This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for GulliversTravel
#1 Posted by GulliversTravel (3062 posts) -

Well Okami is the first of that type of game Ive ever played and enjoying it so far, have I ruined the Zelda games or are they better in ther own ways? Whats the current opinion on the two franchises now that the fanboy wars have settled (at least a bit...).

Avatar image for Panzer_Zwei
#2 Posted by Panzer_Zwei (15498 posts) -

I don't like the ZELDA series at all.

As for OKAMI, it was a beautiful and very enjoyable game when it came out for the PS2.

Avatar image for Renegade_Fury
#3 Posted by Renegade_Fury (19720 posts) -

I love Zelda, but I absolutely hated Okami. Everything from the artstyle to the combat, I thought it sucked. That's just me though, so try out both and see for yourself.

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#4 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

Okami is better than certain Zelda games,not as good as others. Depends on which game we're comparing Okami to.  For instance, IMO Okami> A Link to the Past (raises flame shield).  However, Majora's Mask or Wind Waker> Okami.  

That being said, I loved the hell out of Okami. I think it is a truly amazing game, and definitely deserves to be played by anyone who just loves greatness.  

Avatar image for NaveedLife
#5 Posted by NaveedLife (17179 posts) -

Okami has its amazing aspects, but Most Zelda games are better than it.  Okami is more like Skyward Sword tier (though both games have very different issues) and not on the level of OoT, MM, and WW.  

 

Okami needed better puzzles and less hand holding.  Loved the art, music, and presentation all wrapped up in a solid zelda like game, but not amazing.

Avatar image for Buckhannah
#6 Posted by Buckhannah (715 posts) -
About on Par with Wind Waker and the GC version of Twilight Princess, better than the Wii version of Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword.
Avatar image for benleslie5
#7 Posted by benleslie5 (8649 posts) -

I love Okami for what it was, I would love to see another game like this

Avatar image for Suppaman100
#8 Posted by Suppaman100 (5250 posts) -
Okami's not as good as ALTTP but just as good or even better than OOT. Overall Okami > Zelda
Avatar image for JigglyWiggly_
#9 Posted by JigglyWiggly_ (24606 posts) -
both good zelda is better
Avatar image for senses_fail_06
#10 Posted by senses_fail_06 (7098 posts) -
Zelda. Okami is boring.
Avatar image for Shenmue_Jehuty
#11 Posted by Shenmue_Jehuty (5211 posts) -

I can see where people draw similarities between Okami and the Zelda series, however they felt like very different experiences to me when I played Okami versus playing any Zelda game. I definitely would say Zelda is better overall, at least Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess. I did enjoy Okami more than Wind Waker though.

Avatar image for SciFiCat
#12 Posted by SciFiCat (1750 posts) -
Well that is kind of a unfair comparison since there have been way more Zelda games than Okami games,that said, I enjoyed Okami on PS2 to a level that is unimaginable. I've played several Zelda games but Okami just felt so much more inspired and beautiful, Its combat was incredibly rich and flexible. Maybe because it is more unique and its art style is absolutely gorgeous and in some aspects it surpassed even some comparable Zelda games like Wind Waker. Its world and its inhabitants felt more vibrant, alive, as if every nook and cranny was a piece of art imbued with the spirit of Japan's rich mythology and millenarian aesthetics. Zelda's mythology is small in comparison. I like Zelda but the original Okami holds a special place among the best games I've ever played.
Avatar image for chocolate1325
#13 Posted by chocolate1325 (33009 posts) -

Depends which Zelda game you compare Okami to but overall Zelda has had more games and is far superior.

Avatar image for BigBen11111
#14 Posted by BigBen11111 (1529 posts) -

To me nothing compares to the greatness of Zelda games, ever.

Avatar image for rawsavon
#15 Posted by rawsavon (40001 posts) -
I have played every zelda console game up until the Wii game and consider myself to be a fan of the series. But, IMO, Okami out zelda'ed every zelda game. -much larger world and bigger story -better characters -more charm -better combat The only area it did not do better in was the fact that it took a while to get going...whereas many (though not all) zelda games start out stronger
Avatar image for BarbaricAvatar
#16 Posted by BarbaricAvatar (982 posts) -

I have played every zelda console game up until the Wii game and consider myself to be a fan of the series. But, IMO, Okami out zelda'ed every zelda game. -much larger world and bigger story -better characters -more charm -better combat rawsavon

 

And a wolf-god is a much more compelling central character than Gary green hat.

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#17 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

I love Okami for what it was, I would love to see another game like this

benleslie5

Okamiden was released on DS. Nowheere near as good as Okami, but still really good and worth playing.

Avatar image for Emerald_Warrior
#18 Posted by Emerald_Warrior (6581 posts) -

Okami is a beautiful game, no doubt. But there's just no comparison to a series as high-quality and as long-running as Zelda. Nearly every single Zelda games (excludng the CD-i, of course) is a masterpiece. And there's a bunch of them.

Avatar image for Blueresident87
#19 Posted by Blueresident87 (5657 posts) -

I think Okami is much more unique, at least now it is, but it's difficult to argue with a video game that's followed the same formula(more or less) for 20 years and is still successful.

Avatar image for jsmoke03
#20 Posted by jsmoke03 (13696 posts) -

1 game vs a legacy franchise? kind of ridiculous dont you think?

Avatar image for deactivated-57ad0e5285d73
#21 Posted by deactivated-57ad0e5285d73 (21398 posts) -

I love Zelda, but I absolutely hated Okami. Everything from the artstyle to the combat, I thought it sucked. That's just me though, so try out both and see for yourself.

Renegade_Fury
I thought Okami stunk as well. The game felt like one bill ol gimmick.
Avatar image for Dudersaper
#22 Posted by Dudersaper (32951 posts) -
Not a huge fan of either, but I pick LoZ for OoT, which was the only LoZ I finished, and loved it. Started Okami but pushed it back into my backlog.
Avatar image for riou7
#23 Posted by riou7 (10841 posts) -

Love both, can't really decide which one's better!

Avatar image for vashkey
#24 Posted by vashkey (33782 posts) -
Wind Waker and Twilight Princess are the only Zelda games I've played through all the way but I feel they were better than Okami. Okami was about twenty hors longer than it needed to be. It felt padded out and the script was pretty obnoxious That said, I still feel like Okami was still a great game and you have to give it credit for it's creativity and presentation too. I just feel like the Zelda games were better paced.
Avatar image for LAN7ERN
#25 Posted by LAN7ERN (352 posts) -
The Zelda series is one of the best ones of all time.
Avatar image for NaveedLife
#26 Posted by NaveedLife (17179 posts) -

I have no idea why people like Okami's combat, or how they can say it has better puzzles.  Zelda is far superior.  

Avatar image for Blueresident87
#27 Posted by Blueresident87 (5657 posts) -

I have no idea why people like Okami's combat, or how they can say it has better puzzles. Zelda is far superior.

NaveedLife

I think you said before that Zelda is pretty much superior in every way that matters most, and you're right. Okami has its place for what it does, Zelda is better overall.

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#28 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

I have no idea why people like Okami's combat, or how they can say it has better puzzles. Zelda is far superior.

Blueresident87

I think you said before that Zelda is pretty much superior in every way that matters most, and you're right. Okami has its place for what it does, Zelda is better overall.

I personally think that Okami has a better overworld design than many Zeldas... It was a very fun game to explore.  Only a few Zeldas compete with it, like MM and WW.

Not saying Okami is better though, just in that way.

Avatar image for thedork_knight
#29 Posted by thedork_knight (1742 posts) -
am current playing okami ( 5hr in) and while it looks amazing and has bucket loads of charm, i finding it quite boring.
Avatar image for Blueresident87
#30 Posted by Blueresident87 (5657 posts) -

[QUOTE="Blueresident87"]

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

I have no idea why people like Okami's combat, or how they can say it has better puzzles. Zelda is far superior.

turtlethetaffer

I think you said before that Zelda is pretty much superior in every way that matters most, and you're right. Okami has its place for what it does, Zelda is better overall.

I personally think that Okami has a better overworld design than many Zeldas... It was a very fun game to explore. Only a few Zeldas compete with it, like MM and WW.

Not saying Okami is better though, just in that way.

Agreed that Okami does have better overworld design, but I don't find that the poor design of most worlds in Zelda hurts the games that much. A Link to The Past has the best overworld design of any Zelda game for me, along with MM and WW like you said. But even other Zelda games that lack in this department provide a solid 'Zelda' experience.

Avatar image for GulliversTravel
#31 Posted by GulliversTravel (3062 posts) -
Interesting responses from everyone. Im currently on the final boss and Ive enjoyed the game mainly for the mood it creates and the steady unlocking of abilities that make revisiting older sections an enjoyable activity. Its dungeons and puzzles are really basic though, and there are only a few but they help to break up the game and are not the focus. Its also a pretty simple game, how do the Zeldas compare in that regard?
Avatar image for Blueresident87
#32 Posted by Blueresident87 (5657 posts) -

Interesting responses from everyone. Im currently on the final boss and Ive enjoyed the game mainly for the mood it creates and the steady unlocking of abilities that make revisiting older sections an enjoyable activity. Its dungeons and puzzles are really basic though, and there are only a few but they help to break up the game and are not the focus. Its also a pretty simple game, how do the Zeldas compare in that regard?GulliversTravel

The dungeons in the Zelda games are far more complex overall than anything you'll find in Okami. The puzzles are a main focus of the Zelda games.

Avatar image for Business_Fun
#33 Posted by Business_Fun (2282 posts) -

At the risk of sounding like a complete idiot, how are the two franchises comparable?

Avatar image for MonoSilver
#34 Posted by MonoSilver (1392 posts) -
I've never been able to get into the Zelda series but I will keep trying. Okami is one of my favourite games though. Truly a work of art and enjoyable to play.
Avatar image for Dudersaper
#35 Posted by Dudersaper (32951 posts) -

At the risk of sounding like a complete idiot, how are the two franchises comparable?

Business_Fun
In both games you use a being with legs, duh :roll:
Avatar image for Business_Fun
#36 Posted by Business_Fun (2282 posts) -

[QUOTE="Business_Fun"]

At the risk of sounding like a complete idiot, how are the two franchises comparable?

Dudersaper

In both games you use a being with legs, duh :roll:

And the answer was staring me in the face :( Complete idiot it is, then.

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#37 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="Blueresident87"]

I think you said before that Zelda is pretty much superior in every way that matters most, and you're right. Okami has its place for what it does, Zelda is better overall.

Blueresident87

I personally think that Okami has a better overworld design than many Zeldas... It was a very fun game to explore. Only a few Zeldas compete with it, like MM and WW.

Not saying Okami is better though, just in that way.

Agreed that Okami does have better overworld design, but I don't find that the poor design of most worlds in Zelda hurts the games that much. A Link to The Past has the best overworld design of any Zelda game for me, along with MM and WW like you said. But even other Zelda games that lack in this department provide a solid 'Zelda' experience.

Oh totally I didn't mean to say the world designs in Zelda games are bad. Just that I think Okami got the feel of it down better than many Zelda games.

The reason I love MM and WW's worlds so much is because they actually feel like adventurous worlds.  MM is dripping with atmosphere, so there's always something cool to see or something to find.  WW just has a grand sense of advanture, of sailing toe ocean blue and really discovering new things. It's awesome.

IMO ALttP overworld is just all right, I think the game as a whole is kinda overrated. That being said, it's still one of the btter Zelda games, and definitely one of the all time greats. I just don't think it's as godly as some people say.

Avatar image for YoshiYogurt
#38 Posted by YoshiYogurt (6008 posts) -
Okami> A Link to the Past turtlethetaffer
I usually like your posts but this is just laughable. Anyway, Okami is an pretty fun.
Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#39 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]Okami> A Link to the Past YoshiYogurt
I usually like your posts but this is just laughable. Anyway, Okami is an pretty fun.

Like I said, flame shield raised. I don't really think ALttP is as godly as some people say. Is it a great game? Absoultely, one of the best. But I don't think it's God tier.

Avatar image for Blueresident87
#40 Posted by Blueresident87 (5657 posts) -

[QUOTE="YoshiYogurt"][QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]Okami> A Link to the Past turtlethetaffer

I usually like your posts but this is just laughable. Anyway, Okami is an pretty fun.

Like I said, flame shield raised. I don't really think ALttP is as godly as some people say. Is it a great game? Absoultely, one of the best. But I don't think it's God tier.

I think I have plenty of nostalgia that clouds my judgement of ALttP, in fact I know I do. I haven't played the game in a very long time. But I do remember the overworld being full of mystery and I remember it being interesting in a way that I wanted to explore it just as much as I wanted to conquer the dungeons. I don't think I've felt that for any other Zelda game save MM. As you said, MM has a tremendous overworld.

Avatar image for Emerald_Warrior
#41 Posted by Emerald_Warrior (6581 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="YoshiYogurt"] I usually like your posts but this is just laughable. Anyway, Okami is an pretty fun.Blueresident87

Like I said, flame shield raised. I don't really think ALttP is as godly as some people say. Is it a great game? Absoultely, one of the best. But I don't think it's God tier.

I think I have plenty of nostalgia that clouds my judgement of ALttP, in fact I know I do. I haven't played the game in a very long time. But I do remember the overworld being full of mystery and I remember it being interesting in a way that I wanted to explore it just as much as I wanted to conquer the dungeons. I don't think I've felt that for any other Zelda game save MM. As you said, MM has a tremendous overworld.

Very true. But the same holds true for the original Legend of Zelda, IMO. I bombed, flamed, and rocked-pushed the hell out of that overworld looking for secrets.

Avatar image for turtlethetaffer
#42 Posted by turtlethetaffer (18640 posts) -

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="YoshiYogurt"] I usually like your posts but this is just laughable. Anyway, Okami is an pretty fun.Blueresident87

Like I said, flame shield raised. I don't really think ALttP is as godly as some people say. Is it a great game? Absoultely, one of the best. But I don't think it's God tier.

I think I have plenty of nostalgia that clouds my judgement of ALttP, in fact I know I do. I haven't played the game in a very long time. But I do remember the overworld being full of mystery and I remember it being interesting in a way that I wanted to explore it just as much as I wanted to conquer the dungeons. I don't think I've felt that for any other Zelda game save MM. As you said, MM has a tremendous overworld.

Again, I'm not bashing ALttP in any way. I beat it a few years ago and it really is still a fantastic game. I just think Okami is better, that's all.  I liked the atmosphere, story and exploratory elements better, although ALttP had much better dungeon design.

From what I think, I'd say that Okami is more about the world and Zelda tends to be more about the dungeons. Not always, but a lot of the time.

And I think Wind Waker also had one of the better overworlds in the series.  It had a fantastic feeling of adventure. It just made you want to hop in the boat and set course for uncharted islands. (I thought the sailing wasn't bad, I liked the anticipation and found it relaxing.)  Although MM has quite possibly the best atmosphere in any game ever, WW is a close contender for one of the best overworlds in gaming.