Feature Article

Shadow of Mordor's Wraith, and the Joys (And Tribulations) of Telling Original Stories in Middle-earth

Hand of silver.

It’s mid-July, and I'm sitting in a room with the charming and diplomatic Michael de Plater, director of design for the upcoming Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor. I've just seen the trailer embedded below, and already I've gone off on a tangent, chatting with de Plater about Gollum's animations, the thankless task of designing certain game elements that players only notice when they're bad, and the stresses of releasing a game set in such a well-known, well-loved fantasy universe.

Eventually, however, we turn the conversation to a more relevant subject: developer Monolith and publisher Warner Bros. Interactive will be confirming the identity of Shadow of Mordor's other main character--the wraith that shares a body with resurrected ranger Talion--at San Diego Comic-con. As it happens, the wraith is Celebrimbor, the Noldorin prince that forged the Rings of the Elves, though that won't come as much of a surprise to keen observers. (Even before the Comic-con reveal, Wikia's Shadow of Mordor wiki already states it as brute fact.)

Please use a html5 video capable browser to watch videos.
This video has an invalid file format.
Sorry, but you can't access this content!
Please enter your date of birth to view this video

By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

We should probably get to the big news, the announcement that you guys are making for Comic-con. What are you revealing?

We've talked a lot about the living world and the nemesis system, but not a lot about the story, and we've talked about Talion a little bit, but really, we actually do have two main characters of pretty much equal weighting in terms of their stories and the role that they play. Something we went back and forward a lot on is, how big of a spoiler is it to reveal that the wraith is in fact this character of Celebrimbor as well?

All of the people who have explored the lore deeply enough can work out who he is anyway, from his traits, and his attributes, and that he forged the Rings of Power, and so on. For the people who haven't heard of him, or have seen the movies, it's just a little bit of research. It's really interesting to discover this character who is more complex and more nuanced than maybe what we think of most elves. And plus, going into the game with that little bit of back knowledge, that'll be extra history for where we take our story from that point--the twists, the turns, the revelations, and how we move towards the conclusion, and how the conflict with Sauron gets even richer.

No Caption Provided

That's what we're excited about with Comic-con, revealing who this guy is, why we chose him as a character, why he's so interesting, what his relationship to Sauron is. And also, I think the authenticity he brings to even the gameplay itself--one of the assumptions people sometimes make in Tolkien is the level of power in some of the characters, because they don't see Gandalf fling the fireballs around, that that sort of level of power is somehow inauthentic. But of course, Gandalf is restricted, there are rules placed on him that he's not allowed to do that. He can't take on Sauron toe to toe, he can't match him in power, he has to work by inspiring people and bringing out the best in others.

Celebrimbor is not someone who has that restriction. He is in the situation Galadriel was in when Frodo said "I'm offering you the ring of power." Galadriel's reaction was that you wouldn't have a dark lord but a dark queen, so I'm not going to do that. Celebrimbor is obviously a much prouder character, a much darker character. Partly he wants to bring down Sauron, but partly he's also trying to achieve a redemption for what seem like his sins, his shame in allowing himself to be deceived by Sauron.

I've seen reactions both positive and negative to the idea of this sort-of wraith/human hybrid. From what you've seen, what's been the reaction to the idea, and are you hoping that with more explanation for the story coming out, that that will help buoy people's understanding?

No Caption Provided

The level of power--and by power, I mean the way Tolkien means power--of a character like Celebrimbor does add to the authenticity and the feasibility. The one I get frustrated with is, sometimes people say "Oh, we haven't seen exactly this thing before in Tolkien's writings, we haven't seen an exact example of this type of wraith, therefore it can't happen." But in reading Tolkien, there's nothing like the army of the dead until we've seen the army of the dead. There's nothing like the barrow-wights until we've seen the barrow-wights. There's nothing like the dead marshes until we've seen the dead marshes. There's not exactly a consistent way in which the ringwraiths are handled. Do they have flesh? Do they not have flesh? Are they physical? Are they corporeal? Are they incorporeal? I think a key part of the authenticity is that you do want to introduce something with a bit of mystery and a bit of wonder, but is still authentic in the canon, in the myth, in what we already know. I don't think we would ever want to limit ourselves to only showing things that have been specifically included or shown in the books.

I don't think there's ever a situation where you're going to make every purist happy. There's a guy, probably one of the most respected Tolkien scholars in the world--he was also one of the consultants on the films, a guy called Tom Shippey. And he gave a really good lecture the other day--there's a link to it on theonering.net--and he basically spoke to that point. There's a group of people whose greatest pleasure is pointing out faults or flaws, and the way he expressed it was, "the prize goes to the person who makes the biggest fuss about the smallest detail."

Partly he wants to bring down Sauron, but partly he's also trying to achieve a redemption for what seem like his sins, his shame in allowing himself to be deceived by Sauron.

Michael de Plater, Director of Design, Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor

The single biggest thing for us that we've adapted to suit our story is also something changed in the films. In the Hobbit movie, we see that they go to the tomb in Fornost, and we see that the Witch-king has escaped from his tomb. The Witch-king of Angmar, when he was defeated thousands of years ago, his body was entombed and now he's resurrected, and both he and Sauron are back. In the movie that worked really well, but it's really compressing a timeline of a lot of things that actually happened in the books. And we've actually done that one as well, so we've compressed that timeline that said that Sauron and the Nazgul have reawakened at that time and have returned.

It's not changing anything per se, but shuffling around some of the events--but to some people, that's a really big deal, because it was the Witch-king who fled at the Battle of Fornost, and Glorfindel said "No, don't chase him because there's no point, it's not by the hand of man that he will die." That's the prophecy that ultimately feeds into where Eowyn stabs the Witch-king in the face and says "I am no man." Shifting that detail does have ripple effects, so there's little things like that--little or not so little. Overall it's about being as authentic as possible, but I don't see any scenario in which you make everyone absolutely happy.

No Caption Provided

Usually we see Lord of the Rings stories that feature characters we know, and take place in places we spend a lot of time in in the novels. In Shadow of Mordor, we spend a lot of time with characters that we don't know in Mordor, a place that hasn't been greatly explored in games. It seems like you've got a much longer leash attaching you to the world, a much larger space in which to work your magic and do something original with.

I can't remember who said it, or what [intellectual property] they were saying it in relation to, but that they were trying to copy the disease and not its symptoms. Those two things which you just mentioned, one is constantly visiting new places and seeing things that haven't been done, and Tolkien does that constantly. Between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, they touch in a couple of places, but overall, you're constantly seeing new things as well. You find something highly detailed and iconic like Gollum, so you can anchor on it, but then there are all these spaces you can go in. And I think it's what helps the overall scale of the world feel bigger and more authentic, and again, The Hobbit, it's a standalone story with all these threads and connections to The Lord of the Rings.

I don't think there's ever a situation where you're going to make every purist happy.

Michael de Plater

Like The Necromancer hardly gets touched on in The Hobbit but is obviously a really key character, and these are big events. In the same way, Celebrimbor is great, because he's not actually mentioned very often, but he's really key, forging the Rings of Power, and also key as an elf who isn't just a good guy. We wanted to follow The Hobbit [as it relates to The Lord of the Rings], something that works as an epic standalone story with tendrils that go out to the big picture.

We've got Peter Jackson's vision of what these places and people are like, and for a lot of people, that's what we think about. Do you ever find yourself feeling limited in what you can do, because another artist has gotten there first? Do you feel beholden to staying true to that person's vision even when they don't stay close to the original details?

The thing that was most inspiring about the movies from the get-go is that they are very true to the spirit of the books and most of the details, and whenever something does change, it's for a very good reason that makes for a better movie. They are as authentic as they can be while still being the best movies they can be. We try to follow the same philosophy, absolutely as authentic, and all the attention to detail, and if anything is changed at all, in the same way if they change anything it's to make a better film, we're doing it to make the best game that we can make. Different media do have some differences, and we want to make the best game we can make that's absolutely true to the material.

So you've got these examples of what Peter Jackson's movies are compared to Tolkien's books, or what the Arkham games are compared to Chris Nolan's movies, and so you do the absolute best thing you can do within your own medium that's also as true as you can possibly make it. And not just retelling the same stories people have already seen, which is a fundamentally dull thing--it's not something Tolkien ever did, or would ever do, is just retread the same ground. But trying to be authentic and trying to tell a good standalone story.

No Caption Provided

One of the first things that struck me when I first saw Shadow of Mordor was its pervasive sense of weight and dread. In The Lord of the Rings novels, we get respite, we get an oasis. I'm curious--you've got a universe that's not just Mordor, but you've got The Shire, you've got Rohan, you've got lots of complementary ideas. When you've got a game that takes place in Mordor, how do you provide an oasis to the player?

That was a really important issue for us, and we attacked it from a few different directions. Firstly, it was part of the fun of Mordor at this time--Sauron has just returned, he hasn't been there for two-thousand years, so we don't have to make it into the blasted hellscape that we see later. It is more of a place that's in transition, so there are bits of it that are still green. And it's interesting to think of Mordor as a living place; Sauron has to feed armies, he has to grow crops, he can't just have this blasted land with troops marching over--it has to function. It's on the brink of this totalitarian domination, but it's still turning into that.

No Caption Provided

The other approach to that was in the writing. [Lead writer] Christian [Cantamessa] and [voice actors] Troy [Baker] and Alistair [Duncan] did a great job of bringing humor into the story so that it's not constantly grim and dark, and there are some really relatable moments in there. Additionally--it's obviously weighted more towards dark humor--but one of the key writers we had on the nemesis system was a guy called Dan Abnett, and he's written a bunch of great comics. With Andy Lanning he did a lot of the Guardians of the Galaxy reboot that's become the next big Marvel thing, and he did some of the best Warhammer 40K novels, where I think his are differentiated by injecting some humanity and some humor into them.

I think that humor is really important to lift the tone, and that's a key part of the nemesis system. People want to meet and re-encounter these [orcs], they want to hear what they're going to say--that combination of having them remember you and reacting to you, and having lots of amusing stuff to say, really does lighten it. And then there's down time. If you don't want the relentless combat, or pursuing the story, there's a lot of secrets to uncover and explore. You can uncover the history and learn more about the lore, learn about the wraith and the history of Mordor.

So game players and even people like in the media like to condense games into a simple description. We might say [Shadow of Mordor] is sort of like Assassin's Creed in Mordor, or it's Batman: Arkham Asylum in Mordor. Do you think the project has been helped or hindered by those kinds of comparisons?

No Caption Provided

They do both. On balance, I think it's a good thing. It's an entry point, we exist within a genre, open-world third-person action. People will always map you to something. We're mapped to an action game. We have strong [role-playing game] elements, and a lot of the time people see fantasy and the first place they're gonna go to is they're gonna think you're an RPG. The fact that people are mapping us to an action game, and understanding that moment-to-moment action and gameplay, is a good thing. If they didn't do that, maybe they'd be mapping us more to The Witcher, Dragon Age, or Skyrim.

For us, it's a big deal when people get their hands on it, because when they start to play, there's impressions that people get and reactions that they have is that there's more to it. If there is an area where it's fine for people to make comparisons, it's that we want people who have played Batman to pick [Shadow of Mordor] up and feel comfortable with the controls.

So surely you're ready to move on to new projects now. Shall I assume that Condemned 3 and a new No One Lives Forever are in the works?


I'll take that as a yes. [Editor's note: Don't take that as a yes.]

Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? Email news@gamespot.com


Kevin VanOrd

Kevin VanOrd has a cat named Ollie who refuses to play bass in Rock Band.
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor

Back To Top
60 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
  • 60 results
  • 1
  • 2
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for scorpionz9

I came to this article epecting to see SMASH MONTAGE... GS fix your links ....

Avatar image for Jimminyfixit

7/10 if reviewed by the KVO - man that guy's stringent!

8 or 9 I reckon personally......

Avatar image for S-181

I think a golden opportunity for a Middle Earth game would be Aragorn's long journey deep into the South and East, areas almost entirely unexplored in Tolkien's writings, and literally off the maps provided in the Lord of the Rings. (Appendix A to the Lord of the Rings: "He rode in the host of the Rohirrim, and fought for the Lord of Gondor by land and by sea; and then in the hour of victory he passed out of knowledge of Men of the West, and went alone far into the East and deep into the South, exploring the hearts of Men, both evil and good, and uncovering the plots and devices of the servants of Sauron. Thus he became at last the most hardy of living Men...") Sounds to me like the perfect premise for an open-world action RPG like Shadow of Mordor - there are opportunities for an enormous amount of creativity, as well as nods to Tolkien's writings. The Blue Wizards who disappeared into the East could play a part, and the culture of Harad could be explored, and the Black Numenoreans, the possibilities are endless.

As for this game, using Celebrimbor is indeed a masterstroke, but I'm nevertheless not expecting something up to the quality of Tolkien, or Jackson's movies (story-wise). That is in no way going to stop me enjoying the game however, assuming it ends up as good as it seems so far.

Avatar image for Hurvl

"the prize goes to the person who makes the biggest fuss about the smallest detail" I can think of many worthy contenders for that prize on this site :P.

Wraith thingy sounds a bit contrived, like they wanted to justify this game's existence by making their own personal mark on the brand and so went out of their way to come up with something not done before. Original and different being more important than anything else. Yeah, sure, whatever, you can have your contrived story and premise as long as you give me something that's fun to play.

Avatar image for themc_7

I'm pumped for this game. I wish I knew more about the lore surrounding this fantastic universe. Other than the movies and a few of the games, I don't know much about the LOTR.

Avatar image for jecomans

The epic month of October, for so long lingering on the distant horizon, now seems to be almost upon us.

Avatar image for themc_7

<< LINK REMOVED >> October is gonna be insane. I've got like 6 major releases in a 6 week time frame.

Avatar image for jecomans

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> Similar here; 5 definitely's, and 3 maybe's. I might take a week off for, uh, 'religious holidays'.

Avatar image for Godien

This was a really great article; Kevin, you never disappoint.

Avatar image for homelessgamer

Kevin is the the bomb, not giant but still pretty cool.

Avatar image for clay865

I've had my next gen console for about 4 months now. This will be the first game I buy.

Avatar image for epicsymphony

Yup, take my money.

Avatar image for deactivated-59ef89729997b

<< LINK REMOVED >> Your missing a word in the second quote.

Avatar image for jonnyb81

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> You're missing an apostrophe and an "E" in your first word.

Avatar image for homelessgamer

You're missing a capital letter in you're name. Who gives a rats as's

Avatar image for Stebsis

<< LINK REMOVED >> Non of your kan wirte sith!

Avatar image for Kevin-V

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> Thanks for the heads up! This has been fixed.

Avatar image for jecomans

<< LINK REMOVED >> Great write up. Continually more excited about this game.

Avatar image for robbansj

That last trailer is so damn good, cant wait for this game.

Avatar image for GunEye

You know this game does look amazing. I honestly can't wait to play it. I hope they release a playable demo of it. Let's hope it will turn out to be as great a game as we all hope: in terms of story, gameplay, depth, visuals, performance and more. I love the fact they are bringing fresh new ideas, and showing their take on the Middle Earth and lore. I less fond of the fact they are overusing the same art style of the weapons, and Gollums old look from the movies - it's overdone.

Avatar image for Dredcrumb9

Off topic, but I just watched all of the extended cuts of the Lord of the Rings trilogy on blu-ray and I am floored. These are the best 3 movies ever made by any director. Peter Jackson did these? The same guy who made Bad Taste and Meet the Feebles? Wow, just wow....

Avatar image for Dark_Rage

This game .. looks amazing.

Avatar image for GunEye

<< LINK REMOVED >> let us hope it will really be that way.

Avatar image for LucentWolf

I don't want to be interested in this game. I have enough on my effin plate already. >.<

Avatar image for Hurvl

<< LINK REMOVED >> I've had enough on my plate for years already, but luckily games don't mould, so I can just have it sit there and nibble at it bit by bit.

Avatar image for sopichan

So this game takes place sometime in between the 60 years that go by between The Hobbit and LotR, that should be really fun to experience :)

Avatar image for Afinati

"If they didn't do that, maybe they'd be mapping us more to The Witcher, Dragon Age, or Skyrim." I can appreciate that.

Avatar image for Ayzed

I can't wait for this game man it looks awesome. Day one buy for me

Avatar image for irsoccer05

Lot's of good games releasing over the next year or two. This game looks like it'll be a strong one.

Avatar image for oflow

I wish they had just made the main character an Orc. The half wraith guy kinda tramples on the lore (this guy is really going to challenge Sauron for the control of Mordor? Really?) and is just kinda corny. At least an orc organizing other orcs would be more plausible.

I do kinda like the looks of it though so I'll probably pick it up.

Avatar image for KerrinScott

<< LINK REMOVED >> it doesn't trample at all.

The process of becoming a wraith is never strictly defined in ANY of the lore -- neither The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, nor The Silmarillion. There are hints that it's a "wasting" of sorts -- much like Denethor's madness is portrayed in the films (though not at all in the books). So, I don't think it's really a departure at all.

Though it does bump up against the notion that all elves MUST travel to the Halls of Mandos in order to be resurrected into the world, this too is never made patently clear. And there is a lot of precedent for *wraiths* in the mythos itself. In fact, once the ring is utterly destroyed Sauron does not actually *die* but rather is dispersed -- never again able to take his physical form -- and becomes a "spirit of malice that gnaws itself in the shadows."

He can never take any corporeal form again, but it may be that he yet exerts *some* measure of influence.

The Nazgul are obviously a good example as well, as are the Dead Men of Dunharrow.

I agree with de Plater; I actually think it's a brilliant stroke to choose Celebrimbor as the protagonist (...maybe the antagonist in a sense). He would certainly have the motivation; his story is not strictly detailed; we don't know precisely what lead to his downfall, how he was tormented by Sauron, and he is a completely LEGITIMATE power player in the lore. He wasn't just the greatest smith of the second age; he was a Noldorin prince, the grandson of the GREATEST of all elves -- Feanor (who forged the Silmarils, but was corrupted by their beauty and died in his pursuit of them after Melkor stole them). His entire line swore a blood oath to retrieve them, and ALL of his sons perished for it. It's entirely reasonable to assert that Celebrimbor is on the same level as characters like Gil-Galad, Galadriel, Elrond, Cirdan, Glorfindel, etc.

I'm super stoked about this reveal...

And being a very serious Tolkien fanboy, I'm super glad to see them take these kinds of liberties. I feel like this is PRECISELY the kind of story Tolkien would want someone to tell with his mythos.

Avatar image for evilace_stealth

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> I trust this very serious fanboy, you made a good case - I'm getting this game.

Avatar image for KerrinScott

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> This is the first game in several years that I have seriously considered pre-ordering. I recognize that my fanboyism is no guarantee that it will be excellent. But the devs have said all the right things -- about they mythos, about the gameplay, about their intentions...

The gameplay is highly reminiscent to me of Arkham City moreso than AC, but I enjoy both series so I'm totally okay with that. They haven't really said much about the leveling or progression system, but, again, it seems to be an excellent mixture of both. It genuinely seems like the whole package. And I've been letdown enough by LotR franchises in the past (...here's looking directly at you with a piercing gaze War in the North!) that I'm wary of just about every property that takes on the name.

Anyway, I am very excited about this game...

Avatar image for Evanduil

<< LINK REMOVED >><< LINK REMOVED >> You sir, win the internet for today.

Avatar image for clay865

Waaaaaaaaaaay too long of a comment.

Avatar image for KerrinScott

<< LINK REMOVED >> It's cool. I understand that reading is hard.

Avatar image for STrugglingFool

While I would like to buy it, one must wait when it comes to PC. For others have come and disappointed me.

  • 60 results
  • 1
  • 2