I choose Rapture.

User Rating: 9 | BioShock 2 PS3
While I wasn't in awe of Rapture like I was with the original, it didn't take away from it's intrigue, and it's creepy atmosphere. The storyline is strong, quality can't be questioned. They improved basically everything from the first, and added multiplayer(Pretty fun, grew on me). It isn't groundbreaking, they didn't take the series to the next level, they simply added and improved what was an already very good game. My only gripes are very minor. Playing as a big daddy, you are never as invincible as they seemed to be in the previous game. You take damage in the same way you did in the original, as a human. However, as you progress in the game, the big daddy proves to be a FAR more dynamic threat than you were previously. I am hardly a graphics whore, but it looks very similar to the previous version, which came out over 2 years ago. Rapture still looks amazing, but even a slight little gloss would have gone a long way. The hack tool is very handy, perhaps too handy. It really removes the threat of cameras and turrets, considering you can now just hack them safely from a distance. But again, these are minor gripes. The multiplayer comes off akward at first, especially if you are a Call of Duty/MAG/Battlefield ect player. However, as I progressed it became a very fun, and refreshing change of pace from other online shooters. Overall a very good game that was absolutely worth my $60.