Yeah, this may very well be one of many topics, but whatever.
For me, I just couldn't get into Star Ocean: Till the End of Time. Sure, the combat was decent, but the ridiculous plot twist at the end pretty much made the game disappointing.
Also, Dark Cloud 1. Clunky combat, boring, cardboard characters, a rather weak storyline and the freaking WATER SYSTEM. Thankfully, Dark Cloud 2 is a MAJOR improvement. :)
*Raises flame shield* FF8. I just couldn't get into it for some reason. :/
Halo 2. The immense hype just killed off my will to play it. *shrug*
Cold Fear. I just couldn't get into it.