Iwata: "Customers do not want online games"

Outspoken executive tells Japanese press that online-enabled gaming is on the way out, drops hints of a Bandai partnership.


For years one of the major complaints about the GameCube has been its lack of online-enabled games. Judging by comments made last week by Nintendo president Satoru Iwata, that won't be changing anytime soon.

In an interview with the Japan Economic Foundation's magazine, Japan Spotlight, the famously outspoken Iwata repeated his oft-quoted assertion that "customers do not want online games." He told the Spotlight, "At the moment, most customers do not wish to pay the extra money for connection to the Internet, and for some customers, connection procedures to the Internet are still not easy."

To back up his claims, Iwata pointed to sales during the 2003 holidays. "During the year-end shopping season last year, none of the online games succeeded," he said. "All the games that sold well were off-line games." Iwata did not name any games specifically, referring only to lackluster sales of "SCEI’s online golf game," presumably Hot Shots Golf Fore!, which was released last November in Japan. (The game is due in North America next month.)

But while Iwata's disdain for online play was clear, he would not abandon the concept altogether. "Online technology has its own interesting features, so I don’t rule out the possibility of making use of it for games," he said. Iwata also said that the industry would soon come around to his point of view. "Game companies now find it difficult to make online game businesses successful, and their enthusiasm for them is cooling," he predicted.

The Nintendo president also used the interview to fire a few broadsides against Sony's upcoming PSP. He dismissed the PSP and Sony's PSX PlayStation 2/personal video recorder hybrid as "entertainment goods," not true gaming machines. "I think customers will not regard the Nintendo DS as having the same purpose as the PSP." He even went so far as to say that the two portables were so different as to not qualify as competitors. "Just as the GameCube does not compete with the PSX, the Nintendo DS will not compete head-to-head with the PSP."

Iwata also brushed off charges that Nintendo's games are geared too much toward children. "Game software should neither be exclusively targeted at children nor adults," he told the Spotlight. "Instead, we will develop software which anyone can instantly understand." Iwata singled out WarioWare Inc.: Mega MicroGame$ and Donkey Konga as shining examples of all-ages games. "When we market new software for adults, we should publicize it as software that everyone can enjoy... That will be more effective than undertaking a promotion specifically aimed at adults."

As always, Iwata's commentary was engaging. However, it was his comments on Nintendo's relationship with Bandai that got industry watchers' attention. When asked whether Nintendo's purchase of 2.6 percent of Bandai's stock could be a precursor to a merger between the companies, Iwata demurred--at first. "It all started when a holder of Bandai shares approached us," he told the Spotlight. "We bought the shares as Bandai’s business value and stock price were balanced." Then he hinted that Nintendo and Bandai could indeed start some form of joint projects. "We already had a relationship with Bandai, as we had marketed Bandai’s software," he said. "A closer relationship would be beneficial for both sides and it will be nice if the two companies can work together in doing something interesting."

Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? Email news@gamespot.com

Join the conversation
There are 11 comments about this story
11 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for supertom221

Ahah.... Guess he was wrong afterall.

Avatar image for UltimateXShadow

Times change.

Avatar image for ChiefFreeman

Sorry Mr. Iwata, but you were wrong about online.

Avatar image for LynQ

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

Avatar image for darkzerogamer

Yeah nobody wants on line play, tell that to the people who log onto xbox live every day to play madden or halo 3.

Avatar image for THizzle7XU

Ya, everyone sure came around to see his views on online gaming... I mean, what the hell was Microsoft thinking? Xbox Live, nobody wants to pay even more money on top of their Internet connection! Oh, except for several million people... How could you even say back then that Internet gaming had no potential? Even the blind could see it would be huge, especially with Halo 2 on the horizon at that point. Plus, hadn't he heard of PC games like Counter Strike and UT by then?

Avatar image for Flashx11

Well, this isn't as unreasonable as you think; Iwata's point is that if the game relies on online play to be a good, worthwhile (and cash) game, it can't depend on the Internet. Also, the Wii is able to access the internet for free, something the gamecube is/was incapable of without additional hardware (and thus, $). Essentially, most of the barriers preventing online play have been removed (partially, at least). So, no, you can't really hold Iwata to this. This actually kind of reminds me of when Steve Jobs said that no one wanted to watch movies on that small of a screen (referring to an iPod), and then the iPod Video came out. Same trick by Iwata...? Not only that, but saying what he said guarantees that Iwata wouldn't eat his words either way; if online games didn't catch on, then he was right; if they didn't, then all the better for Nintendo

Avatar image for Timstuff

That idiot Iwata would be eating his words right now if Wii wasn't illogically popular right now. Basically though, he has a knack for being wrong about fads and the game industry in general, so it wouldn't surprise me if he's wrong about Wii not being a fad.

Avatar image for TurtlePerson2

Iwata was right, online was just a phase. Not!

Avatar image for Gribb85

Doesn't surprise me Iwata always seems to have a different slant on the gaming business then other big wigs in the industry. Just gotta have faith in the main, and thank the big one above that someone is taking gaming in a completely different direction

Avatar image for nerdmike

hmm.... no online for the game cube, no HD for the Wii something tells me that