Why do we have to be respectful in court?

in the video when the girl said adios and the judge acted on it, that was his mistake, he is not fit to be a judge.dragonmaster64

[QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]in the video when the girl said adios and the judge acted on it, that was his mistake, he is not fit to be a judge.pie-junior

[QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]in the video when the girl said adios and the judge acted on it, that was his mistake, he is not fit to be a judge.dragonmaster64

[QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]in the video when the girl said adios and the judge acted on it, that was his mistake, he is not fit to be a judge.dragonmaster64

[QUOTE="pie-junior"][QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]in the video when the girl said adios and the judge acted on it, that was his mistake, he is not fit to be a judge.dragonmaster64

If I was a kid getting a right telling off by my dad for being a little sh!t, and just started laughing, the chances are he's going to give me a right fuking hiding and I'd be careful about doing the same thing again. She acted like a kid - the judge treated her like one, with the hope that outcome to the above will be the same. If the judge's role is to instill a sense of remorse and ensure individuals don't reoffend then his response may be justified. Whether or not punishment actually works though is for another thread. But anyway. Heyho.

Is this in refernce to that girl who gave the judge the middle finger and got 90 days in jail?

Because there's this thing called contempt of court

[QUOTE="BlackHawk340"]

Punishments should be decided on what and how bad the crime was not on how someone acts in court.
The fact the judge punished the girl for how she acts made it clear hes not fit to be judge anymore.

They should always be neutral even if the person in the stands is a total douche.

ad1x2

2 things that have nothing in common, the judge doesnt have to hire this girl to stand and represent his company.

BUT not hiring someone by their looks is forbidden by law, they usually make up soem excuse  because its uncontitutional to decline someone on their looks.

Also if you where in court for robbing soemone.

You know you are innocent but prosecutor keep pushing, you lose your temper "I did not fkn do it!" can happen to any man is a tight spot.
Or this when you get arrested, "I didnt fkn do anything!"

Later that day video is released and sure enough youa re innocent, but but but because you lost your temper the judge still confies you to 30 days of cell because nothing, he didnt like you.

Do you think thats fair? Being judged for something outside of what you re in for.

Well he didnt commit the murder but I dotn like his shoelaces, 5 months of detention!

Hard to explain english is not my primary language :D

I never understood why we have to be respectful in court. like noone enforces you to be respectful in public but when in court its a whole different story. this judge is just a human, he is not God. so i dont understand.

I am also a believer in God, and his teaching "Have mercy on others so God may have mercy on you" I watched alot of judge videos (pretty much the unfair ones that OT posts) where they give harsh judgements and is unfair.

so what do you think?

 

EDIT: You are all mis understanding my point, what im really saying is that it seems whether your respectful or not affects your sentence. When justice should just be justice no emotions, sentiments anything...

i am reffering to that video where she particularly said adios, then he raised her sentence. There should be nothing nothing wrong with that.

dragonmaster64

+1

You could have asked this question in the thread about where you got the idea to ask in the first place. But to answer your question. If you're suspected of doing something, why would you not be anything but respectful and hope to convince the judge to lessen or nullify the sentence. Does that even need some explanation? DevilMightCry

[QUOTE="ad1x2"][QUOTE="BlackHawk340"]

Punishments should be decided on what and how bad the crime was not on how someone acts in court.
The fact the judge punished the girl for how she acts made it clear hes not fit to be judge anymore.

They should always be neutral even if the person in the stands is a total douche.

BlackHawk340

2 things that have nothing in common, the judge doesnt have to hire this girl to stand and represent his company.

BUT not hiring someone by their looks is forbidden by law, they usually make up soem excuse  because its uncontitutional to decline someone on their looks.

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

VanDammFan

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

VanDammFan

[QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

dragonmaster64

[QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

LJS9502_basic

[QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

LJS9502_basic

as you said in another thread....respect is earned. As often very few in these positions deserve respect because they dont exhibit it themselves. Many of them feel entitled and often abuse that position....so whats a guy to do in that sitution...just bow down? 

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

bnarmz

as you said in another thread....respect is earned. As often very few in these positions deserve respect because they dont exhibit it themselves. Many of them feel entitled and often abuse that position....so whats a guy to do in that sitution...just bow down? 

It is a court of law, it does not need to earn your respect.

[QUOTE="LJS9502_basic"][QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

bnarmz

as you said in another thread....respect is earned. As often very few in these positions deserve respect because they dont exhibit it themselves. Many of them feel entitled and often abuse that position....so whats a guy to do in that sitution...just bow down? 

actually, there are ways to get a judge fired if they dont respect you or your rights. people have more power than they show because most of them don't relize that the system is there to serve us not serve the system. No one owns anyone nor does anyone in the court has the right to treat you anyway they want.

actually, there are ways to get a judge fired if they dont respect you or your rights. people have more power than they show because most of them don't relize that the system is there to serve us not serve the system. No one owns anyone nor does anyone in the court has the right to treat you anyway they want.

bnarmz

[QUOTE="VanDammFan"]

OP I see you are a level 53..but that dont mean you are an adult..OR even a respectful adult..so im going to say you are under 30 prob under 25..MOST young people feel they dont have to be respectful to anyone anywhere anymore..its called respect..and actually when the judges tells you to be respectful its the law at that point...dont listen and get thrown in jail,fined,ect..

dragonmaster64

No, you mean you stopped understanding when you tried to read that

Then you went off on another "fire bad!" rant

How old are you? I'm not even sure you can be posting here because there's an age 13 requirement and your questions are revealing that you're much younger.

[QUOTE="BlackHawk340"]

Punishments should be decided on what and how bad the crime was not on how someone acts in court.
The fact the judge punished the girl for how she acts made it clear hes not fit to be judge anymore.

They should always be neutral even if the person in the stands is a total douche.

thegerg

That's the dumbest thing I've ver heard. If someone acts in vilation of the law, why should they not be punished?

[QUOTE="thegerg"]

[QUOTE="BlackHawk340"]

Punishments should be decided on what and how bad the crime was not on how someone acts in court.
The fact the judge punished the girl for how she acts made it clear hes not fit to be judge anymore.

They should always be neutral even if the person in the stands is a total douche.

dragonmaster64

That's the dumbest thing I've ver heard. If someone acts in vilation of the law, why should they not be punished?

[QUOTE="dave123321"][QUOTE="dragonmaster64"] lol grow up? are you retarded? dragonmaster64

:roll:

This thread is sooo facepalm-y ;sFMAB_GTO

It is pretty awful, its up there with 'Why CAN'T I put my face next to the hungry lions jaws?'

I mean you can if you like, just don't be surprised if it gets eaten.

This thread is sooo facepalm-y ;sFMAB_GTO

i think everyones missing the main point of the thread or didnt understand the main point.dragonmaster64

  Quoted for truth, I think it sort of those who are in favor of the status quo because it is convenient.  

[QUOTE="FMAB_GTO"]This thread is sooo facepalm-y ;stenaka2

It is pretty awful, its up there with 'Why CAN'T I put my face next to the hungry lions jaws?'

I mean you can if you like, just don't be surprised if it gets eaten.

[QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]i think everyones missing the main point of the thread or didnt understand the main point.mahlasor

  Quoted for truth, I think it sort of those who are in favor of the status quo because it is convenient.  

[QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]i think everyones missing the main point of the thread or didnt understand the main point.mahlasor

  Quoted for truth, I think it sort of those who are in favor of the status quo because it is convenient.  

[QUOTE="mahlasor"]

[QUOTE="dragonmaster64"]i think everyones missing the main point of the thread or didnt understand the main point.dave123321

  Quoted for truth, I think it sort of those who are in favor of the status quo because it is convenient.