It was fun until expansion 11 came out, this review is for the game as a whole, not for just one expansion.
Now about the game itself. There is practically no solo content at all, and since there arent many new people starting it up, it is near impossible to get a group before level 46. Death in EQ is the most painful for any game- you have to run back to get your body (which I can deal with) but you also lose up to 10% of your experience for EACH death, which means that you can also lose a level. Clerics are becoming harder to find, and even then you are expected to fork over a good chuck of money just for a rez.
EQ is steadily getting worse because all SOE cares about, is pushing out two expansions a year, rather than trying to fix old things that need fixing. The old zones are practically deserted because no one ever goes there. If you want to play a First-Gen MMO, then EQ is the game for you, but if you want an online game that is actually fun, play something else.
Gameplay 5- Gets worse as time goes on. Old bugs that have been around for years still arent fixed, SoE only cares about money, so pushing out two crappy expansions a year is all they do.
Graphics 8- Ill admit the newer content does look real nice.
Sound 4- What sound, there isnt much besides hearing pain when your character gets hit. The in-game music is so bad that I have the volume turned off, and most of the zones dont even have music.
Value 6- If you want to play it, get the Titanium pack, it has the core game plus the first 10 expansions for 20$, thats a lot better than paying 30$ per expansion.