Witcher 3 Studio Responds to Crunch Accusations

Anonymous "insider" claims trailers and demos are overly flattering; Studio says trailers speak for themselves.

612 Comments

Related
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Follow
Tap To Unmute
GS News Update: The Witcher 3 Dev Responds to Allegations of Overblowing Expectations

Want us to remember this setting for all your devices?

Sign up or Sign in now!

Please use a html5 video capable browser to watch videos.
This video has an invalid file format.
Sorry, but you can't access this content!
Please enter your date of birth to view this video

By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

A spokesperson for the studio creating The Witcher 3 has responded to claims that the team has been "crunching for over a year" in a bid to overcome development challenges.

Writing on the games forum NeoGAF, one anonymous user took issue with others praising the Witcher 3, claiming that developer CD Projekt Red has built an "overblown" impression of the game. After the anonymous poster's legitimacy was questioned, a NeoGAF administrator claimed they had been "vetted and cleared," suggesting these were not the words of an outsider.

The anonymous individual took issue with others "painting CD Projekt Red as some magical dev studio with only the best of interests of the gamers in mind. Trust me they are not."

He continued: "The bullsh**ting with the Witcher 3 started from day one. PR is creating an overblown vision of a game that doesn't exist while the team is in crazy crunch time for over a year now."

In response to these accusations, the studio's communications exec, Michał Platkow-Gilewski, told GameSpot that the video demonstrations of the game speak for themselves.

"In principle, we don't comment on rumors, especially when someone anonymous says that it’s 'his/her word against CDP PR,'" Platkow-Gilewski said in a prepared statement.

He added: "So, PR aside, if you have any doubts about Wild Hunt’s quality, have a look at the 35-minute gameplay video we published some time ago, or check out gamers' reactions to our public previews at Gamescom, San Diego Comic Con, and E3 (it's all public and available on the studio’s YouTube channel), and decide for yourself."

CD Projekt Red was asked specifically by GameSpot if the studio wanted to address claims that its team had been crunching--an industry term for working for an unreasonable and unhealthy amount of time in the office--for more than a year. The studio did not respond to this request.

Crunch is a common and ethically complex practice in games development. Many developers, whether self-employed or working at a studio, impose it on themselves. Others believe the practice is unequivocally unfair, especially if imposed on them, due to the detrimental effect crunch can have on quality of life.

In March, CD Projekt Red delayed The Witcher 3 release date to February 2015. At the time, the studio wrote: "We could have released the game towards the end of this year as we had initially planned. Yet we concluded that a few additional months will let us achieve the quality that will satisfy us, the quality gamers expect from us."

Click the thumbnails below to view images in gallery mode
Click the thumbnails below to view images in gallery mode
Gallery image 1Gallery image 2Gallery image 3Gallery image 4Gallery image 5Gallery image 6Gallery image 7Gallery image 8Gallery image 9
Gallery image 1Gallery image 2Gallery image 3Gallery image 4Gallery image 5Gallery image 6Gallery image 7Gallery image 8Gallery image 9Gallery image 10Gallery image 11Gallery image 12Gallery image 13Gallery image 14Gallery image 15Gallery image 16Gallery image 17Gallery image 18Gallery image 19Gallery image 20

Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? Email news@gamespot.com

Join the conversation
There are 612 comments about this story
612 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for sortajan
sortajan

all I care about is the finished product, and I haven't seen it yet. i reserve judgement until i've played the game myself.

Avatar image for hellsingfamily
Hellsingfamily

I feel like this should have happen with destiny lol

Avatar image for garcia_jx
garcia_jx

I don't think I could ever crunch, especially if it's mentally fatiguing. I can deal with physical fatigue, but not mental

Avatar image for darthvandersag
darthvandersag

I do see how a 'crunch' is a bad thing but I believe people are reading too much into this. Especially if the people involved are passionate about their product, they probably don't mind putting in that extra effort to make the game absolutely perfect. I know I wouldn't (and don't).

Avatar image for bluefox755
bluefox755

They're probably not as noble or "all about the players" as we all seem to think, but they're certainly closer than the majority of other devs out there.

Avatar image for DanZillaUK
DanZillaUK

Add to the mix free copies of Witcher 1&2 for anyone who bought them on Steam, so they can also have the DRM free copy to play/install on any computer they wish to, how can you dislike a group who back up what they claim and have gamers in mind? Sure they want to make money, everybody on earth does, but few go to those lengths to ensure customer satisfaction and re-enforce future business with consumers. Only thing I fault them on is making me wait so long to play Witcher 3, but that is just me being selfish and wanting my cake now :P

Avatar image for -blaklabel-
-blaklabel-

<< LINK REMOVED >> ur comment is a total fail, no one fucking about creating ur character, and what i find the worst fucking retard is,.... WHY THE **** WOULD U SPEND HOURS ON MAKING A CHARACTER WHEN THE GOAL IS TO PLAY.... about ur fucking retard DA3... what is dragon age... a gay copy no challenge of dark souls?

Avatar image for Xenro4
Xenro4

<< LINK REMOVED >> Create a character or not, a good game is a good game.

Avatar image for darthvandersag
darthvandersag

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> It isn't just good it's a great game. Probably one of the best there is if one were to make a list or something.

Avatar image for PCsama
PCsama

<< LINK REMOVED >> i played both of Witcher 1&2 (both were amazing),and Dragon Age 1&2 (the first was a blast BUT the second was a "CRAP"), when you hear the word witcher the first thing or picture comes to your mind is the face of the famous Geralt of Rivia, want to say that the both games hope to be great they both adopt the term "open world" from the infamous game skyrim and the issue of creating your won player isn't that big deal

Avatar image for solidsnake7882
solidsnake7882

<< LINK REMOVED >> Ok this deserves a response. Bioware did not lie on ME3 can't comment on DA2 haven't played but want to. I won't get into a point-counterpoint but if I remember correctly the article about ME3 was when they hadn't changed the story. It wasn't a lie. I will agree about letting trailers make your choice though.

Avatar image for Fernin-Ker
Fernin-Ker

<< LINK REMOVED >>


I think both games are going to be great. As for the character creation issue, I think it's a none issue when the character you're playing as a good one, which Geralt more than qualifies as. By your logic then The Nameless One must have been in a bad game...

Avatar image for trungtoto
trungtoto

gamespot now working on rumors ... how nice :)))

Avatar image for GunEye
GunEye

I hate CDPR and all they represent!


lol I wonder if an official spokesman will bother respond now ;)?!

Avatar image for leikeylosh
leikeylosh

Nice try, anonymous, but we still love CdProjekt. Until this day, they delivered exactly what they promised, not to mention the no-drm policy and respecting and listening to fans worldwide. It's gonna take more than that dubious statement to make us hate this amazing company.

Avatar image for GIF
GIF

Sounds like sour and bitter grapes. Everything I have seen and all of their games have delivered on the hype so why are people taking hype from a troll seriously?!

Avatar image for charlieholmes
charlieholmes

The reality of life is this, many jobs and professions involve crunch times. It's nothing old nor new, it's just real life. I crunched for 26 years at my profession and am now on the beach! It's how life really is. Just saying folks!

Avatar image for majere613
majere613

Yeah, no. I don't plan to get TW3, simply because for whatever reason Geralt and I don't seem to get on (still haven't finished 1 or 2) but accusing a dev that puts no copy-protection on its games of somehow trying to con people? Nope, that doesn't fly, son.

Avatar image for edant79
edant79

I never really fell into the CDPR love fest...but Witcher 1,2 were awesome, and 3 looks even better.

Avatar image for prickpear
PrickPear

An anonymous source.... a.k.a. some bitter Russian kid who's jealous of Poland's success goes talking smack about it, cause he thinks that will put a dent in their earnings..... either that or some rival developer from Dragon Age trying to hijack sales from CDPR, so that people go get DA instead. Why doesn't this anonymous source post his face pic online or go on YT? Let's see this anonymous leaker... why is he so afraid? This isn't Watergate, it's a video game. The kid sounds like what I described, a hijacking troll.

Avatar image for Neo_OnionKnight
Neo_OnionKnight

Pizza guy was upset, even though he delivered 30 mins early all the time, they never let him play or take a peek.

Avatar image for Vojtass
Vojtass

Unfortunately crunching is a common practice in the industry. The thing is that some companies don't pay for extra hours. CDPR does.

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >>

Its a common trick to give someone a title and pay him by the week instead of by the hours then have the person work 70 hours instead of 40. Some people live for a title, most others don't have a choice in the matter but figure it will be easier next time with a better resume.

Avatar image for dmdcsm
dmdcsm

Geez that's never been done before.... sounds about like every game made at one point or another

Avatar image for Warlord_Irochi
Warlord_Irochi

EVERY studio makes games for profit. Period. CD Project is definitely better than others, true, but they are not some kind of charity company either.
And Crunch time is not nice, but it comes with the profession (I don't buy that 1 year of crunch thing, makes no sense)

Avatar image for adwerk
adwerk

<< LINK REMOVED >> It was suppose to release this fall (now basically), so the crunch time would make sense as they'd basically just extended the release window thus the crunch time. Its not like they're gonna slow down because they got an extra ½ year of dev time.

Avatar image for Warlord_Irochi
Warlord_Irochi

<< LINK REMOVED >> Not the case. The article claims that they have been "crunching for over a year", not they are starting doing crunch time now.

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

Its capitalism. When you can treat people like slaves you do, when you can't you move production to third world countries. The good news about "crunch time" in the gaming industry is that once developers are done with creating a product for their masters they're often laid off as some sort of "thank you" from the administration.

They should expect some vacations somewhere in the first quarter of 2015.

Avatar image for lord_high_hippo
Lord_High_Hippo

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> "Its capitalism" Indeed, because in the real world only capitalism produced games like this and the technology that makes it possible.

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

I'm sure that in the Roman Empire some people praised slavery because slavery made possible wonders like the Coliseum, Roman aqueducts and whatever.

The thought hasn't occurred to you that CD PR is a Polish company? You know... an eastern European country with people benefiting some eastern European education? Oups, I guess capitalism is not needed anymore...

Avatar image for lord_high_hippo
Lord_High_Hippo

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> Really? Yes you must be correct because I am sure Poland was a world leader in entertainment back in communist days. And yeah, owning people in ancient Rome is EXACTLY like hiring people in a modern company who can quit if they want to, hahaha

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

So they can become slaves for someone else. And if you quit any job you can be sure the next employer will look at your resume very closely.

It was said that masters cared for their slaves since they owned them (like cattle) while in capitalism no one feels any obligations for their employees, and limit themselves to what they are forced to do under law.

As for an eastern education I think you could greatly benefit from one.

Avatar image for SingletreeAve
SingletreeAve

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> I work with a lot of people who (or is it "whom" dammit) have an eastern education and they have serious trouble thinking outside the box and often fail to consider the big picture instead of only the immediate task at hand. Just a personal observation.

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

I relate to Americans everyday and I'm always chocked by their profound naivety and lack of education as far as politics go. Not blaming them though because for most their education comes from the TV in their living room.

As for people from eastern Europe I've meet many and usually they're highly educated. Their only weakness is a certain naivety toward capitalism; nothing a few years at minimum wage can't dissipate, nothing a few years of exploitation from landlords can't dissipate.

Avatar image for SingletreeAve
SingletreeAve

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> Fair enough. The Europeans I know are extremely bright and well educated. I thought you were referring to a far eastern education (i.e. Asian), not eastern Europe. They are also highly intelligent, but tend to have a more rigid thought process in my experience. Anyway, we're all just humans with individual strengths and weaknesses, so it's all good.

Avatar image for dsa_das
dsa_das

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> Are you aware of the fact that Eastern Europe already attempted your communist utopia and as always it kinda did not work out?

Avatar image for SpicaAntares
SpicaAntares

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

Let's try understanding what you're saying. What is communism in your mind, what is utopia, is communism utopia only in Eastern Europe but not elsewhere, on what basis does something "kinda" works or not, does it "kinda" doesn't work one place and "kinda" works elsewhere?

Are you aware that "communist" China is one of the most powerful country on this planet, economically speaking? If communism itself is utopia ask yourself this: why the 20 years war in Vietnam, killing millions of people (US)? Why the overthrowing of Allende in Chile in 1973 (US sponsored)? Why the embargo on Cuba since 1960 (US)?

Don't you find it strange that utopia needs murder, bombs, CIA shenanigans, military dictatorships, embargo and so on to be stopped?

I could answer all these questions but I think you could benefit from finding them by yourself.

Avatar image for Zambash
Zambash

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >>

Avatar image for solidsnake7882
solidsnake7882

<< LINK REMOVED >>

That is very different. Those were new IPs. as for DA 2 have not played it but from what I've heard is that they changed some things and it really isn't that bad. As far as this goes CDPR has already established trust and Both games have been great. They aren't the type to lie. Everything we've seen proves this idiot wrong.