Fallout 3 or Skyrim or Dark Souls.

What’s it gonna be ?

These are my favorite RPG’s.

Which one would you choose over the other ?

Skyrim

Dark Souls

or

Fallout 3

Fallout 3 Mini Nukes the other two. No point discussing any further.

It seems every thread I've seen you make has Dark Souls mentioned in it, haha

All 3 are excellent games but if I really had to choose just one I'd go with Skyrim.

Fallout 3.

Morrowind. Sorry but that was the last of the good Bethseda sandbox RPG's. Oblivion and Skyrim were way too consolized and they took the exact same approach with Fallout.

First i would take Dark Souls and throw it in the toilet and then i would pickup Fallout 3 and sit down and enjoy myself for hours on end :D

Fallout New Vegas >>>>>>>>>>>All of those.

Fallout 3

Dark Souls

Skyrim

in that order..

I have not played Dark Souls, so it is between Fallout 3 and Skyrim.

I pick Skyrim.

Skyrim is a buggy mess with terrible writing and barely any gameplay.

Fallout 3 is an ugly, buggy mess with terrible writing and okay gameplay.

Dark Souls is a great game with deep, solid gameplay, and great art. So Dark Souls.

Fallout 3 no contest.

FTL....because FTL is that fucking bomb. Sorry, just got done talking about FTL in another thread. If you can't play FTL (and **** you for not playing it), I'd go with Fallout 3.

Fallout 3.

Dark Souls. Nothing else matters

My opinion ?

obviously, first one will be Darksouls (Extreme Addicting Games), next Skyrim (this one with its mod along would be one of most beauty game), last one Fallout 3 (Haven't played yet) LOL

I love Dark Souls and Skyrim, but Fallout 3 is the winner. It's only the greatest game I've ever played.

Morrowind is my second favorite game behind Fallout 3, but it's pretty annoying when people feel the need to state their opinion(which is off topic) and then bash the other games that people like. The topic is about Dark Souls, Skyrim, and FO3. If you don't like any of them, why come in here with your elitist attitude? Skyrim and Fallout 3 were huge successes and both have a large fanbase. Your sorrow opinion isn't going to change that.

Demon Souls>>Dark Souls>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> both Skyrim and Fallout 3

The suspense is killing me

And so I stumbled upon the "comparing green apples with red apples with car tires" thread.

@Black_Knight_00: And so you didn’t chose any of them ?

I wasn’t comparing.

I was asking which one you enjoyed the most.

@Murderstyle75: I wasn’t talking about Morrowind.

Consolized ?

I enjoyed Fallout 3 and Skyrim. On my PC.

What’s wrong with you ?

I guess it’s taste.

Deal With It

All of them, all of the unique and fun in their own rights. Stop making stupid comparisons please.

While I appreciate your enthusiasm, I had no intention of you suffering bodily harm. Call a doctor ASAP.

I've seen my GP and he says the only cure is the answer.

Hover your mouse over the text covered by black.

You're an internet wizard. I shall build a religion about you

Well thats easy, choose the one that offers the most autonomy over character creation and story.

Dark souls has better gameplay. If there was a game like Skyrim with the combat and rpg system like Dark Souls....well i'll stop myself before I get too lewd. Gotta go with Dark Souls.

Dark Souls easily. If you want a complete open world rpg, New Vegas, Gothic 2 or Morrowind would be much better choices than F3 or Skyrim.

I'm going with Fallout 3 on this one. Skyrim was good, but I enjoyed Fallout 3 more. Never played Dark Souls.

Please do not do that. >_>

I'd also pick Fall Out 3 in a heartbeat. First game to really "grab me" since ME. It had it all -- open world, unique story, fantastic locations (apocalypse notwithstanding), and it just seemed to have an "it" factor that kept me up late at night when I really should've been doing other things.

Finally picked up New Vegas yesterday, and it's already threatening me with the same involuntary captivity.