Dr Disrespect Is Now Streaming On YouTube, Claims He Doesn't Know Why Twitch Banned Him
Streamer Dr Disrespect has hopped over to YouTube, following his unceremonious banning from Twitch.
Update: Herschel "Guy" Beahm, better known as Dr Disrespect, has returned, and he's now streaming on YouTube following an announcement on Twitter. It is still believed that there is no deal in place between YouTube and Beahm. Nevertheless, he has taken to streaming on the platform and, to begin with, addressed his banning from Twitch. Although he expressed frustrations, Beahm did not provide any explanation for why the ban was issued, instead noting that he was not given much notice and in the time since the justification has not become clear to him. "We still have no idea ... so just let the legal professionals just do what they need to do," he said.
At the time of writing, his stream peaked at 510k concurrent viewers, showing that his popularity has transferred over from Twitch to YouTube. Some other high-profile streamers, including Ninja, have gone back to Twitch after the dissolution of Mixer. They had previously signed enormous contracts to stream exclusively on Mixer.
The original story follows.
More than a month after the action was taken against his account, we still don't know why Beahm was banned. His punishment is one of the highest-profile bans in Twitch history. It remains unclear if Twitch is planning to address the reason in more detail in the future. Likewise, we don't yet know where he may head next; his Twitter profile link has recently been updated to point to YouTube, but there's no indication of an official partnership with that platform or any other. A voice clip shared on his Instagram page during a live video teased that he could be returning to stream on August 6. However, it is unclear if this was intended as a joke. According to esports consultant Rod Breslau, neither YouTube nor Facebook have offered him a partnership. A pinned tweet says he will be streaming on August 7, and his YouTube channel is streaming a static scene at the moment.
He has teased that he's considering a lawsuit against Twitch, but so far there have been no developments on that front, suggesting it may simply be posturing.
Why Was Dr Disrespect Banned From Twitch?
It's unclear exactly why or how long Dr Disrespect will be banned. Following news of the ban, Dr Disrespect did not say anything publicly about the situation, and searching for his Twitch account yielded no results. However, on June 27, a day after news of the ban broke, Beahm broke his silence and posted an update on Twitter, addressing his fans. According to the streamer, Twitch has not provided him with any specific reason for the ban. Meanwhile, Monday's temporary suspension of Donald Trump was accompanied by specific reasoning, with Twitch even citing specific violations of its "hateful conduct" policy.
Dr Disrespect's Statement On His Ban
Champions Club,— Dr Disrespect (@drdisrespect) June 28, 2020
Twitch has not notified me on the specific reason behind their decision... Firm handshakes to all for the support during this difficult time.
Regarding Dr Disrespect's ban, Twitch has offered no specific explanation for the move publicly. Of course, this has left room for speculation. Some have suggested that it could be the result of a DMCA takedown (of which there has been a flurry recently). However, this would ordinarily result in a temporary ban, and there is no sign of that happening.
Beahm finally gave an interview to the Washington Post regarding his ban on July 16. He expressed incredulity about Twitch's decision. However, his legal and publicity teams limited what he could and couldn't answer. Legal action against Twitch is being considered, although it's unclear if this is merely posturing or a route he actually intends to pursue.
"It was a total shock," he said. "Imagine showing up to work and the doors are closed and you can't get inside."
Beahm later shared an ominous video on his Twitter account, backed by moody music. It wasn't clear what purpose it served but it was his first tweet since late June. The timing roughly coincided with the round of interviews that were also published in mid-July. These interviews ultimately gave little explanation for his actions that could have led to the ban. He said he won't be returning to the platform.
Twitch's Statement On Dr Disrespect's Ban
When we reached out to Twitch for comment, we were given the same generic statement already offered to the wider community: "As is our process, we take appropriate action when we have evidence that a streamer has acted in violation of our Community Guidelines or Terms of Service. These apply to all streamers regardless of status or prominence in the community."
The Twitch Community Reacts To Dr Disrespect's Ban
Dr Disrespect was banned from the livestreaming platform back in June 2019 for broadcasting from a public restroom at E3. The ban only lasted two weeks and saw a divisive response from the Twitch community.
According to esports reporter Rod Breslau, Dr Disrepsect's ban is not related to a DMCA measure, and is in fact a permanent ban, rather than a temporary one. This was the first indication there could be something more serious going on than a simple copyright issue. Twitch is also giving refunds to those who had subscribed to his channel and his emotes are no longer on the site.
Sources: DrDisrespect has been permanently banned from Twitch— Rod "4475 SR & Immortal peak" Breslau (@Slasher) June 26, 2020
Sources: it is not DMCA— Rod "4475 SR & Immortal peak" Breslau (@Slasher) June 26, 2020
Breslau also shared a video from Beahm's final stream that showed him struggling to speak, possibly because he knew what was about to happen.
watching a video of the last 8 minutes of todays DrDisrespects stream, he changes behavior abruptly and mumbles out an extremely odd ending— Rod "4475 SR & Immortal peak" Breslau (@Slasher) June 27, 2020
"We'll...we'll get through this champions. life's weird right now....we'll get through this okay. and uh.....fuck" pic.twitter.com/sXXHRbtVij
Zach Bussey, who reports on Twitch happenings, indicated there won't be a public statement shared by Twitch regarding the ban, but that he too has heard it is permanent.
I've just been informed that there will be NO public statement made by Twitch - but the corporate communication team is responding to press inquiries.— Zach Bussey (@zachbussey) June 26, 2020
This is a big one folks. I think Doc is gone. #TwitchNews
Official Twitch Statement:— Zach Bussey (@zachbussey) June 26, 2020
"As is our process, we take appropriate action when we have evidence that a streamer has acted in violation of our Community Guidelines or Terms of Service. These apply to all streamers regardless of status or prominence in the community."
Another streamer, Shannon Plante (AKA ShannonZKiller), indicated that she's heard the Dr Disrepect ban is a permanent one, adding that the cause is "serious." She offered no further specifics, saying she knows the reason for the ban but that she "cannot say" more. She does state that he is "done, and not just on Twitch." At the time of this writing, his YouTube channel and Twitter account remain online, but Plante deleted her tweet.
From my own sources: Doc is indeed done, and not just on Twitch. I know why and cannot say. But this is serious.— Shannon (@ShannonZKiller) June 26, 2020
Dr Disrespect's ban comes not long after Twitch removed several other prominent streamers for alleged sexual abuse and harassment, including IamSp00n, BlessRNG, DreadedCone, and others. Earlier this week, Twitch said it would be issuing permanent suspensions following its investigation into these allegations. The accusations led to a Twitch blackout, with streamers staying off the platform for a day to encourage the streaming service to take action against abusers.
Giphy Removes Dr Disrespect GIFs
Popular GIF hosting service Giphy has also apparently removed GIF material featuring Beahm from its site. This is despite the reasoning behind the ban still not being made public.
Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? Email firstname.lastname@example.org