What Should Of Recieved A Higher Rating...Smooth Moves Or Twilight Princess???

I'm not sure what's going on with the reviews from gamespot when it comes down to Wii Games but don't most you of you think that Twilight Princess should of recieved a higher rating than Smooth Moves???

Twilight Princess: 8.8 Rating

Smooth Moves: 9.1 Rating (Highest Rated Wii Game)

You shouldn't bother with the GS scores they have no clue of what they are doingikwal

good lord you guys are critical....a 7.5!!!??? TP deserves at least .3 points higher than 8.8 IMO...

Dont compare it to OOT, compare it to other games like it....it's a complete masterpiece 4 years in the making by one of the best in the industry, it deserves nothing less than to be the 16th best game of all time

[QUOTE="ikwal"]You shouldn't bother with the GS scores they have no clue of what they are doinghazbazz

both games shouldve scored lower. especially smooth moves

You shouldn't bother with the GS scores they have no clue of what they are doingikwal

Zelda got hosed by GS.  They Say = 9.5, You Say = 9.5

AND KEEP IN MIND, TP was GOTY for EGM, Gamespy, and 1up.  All of those are major game websites/magazines.  TP EASILY is better than Wario Ware and shoulda got a lot higher than 8.8

denifinetly tp it is a lot better oh and ive played both

They both got scores that fit them. I wouldn't change them, nor will I say that they should've gotten a higher/lower rating.

Zelda got hosed by GS.  They Say = 9.5, You Say = 9.5

AND KEEP IN MIND, TP was GOTY for EGM, Gamespy, and 1up.  All of those are major game websites/magazines.  TP EASILY is better than Wario Ware and shoulda got a lot higher than 8.8

NATATO

yeah and Okami was IGNs GOTY and it easily deserved it over the countless awards for both TP and Gears in every publication or website.

[QUOTE="NATATO"]

Zelda got hosed by GS. They Say = 9.5, You Say = 9.5

AND KEEP IN MIND, TP was GOTY for EGM, Gamespy, and 1up. All of those are major game websites/magazines. TP EASILY is better than Wario Ware and shoulda got a lot higher than 8.8

ryustruck

yeah and Okami was IGNs GOTY and it easily deserved it over the countless awards for both TP and Gears in every publication or website.

Zelda should've AT LEAST received a 9.5, if not a 10.Crucifix_Angel

[QUOTE="ryustruck"][QUOTE="NATATO"]

Zelda got hosed by GS. They Say = 9.5, You Say = 9.5

AND KEEP IN MIND, TP was GOTY for EGM, Gamespy, and 1up. All of those are major game websites/magazines. TP EASILY is better than Wario Ware and shoulda got a lot higher than 8.8

Dencore

yeah and Okami was IGNs GOTY and it easily deserved it over the countless awards for both TP and Gears in every publication or website.

yeah i kinda missed the point a little bit. TP was an overhyped GOTY machine that did not deserve scores like 10, 9.5, and various other pipedreams.

WarioWare is good at is genre, but TP is way better in genre and in general.

What happens here is that Gamespot has always hated Nintendo while favoring Sony and MS (and admit it). I mean, you can even see it in the arrange of the consoles bar on top, they're not in an alphabetical order, and Wii is dead last on the next-gen consoles.  Remember when THPS 3 on PS2 (add emphasis on PS2) got a perfect 10???? Not even its genre deserved it, I mean it was good but I've played better sports games. IMO Wii games are way underrated or overrated (like Monkey Ball) here, they just don't care at all and do their job. Yes, sometimes crappy, but they get ther job done.

My conclusion: TP: 9.3, and WW: 9.1 (stays the same)