Is Twilight Princess really the worst 3D Zelda game?

No, that title belongs to Wind Waker. Actually, it's more like the worst Zelda game ever made in my eyes. TP, on the other hand, is one of my favorite Zeldas.

Wow, pick between great games. The only One I have not finish was Wind Waker. I just hate the art design they used. I like celshading and a cartoon style but it just look ugly in Wind Waker.

Yes. It's still a great game, but it's a whole lot worse than all of the other 3D Zeldas.

I thought Skyward Sword was a whole lot worse.

I really liked Twilight Princess... It's the first Zelda game I played from start to finish.

Personally I thought Twilight Princess was the best Zelda game. I still haven't finished Skyward Sword and have yet to play Majora's Mask so I guess I'd pick Wind Waker as the worst Zelda on consoles.

i like twilight princess a lot, but it's my least favorite 3D zelda. with no gameplay hook to really tie into the theme and so many reused enemy designs, it felt a bit too much like fan service.

No it isn't. I'd say the worst 3D Zelda game on consoles is Wind Waker (though WW was still good IMO). If the DS games count though, then I'd say Phantom Hourglass is easily the worst.

Out of all the 3D Zelda titles I've played (having only not played Majora's Mask; waiting for that 3DS remake!) I would have to say Skyward Sword was the weakest, though it being a weak Zelda title doesn't mean it was a poor game. On the contrary, I still found Skyward Sword a strong and unique adventure that was better than a majority of similar titles.

Twilight Princess was my favorite Zelda game out of them all.

Edit: I did not include the DS titles in my opinion. I didn't like those as much as Zelda titles or games, so those would be lower than Skyward Sword if I included them.

Nope. I hate the wolf parts of the game, but I hate the time factor in majoras mask. MM is the worst.

No Skyward Sword is. The game had massive pacing issues at times which were enough to really hold the game back.

Take it back.

NEVER!!!

I've never wanted to kick somebody's azz like I wanted too with wind waker. AND, wind waker Is a kids game and I despise it.

Skyward Sword was the most rubbish Zelda game I have played so its hard to believe its was missed in your ever so fluent list.

I despise wind waker. it is the dumbest game ever created. great music and stupid stupid stupid stupid gameplay.

Worst Zelda it is my least favorite 3D Zelda but still a fine game.

WIND WAKER dominates the worst zelda game category.

It took like 05823190483 hours to get anywhere in that game (you had to equip the sail, change the wind direction, and after all that, it would still take like 10 minutes to get anywhere) there were virtually no side quests, the beginning sequence with you having to sneak around was way too long and boring, and some of the enemies like the hands that would reach and grab you, were just impossible to deal with and drove me to tears when I played this game as a kid.

Also didn't appreciate the dynamic action button commands or whatever they were called. That kind of system belongs in a resident evil game, not the Legend of Zelda series! The sword techniques in the Minish Cap and TWP were far better than these stupid action button commands!

Not to mention that most of the challenge in this game came from navigating the environment, like sidling along a wall, flying with the deku leaf, or using your partner to open doors. I'd much rather the challenge come from the enemies, the puzzles, and the sidequests like almost every other legend of zelda game.

I was very disappointed by this game and it's the only Zelda game that I have played and not finished.

Also, who the f voted that Ocarina of time was the worst!? Who was it!? You deserve to be killed along with your entire extended family.

they tried to make it too much like ocarina and lost originality

I don't really know the answer to that, but I saw my brother's friend play it at his house once. I wasn't impressed. So yes, to me it's bad, along with Wind Waker.