The trend towards having a run button again is bizarre

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for Two400
#1 Edited by Two400 (2787 posts) -

Super Mario 3D World and Sonic Lost World: two games that have zero need for a run button! Analog sticks were meant to eliminate the need for one, as it's annoying to hold a run button when an analog stick can perform the function in a more efficient manner.

What do you think?

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#2 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18600 posts) -

A lot of games have them. It doesn't bother me too much unless it requires finger gymnastics to control efficiently.

Avatar image for nini200
#3 Posted by nini200 (11484 posts) -

It's similar to going back to Dual Analogs for FPS once you're used to more efficient controls (KB/M - WiiMote/Nunchuck), a pain but it works.

Avatar image for quatoe
#4 Posted by quatoe (7135 posts) -

I do not mind a run button. As long as it doesn't hinder anything, which Super Mario 3D World didn't let happen. At least to me.

Avatar image for pierst179
#5 Posted by pierst179 (10803 posts) -

You do have a point, but - honestly - that set-up has never bothered me.

Avatar image for KBFloYd
#6 Posted by KBFloYd (18942 posts) -

its a little annoying...i also wish they ran faster..they seem slow even when fully running.

Avatar image for JordanElek
#7 Edited by JordanElek (18561 posts) -

@Two400 said:

it's annoying to hold a run button when an analog stick can perform the function in a more efficient manner.

It can't, though. In 3D World, the length of your jump directly corresponds to your speed. With a run button, you know- with 100% confidence - whether you're running or walking in any given moment because you're either holding the button or you're not.

I would not want that to be determined by how far the analog stick is being pushed. The line between walk and run would be hazy, and in a game that requires as much precision as 3D World does, haziness is far more annoying than having to hold a button down.

The control in other 3D Mario games suffers a bit because of the lack of a run button. It's much harder to make precision jumps when your speed is determined by a tiny lever with several points of input rather than a solid binary action.

Avatar image for Ovirew
#8 Posted by Ovirew (8125 posts) -

I have always liked having a run button for most games. I'm so used to holding a button to run around, I tend to do it sometimes in games where the button has no function.

On a similar note, I also always screw around with the d-pad and various buttons whenever I try to catch a pokemon in any Pokémon game. Is anyone else this way? Yes? No? I wonder if it actually does help?

Avatar image for FFCYAN
#9 Posted by FFCYAN (4964 posts) -

Most button actions in SM3DW are either run/projectile or jump. Don't act like playing 3D World is complicated with a run button. :|

Avatar image for Two400
#10 Posted by Two400 (2787 posts) -

@FFCYAN said:

Most button actions in SM3DW are either run/projectile or jump. Don't act like playing 3D World is complicated with a run button. :|

Not complicated, but games like Super Mario 64 were fine without one. At least make a separate option for those that don't care about tapping and holding the run button all the time.

Avatar image for ANIMEguy10034
#11 Edited by ANIMEguy10034 (4954 posts) -

I do prefer analog running, but I don't mind playing games that still have a run button.

@Ovirew said:

On a similar note, I also always screw around with the d-pad and various buttons whenever I try to catch a pokemon in any Pokémon game. Is anyone else this way? Yes? No? I wonder if it actually does help?

Pressing buttons have no benefits when catching pokemon, but I'm sure many people still do it to ease their mind, including me. It feels much better pressing buttons with determination than doing nothing but stare at the pokeball and hope for the best. :P

Avatar image for juboner
#12 Posted by juboner (1183 posts) -

3dworld felt like a side scrolling mario bros game to me, and that is why it works well in 3dworld. 3dworld is more linear in level design opposed to galaxy and 64 where you explored. In 3dworld the level keeps u going in a certain path.