Obama says students with disabilities have a right to play sports

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Laihendi
#1 Posted by Laihendi (5871 posts) -

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/24/students-disabilities-school-sports-obama_n_2546057.html?utm_hp_ref=impact&ir=Impact

And the liberal mainstream media acts like he is a heroic social progressive for doing so.

This of course completely contradicts the concept of sports being a display of competitive physical athleticism, because the physically disabled are by definition uncompetitive with regards to physical athleticism. Next Obama will likely be saying that the mentally disabled have a right to participate in math and debate teams.

Obviously the disabled should be able to organize and come up with alternative athletic activities for them to participate in, but they shouldn't be used as a tool to undermine competitiveness for those who aren't inhibited by physical disabilities. This is just another example of the government using public schools to push a political agenda.

Avatar image for DroidPhysX
#2 Posted by DroidPhysX (17098 posts) -
You know in elementary or middle school where you act like you hate a girl to overcompensate the fact that you REALLY like her? The girl is Obama and the guy "hating" her is Laihendi.
Avatar image for nocoolnamejim
#4 Posted by nocoolnamejim (15136 posts) -
For those of us familiar with sports, there are various LEVELS of sports. Varsity, Junior Varsity, Freshman, etc. Essentially, you can compete at different levels based on your ability. But beyond that, we have the regular Olympics and the Special Olympics, which again recognizes that you can have some amazing achievements based on genetic limitations and still not be the best in the world. Sports exist for a variety of purposes. Certainly at the highest levels, it's about competition and showcasing the limits of human physical achievement. But at the high school level it's also often about making friends, learning how to socialize, team behavior, and just plain physical fitness. Mountain meet molehill.
Avatar image for dave123321
#5 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
Lai love is scary
Avatar image for Saturos3091
#6 Posted by Saturos3091 (14938 posts) -

Do you expect the president, a man in a position that panders to the politically correct for its own benefit, would say otherwise?

And of course they have that right. They shouldn't be excluded from doing what they want to do. The only problem comes in if the sport's rules change, or if the game is impacted in some way. Obviously people with disabilities tend to play in special leagues, which is totally fine. If they're capable of playing in other leagues though, then why not?

Avatar image for Yusuke420
#7 Posted by Yusuke420 (2770 posts) -

I saw a news story before a playoff game about a kid who lose a leg due to a nasty knee injury during a high school football game. Rehabed all the way back and threw for a touchdown pass in limited play. No one is saying they should be picked over anyone, but if they can perform at a level high enough to make the team, there's no harm in letting them try out.

Avatar image for Pirate700
#8 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

What a coincidence. They are covering this on the local news now. All this is about is making sure there are programs for disabled people. What's the issue?

Avatar image for Fightingfan
#9 Posted by Fightingfan (38011 posts) -
As long as they don't hinder the game useless I'm all for it. Example. If some kid in a wheel chair wants to do wrestling, and I'm his opponent what am I suppose to do?
Avatar image for Pirate700
#10 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

As long as they don't hinder the game useless I'm all for it. Example. If some kid in a wheel chair wants to do wrestling, and I'm his opponent what am I suppose to do?Fightingfan
They would be in separate programs.

Avatar image for Fightingfan
#11 Posted by Fightingfan (38011 posts) -

[QUOTE="Fightingfan"]As long as they don't hinder the game useless I'm all for it. Example. If some kid in a wheel chair wants to do wrestling, and I'm his opponent what am I suppose to do?Pirate700

They would be in separate programs.

I would hope.
Avatar image for ghoklebutter
#12 Posted by ghoklebutter (19327 posts) -
Well, hey, I'm all for equal opportunity.
Avatar image for nocoolnamejim
#13 Posted by nocoolnamejim (15136 posts) -

[QUOTE="Fightingfan"]As long as they don't hinder the game useless I'm all for it. Example. If some kid in a wheel chair wants to do wrestling, and I'm his opponent what am I suppose to do?Pirate700

They would be in separate programs.

Yeah, basic common sense. Lai's post above is an example of someone arguing with an Obama that doesn't exist. Obama made a reasonable sort of statement that high school sports are a part of the social experience of high school and finding a way for disabled individuals to take part isn't a bad thing and is presenting it like Obama is advocating the end of athletic competition.
Avatar image for jimkabrhel
#14 Posted by jimkabrhel (15625 posts) -

[insert something promoted by President Obama]

[insert Laihendi's ignorant derisive comments which are laughable, mostly likely dervied from overexposure to right-wing media and inadequate exposure to critical thinking]

Gents and Ladies? There you have a Laihendi thread

Avatar image for Allicrombie
#15 Posted by Allicrombie (26207 posts) -
LIES. >.>
Avatar image for SUD123456
#16 Posted by SUD123456 (4835 posts) -

The idiot that is the TC confuses equality of access with equality of outcome.

Not surprisingly TC's threads always have the common denominator of idiocy.

Avatar image for Zeviander
#17 Posted by Zeviander (9503 posts) -
So long as they are included only in non-competitive leagues then all is okay.
Avatar image for dave123321
#18 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
Lai, I admire your resilience to criticism
Avatar image for perfect_blue
#19 Posted by Perfect_Blue (29491 posts) -

I don't see the problem. Why are you against the disabled having rights Laihendi? That's not what the founding fathers preached.

Avatar image for dave123321
#20 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension
Avatar image for lamprey263
#21 Posted by lamprey263 (34153 posts) -
don't see what the fuss is about, seems like an extension of Title IX from women to the disabled
Avatar image for nocoolnamejim
#22 Posted by nocoolnamejim (15136 posts) -
Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension dave123321
I said it wouldn't end well for you.
Avatar image for SpartanMSU
#23 Posted by SpartanMSU (3440 posts) -

I don't see anything wrong if they have separate programs. If not, then I have a problem with it. Why should a disabled kid get to make the team when someone who was born unathletic not be able to make it? How are they different in respects that they both don't have the necessary athletic abilities/skills to be competative?

Avatar image for dave123321
#24 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
I was UPSET
Avatar image for DroidPhysX
#25 Posted by DroidPhysX (17098 posts) -
Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension dave123321
ROFL
Avatar image for Agent-Zero
#26 Posted by Agent-Zero (6196 posts) -
[QUOTE="dave123321"]Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension DroidPhysX
ROFL

What happened?
Avatar image for nocoolnamejim
#27 Posted by nocoolnamejim (15136 posts) -
I was UPSETdave123321
I understand. I...just didn't expect such emotions from you. Nevertheless, I am a good Christian boy who values forgiveness after doing... penance. Say this and I shall appeal to the lord to look mercifully upon you.
Avatar image for Pirate700
#28 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

[QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="dave123321"]Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension Agent-Zero
ROFL

What happened?

I'm wondering what they're talking about as well.

Avatar image for WSGRandomPerson
#29 Posted by WSGRandomPerson (13694 posts) -
Well, no. I mean, if they want their own separate style of a sport (special Olympics, wheelchair basketball, etc.) then sure. However I don't think we should bring down normal sports for people who are obviously not suited to play in them.
Avatar image for dave123321
#30 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
[QUOTE="DroidPhysX"][QUOTE="dave123321"]Jim, please tell someone to end the year long tdh suspension Agent-Zero
ROFL

What happened?

Jim ruffled my feathers
Avatar image for Pirate700
#31 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

[QUOTE="Agent-Zero"][QUOTE="DroidPhysX"] ROFLdave123321
What happened?

Jim ruffled my feathers

What does that have to do with TDH?

Avatar image for dave123321
#32 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
Anyway You can delete your post where you quoted my offending comment Jim To keep the damage to a minimum Not that it seems like it is anything that is kept hidden
Avatar image for dave123321
#33 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -

[QUOTE="dave123321"][QUOTE="Agent-Zero"] What happened?Pirate700

Jim ruffled my feathers

What does that have to do with TDH?

This doesn't concern you
Avatar image for Pirate700
#34 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

[QUOTE="Pirate700"]

[QUOTE="dave123321"] Jim ruffled my feathers dave123321

What does that have to do with TDH?

This doesn't concern you

Then why are you discussing it publicly?

Avatar image for dave123321
#35 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
That sounded more rude then I intended Sorry
Avatar image for nocoolnamejim
#36 Posted by nocoolnamejim (15136 posts) -
[QUOTE="dave123321"]Anyway You can delete your post where you quoted my offending comment Jim To keep the damage to a minimum Not that it seems like it is anything that is kept hidden

The lord appreciates your apologetic spirit my child.
Avatar image for Pirate700
#37 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

That sounded more rude then I intended Sorrydave123321
It's too late. My feelings are crushed.

Avatar image for Allicrombie
#38 Posted by Allicrombie (26207 posts) -

[QUOTE="dave123321"]That sounded more rude then I intended SorryPirate700

It's too late. My feelings are crushed.

lol.
Avatar image for dave123321
#39 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -

[QUOTE="dave123321"][QUOTE="Pirate700"]What does that have to do with TDH?

Pirate700

This doesn't concern you

Then why are you discussing it publicly?

publicness allows my post to reach out to more then one
Avatar image for Pirate700
#40 Posted by Pirate700 (46465 posts) -

[QUOTE="Pirate700"]

[QUOTE="dave123321"]That sounded more rude then I intended SorryAllicrombie

It's too late. My feelings are crushed.

lol.

:P

Avatar image for MetalDogGear
#41 Posted by MetalDogGear (825 posts) -
[QUOTE="DroidPhysX"]You know in elementary or middle school where you act like you hate a girl to overcompensate the fact that you REALLY like her? The girl is Obama and the guy "hating" her is Laihendi.

Bulbasaur sucks
Avatar image for VanHelsingBoA64
#42 Posted by VanHelsingBoA64 (5455 posts) -
doesn't laihendi consider disabled people property
Avatar image for dave123321
#43 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
doesn't laihendi consider disabled people propertyVanHelsingBoA64
Some of them
Avatar image for Allicrombie
#44 Posted by Allicrombie (26207 posts) -
doesn't laihendi consider disabled people propertyVanHelsingBoA64
Django Unchained: OT Edition.
Avatar image for JohnF111
#45 Posted by JohnF111 (14187 posts) -
I like that they are accomodating disabled people more and more and this is brilliant that they are creating more opportunities for team work and sports for them. I mean sports is fun as hell not just a professional business. At university there were two disabled guys in my first year, they had helpers to make sure note were taken and classes were attended, what I didn't know was that they had been through the same year of university FIVE TIMES in a row and never managed to pass and I think there's a time to draw the line and just get them the hell out, that was essentially eight places on that course taken up by two guys who shouldn't have been there., the first year fine, gotta evaluate them to start with so instead of ten its eight places. Moral of the story: Don't try to treat them as equals just because you don't want to upset anyone.
Avatar image for dave123321
#46 Posted by dave123321 (35327 posts) -
[QUOTE="VanHelsingBoA64"]doesn't laihendi consider disabled people propertyAllicrombie
Django Unchained: OT Edition.

Whis is the django of OT?
Avatar image for Laihendi
#47 Posted by Laihendi (5871 posts) -

The article in the op specifically mentions how one of Obama's special advisers was partially blind during high school so the school made it so that everyone wrestling had to touch each other at all times so that he would not be disadvantaged. If this man gets what he wants then there will just be more changes like that that effect everyone. Sports will be remade in attempt to remove any competitive advantages or disadvantages that anyone in a given group might have.

The reality is that there are simply not enough physically handicapped people who are interested in athletics to create teams for traditional sports for the disabled in most places. That means that if they are going to participate in traditional sports they must be on the same team as the nondisabled. We should end public education and all of these kinds of programs and let people organize on their own and form their own sports teams and make them however they want. The government shouldn't be controlling how children engage in sports.

Avatar image for jimkabrhel
#48 Posted by jimkabrhel (15625 posts) -

The article in the op specifically mentions how one of Obama's special advisers was partially blind during high school so the school made it so that everyone wrestling had to touch each other at all times so that he would not be disadvantaged. If this man gets what he wants then there will just be more changes like that that effect everyone. Sports will be remade in attempt to remove any competitive advantages or disadvantages that anyone in a given group might have.

The reality is that there are simply not enough physically handicapped people who are interested in athletics to create teams for traditional sports for the disabled in most places. That means that if they are going to participate in traditional sports they must be on the same team as the nondisabled. We should end public education and all of these kinds of programs and let people organize on their own and form their own sports teams and make them however they want. The government shouldn't be controlling how children engage in sports.

Laihendi
Wat do you think about Title IX then?
Avatar image for BossPerson
#49 Posted by BossPerson (9177 posts) -
See its because Ayn Rand hates disabled children, Laihendi loves Ayn Rand, thus Laihendi hates disabled children
Avatar image for Laihendi
#50 Posted by Laihendi (5871 posts) -
[QUOTE="Laihendi"]

The article in the op specifically mentions how one of Obama's special advisers was partially blind during high school so the school made it so that everyone wrestling had to touch each other at all times so that he would not be disadvantaged. If this man gets what he wants then there will just be more changes like that that effect everyone. Sports will be remade in attempt to remove any competitive advantages or disadvantages that anyone in a given group might have.

The reality is that there are simply not enough physically handicapped people who are interested in athletics to create teams for traditional sports for the disabled in most places. That means that if they are going to participate in traditional sports they must be on the same team as the nondisabled. We should end public education and all of these kinds of programs and let people organize on their own and form their own sports teams and make them however they want. The government shouldn't be controlling how children engage in sports.

jimkabrhel
Wat do you think about Title IX then?

Education and recreation should not receive federal funding anyways so the fact that Title IX is even relevant is a problem.