?applesxc47

I think Germany refuses to apologize, which is why WW2 happened. IRC after WW1 Germany wasn't allowed to have a military. Nazi military go hard.

It was also because WWI economically crippled Germany and they had no chance of recovering without...doing something drastic :P

You can be sarcastic, but Germany was kinda screwed over after WW1.
Avatar image for muller39
#13 Posted by muller39 (14953 posts) -
[QUOTE="muller39"][QUOTE="gamerguru100"] So was Germany, Mongolia, Britain, and France, but are they apologizing for colonizing other areas a long time ago?TheWalkingGhost
Agreed but perhaps they just want keep being on good terms.

Maybe China and Korea could get over it and move on? What the rest of the world is doing.

Everyone should move one especially if you or your family were not involved I agree. People tend to hold grudges no pun intended from your sig ;)
Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#14 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -
[QUOTE="muller39"][QUOTE="TheWalkingGhost"][QUOTE="muller39"] Agreed but perhaps they just want keep being on good terms.

Maybe China and Korea could get over it and move on? What the rest of the world is doing.

Everyone should move one especially if you or your family were not involved I agree. People tend to hold grudges no pun intended from your sig ;)

I have a sig?????
Avatar image for applesxc47
#15 Posted by applesxc47 (10761 posts) -

[QUOTE="applesxc47"]

[QUOTE="Fightingfan"] I think Germany refuses to apologize, which is why WW2 happened. IRC after WW1 Germany wasn't allowed to have a military. Nazi military go hard. TheWalkingGhost

It was also because WWI economically crippled Germany and they had no chance of recovering without...doing something drastic :P

You can be sarcastic, but Germany was kinda screwed over after WW1.

I know, I said that.

Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#16 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -

[QUOTE="TheWalkingGhost"][QUOTE="applesxc47"]

It was also because WWI economically crippled Germany and they had no chance of recovering without...doing something drastic :P

applesxc47

You can be sarcastic, but Germany was kinda screwed over after WW1.

I know, I said that.

Just seemed like with that smiley you were being sarcastic.
Avatar image for th3warr1or
#17 Posted by th3warr1or (20640 posts) -
I was under the impression that Japan still hasn't apologized for Nanking.
Avatar image for gamerguru100
#18 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -
I was under the impression that Japan still hasn't apologized for Nanking. th3warr1or
I've heard their textbooks don't mention it. I think Japan has to acknowledge what they did, but they shouldn't be apologizing over and over after seventy years.
Avatar image for Socijalisticka
#19 Posted by Socijalisticka (1555 posts) -

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

gamerguru100

apologizing for lessening the actual scale of genocide != apologizing for genocide

Avatar image for GummiRaccoon
#20 Posted by GummiRaccoon (13793 posts) -

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

gamerguru100

read r@pe of nanking

Avatar image for gamerguru100
#21 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -

[QUOTE="gamerguru100"]

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

GummiRaccoon

read r@pe of nanking

I've heard of it. But it's 2012, not 1946. People need to move on. China and Korea should move on from WW2 and the US should move on from 9/11. Most people in China and Korea today weren't alive in 1945, so they really shouldn't have a beef with Japan.
Avatar image for muller39
#22 Posted by muller39 (14953 posts) -
[QUOTE="muller39"][QUOTE="TheWalkingGhost"]Maybe China and Korea could get over it and move on? What the rest of the world is doing.TheWalkingGhost
Everyone should move one especially if you or your family were not involved I agree. People tend to hold grudges no pun intended from your sig ;)

I have a sig?????

Avatar was what I meant. My bad.
Avatar image for GummiRaccoon
#23 Posted by GummiRaccoon (13793 posts) -

[QUOTE="GummiRaccoon"]

[QUOTE="gamerguru100"]

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

gamerguru100

read r@pe of nanking

I've heard of it. But it's 2012, not 1946. People need to move on. China and Korea should move on from WW2 and the US should move on from 9/11. Most people in China and Korea today weren't alive in 1945, so they really shouldn't have a beef with Japan.

China and Japan have been adversarial for thousands of years, they aren't going to stop just because. You think the Japanese were able to be so monstrous to them if they didn't think poorly of them in the first place?

Avatar image for CreasianDevaili
#24 Posted by CreasianDevaili (4364 posts) -

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

gamerguru100
You know this answer since you asked it right? Japan, China, and Korea all have differences compared to western society. Especially in Japan there is a big thing about family heritage. What the Japanese did, and in turn, done to them by, specifically the North Koreans, messes with those ideals to this very day. We shouldn't need to get into what happened in China since its been mentioned many times in threads already. Suffice to say they are still reaping what they sowed.
Avatar image for KG86
#25 Posted by KG86 (6021 posts) -

65 years isn't that long ago in the big scheme of things. Some people who went through these things are still alive.

Avatar image for Zeviander
#26 Posted by Zeviander (9503 posts) -
It's a Japanese thing. You keep apologizing until the other "person" asks you to stop. Then you keep apologizing.
Avatar image for punkpunker
#27 Posted by punkpunker (3383 posts) -

65 years isn't that long ago in the big scheme of things. Some people who went through these things are still alive.

KG86

this

Avatar image for TheWalkingGhost
#28 Posted by TheWalkingGhost (6092 posts) -
It's a Japanese thing. You keep apologizing until the other "person" asks you to stop. Then you keep apologizing.Zeviander
Japan: Apologize until the other dude gets pissed, and then apologize some more. America: Pretend it never happened or lie about it. Europe: Blame it on the American.
Avatar image for gamerguru100
#29 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -

[QUOTE="KG86"]

65 years isn't that long ago in the big scheme of things. Some people who went through these things are still alive.

punkpunker

this

The majority living today weren't alive in '45. Should they be blamed and demanded to apologize too?
Avatar image for jun_aka_pekto
#30 Posted by jun_aka_pekto (22029 posts) -

I was under the impression that Japan still hasn't apologized for Nanking. th3warr1or

That, plus I think victims of the Japanese want an "official" apology from the Japanese government. I would guess it would be the legal and binding type that requires vote and ratification by the Japanese government (kind of like the opposite of a Declaration of War). I don't think it's happened yet though.

Individual speeches by Japanese Prime Ministers don't count. It's like demanding something in writing and notarized to boot.

Avatar image for StryderK
#31 Posted by StryderK (3189 posts) -

[QUOTE="GummiRaccoon"]

[QUOTE="gamerguru100"]

Even in the 2010s, Japanese leaders have given apologies to China and Korea for its actions during WW2. Why? :? It was over 65 years ago.

gamerguru100

read r@pe of nanking

I've heard of it. But it's 2012, not 1946. People need to move on. China and Korea should move on from WW2 and the US should move on from 9/11. Most people in China and Korea today weren't alive in 1945, so they really shouldn't have a beef with Japan.

They should yes...But there are problems...

ie, Japanese says sorry one day, then the next says the R ape of Nanking is just a "minor incident" and "Many photographs taken during that period were "fakes"". The next, we are sorry. Then write school books that basically says "Unit 731 (Don't read about this if you have a weak stomache) is just a figment of Chinese imagination and commuist propoganda". One day announces they are sorry for comfort women, turns around and say those women were never forced and they "are volunteers who offered their lives for the "holy war" to liberate Asians from the tyranny of the white man". And to compound the problems, many class A war criminals, are buried in the Yushukuni, Japanese national cemetary and they REFUSE to take them out, with many Japanese high end politicians, especially the far right, visit it every year. It's stuff like this that STILL gets its Asain neighbor nigh the entire S Pacific rim up in arm every time Japanese do something silly. Look at around 2003 or so, when Japanese tried to apply for permanent voting memeber within the U.N. And the end result protest up and down the rim took many japanese by surprise, many were wondering, "Didn't we liberated these people during WW II? Why they hate us so much?"....There in lies your answer....

Avatar image for one_plum
#32 Posted by one_plum (6499 posts) -

Apologizing? They're still trying to find ways to downplay their actions.

Avatar image for RahXephon101
#33 Posted by RahXephon101 (501 posts) -

I agree that it is kind of ridiculous, I mean most of the people alive in Japan were born after WWII. It is important to remember the past, but at a certain point people need to move on. Think about the present, Japan is a democracy that now cares about human rights. China treates Tibet like crap and is a nation full of human rights violations.

Avatar image for sonicare
#34 Posted by sonicare (55287 posts) -

Honestly, I dont think those apologies mean much. It makes no sense to apologize for the actions of your forefathers. You had no control over that and Japan is a much different nation than it was back in the 1940's. So is the rest of the world. Makes no sense to me to apologize for the actions of someone else.

Avatar image for sune_Gem
#35 Posted by sune_Gem (12463 posts) -

Honestly, I dont think those apologies mean much. It makes no sense to apologize for the actions of your forefathers. You had no control over that and Japan is a much different nation than it was back in the 1940's. So is the rest of the world. Makes no sense to me to apologize for the actions of someone else.

sonicare

I agree with that to an extent. But people do still judge others by the actions of their forefathers. As unfair as that is.

Avatar image for bigfoot2045
#36 Posted by bigfoot2045 (732 posts) -

Read up on the Rape of Nanking and the Bataan Death March. The Japanese commited some of the worst atrocities in human history and on a massive scale. In fact, the Japanese made the Nazis look tame and civilized by comparison.

Avatar image for punkpunker
#37 Posted by punkpunker (3383 posts) -

[QUOTE="punkpunker"]

[QUOTE="KG86"]

65 years isn't that long ago in the big scheme of things. Some people who went through these things are still alive.

gamerguru100

this

The majority living today weren't alive in '45. Should they be blamed and demanded to apologize too?

statistically japanese are longer living so...

Avatar image for LJS9502_basic
#38 Posted by LJS9502_basic (161701 posts) -

Honestly, I dont think those apologies mean much. It makes no sense to apologize for the actions of your forefathers. You had no control over that and Japan is a much different nation than it was back in the 1940's. So is the rest of the world. Makes no sense to me to apologize for the actions of someone else.

sonicare
If an apology wasn't done in the past...it's a step to better diplomatic relationships. More self serving than anything....
Avatar image for one_plum
#40 Posted by one_plum (6499 posts) -

I agree that it is kind of ridiculous, I mean most of the people alive in Japan were born after WWII. It is important to remember the past, but at a certain point people need to move on. Think about the present, Japan is a democracy that now cares about human rights. China treates Tibet like crap and is a nation full of human rights violations.

RahXephon101

If the German government started editing history textbooks and taking an ambiguous stance on its past atrocities, people wouldn't be offended?

Avatar image for RahXephon101
#41 Posted by RahXephon101 (501 posts) -

[QUOTE="RahXephon101"]

I agree that it is kind of ridiculous, I mean most of the people alive in Japan were born after WWII. It is important to remember the past, but at a certain point people need to move on. Think about the present, Japan is a democracy that now cares about human rights. China treates Tibet like crap and is a nation full of human rights violations.

one_plum

If the German government started editing history textbooks and taking an ambiguous stance on its past atrocities, people wouldn't be offended?

I never meant that Japan should rewrite history. Their history textbooks should continue to acknowledge atrocities. My issue is when Japanese citizens born 30 years after the war have to stand up and apologize for something their ancestors did. At a certain point people are going to have to move on. Should the Japanse governemnt have to continue to apologize 100 years from now?

Also my point stands, we need to focus on current events. Japan is a democracy and advocates human rights, China is a dictatorship carrying out countless human rights violation (do you not see the hypocrisy of chinese youths demanding an apology for atrocities that they never experienced, while currently treating Tibet horribly?).

Avatar image for ClassicRockFTW
#42 Posted by ClassicRockFTW (1106 posts) -

They were quite ruthless.

muller39

"HEY GAIZ LETS DROP A BOMB ON A CITY TO KILL CIVILIANS, THAT'LL SHOW THOSE RUTHLESS JAPANESE!!!"

Avatar image for thebest31406
#43 Posted by thebest31406 (3775 posts) -
I wasn't aware they were still apologizing.
Avatar image for Nibroc420
#44 Posted by Nibroc420 (13571 posts) -
because apologizing is kawaii desu!FMAB_GTO
/facepalm Your lack of understanding of the Japanese you write is very telling.
Avatar image for FMAB_GTO
#45 Posted by FMAB_GTO (14385 posts) -
[QUOTE="FMAB_GTO"]because apologizing is kawaii desu!Nibroc420
/facepalm Your lack of understanding of the Japanese you write is very telling.

It means cute, and i was just saying for the sake of it.
Avatar image for Treflis
#46 Posted by Treflis (13278 posts) -
I do think that after 65 years they can stop, most have forgiven and moved on since then. France, England and the majority of European countries including the US have forgiven Germany and it's now a allied country and well liked. Same with Italy and Japan. Yes war crimes happened, horrible things, But they happened. Nothing will change that. So it's better to move on and learn from such mistakes so you can do more good, then simply be stuck and dwell on them.
Avatar image for gamerguru100
#47 Posted by gamerguru100 (12686 posts) -

[QUOTE="gamerguru100"][QUOTE="punkpunker"]

this

punkpunker

The majority living today weren't alive in '45. Should they be blamed and demanded to apologize too?

statistically japanese are longer living so...

So? Most Japanese today were still born after WW2, dude. :?
Avatar image for one_plum
#48 Posted by one_plum (6499 posts) -

[QUOTE="one_plum"]

If the German government started editing history textbooks and taking an ambiguous stance on its past atrocities, people wouldn't be offended?

RahXephon101

I never meant that Japan should rewrite history. Their history textbooks should continue to acknowledge atrocities. My issue is when Japanese citizens born 30 years after the war have to stand up and apologize for something their ancestors did. At a certain point people are going to have to move on. Should the Japanse governemnt have to continue to apologize 100 years from now?

Also my point stands, we need to focus on current events. Japan is a democracy and advocates human rights, China is a dictatorship carrying out countless human rights violation (do you not see the hypocrisy of chinese youths demanding an apology for atrocities that they never experienced, while currently treating Tibet horribly?).

The issue isn't really against the Japanese people; it's more on the stance taken by the government and the officials. Similarly, many people (including many Chinese) still lambast the Chinese government's involvement in the Tiananamen Square protests, demanding apology and compensation to this day because they still assume no responsibility.

Avatar image for OB-47
#49 Posted by OB-47 (10909 posts) -

At least it's better than pretending it didn't happen

Avatar image for WhiteKnight77
#50 Posted by WhiteKnight77 (12605 posts) -

It's one thing for a prime minister or other official to apologize and another for the country to apologize and that is where many people still harbor a resentment towards Japan, the lack of a formal, Diet (Japanese Parliament) voted on one. People are wanting on offical apology.