BioShock PC Remasters Having Issues; Only Slightly Better, Steam Reviews Say

Steam users have reported that the BioShock 1 and 2 remasters have a slew of problems.

75 Comments
Please use a html5 video capable browser to watch videos.
This video has an invalid file format.
00:00:00
Sorry, but you can't access this content!
Please enter your date of birth to view this video

By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Now Playing: BioShock Retrospective

We recently found out that BioShock: The Collection blocks streaming on consoles, and now the PC remasters are getting a fair bit of flack. Steam users have reported that the original BioShock features new and old bugs and lacks a variety of settings that are commonly found in PC games.

Many users claim that the game is not remastered but instead "retextured," as it only features "better lighting and a VERY slightly sharper texture pack," says user Hotshot. Crashes are also present for many players trying to make their way into Rapture via the Bathysphere.

Another common issue players are experiencing is mouse acceleration, which was present in the original game. Steam user Cheesus said, "They didn't touch all the mouse issues that plagued the original. Mouse sensitivity slider doesn't work right. If you lower the sensitivity to 1, the mouse cursor doesn't [move] unless you fling your mouse." Players have also criticized the lack of an FOV slider.

BioShock 2 has gotten its fair share of negative reviews as well, with users saying its graphical settings are minimal and the visuals are only marginally better.

Despite the bad reviews, BioShock 1 and 2 Remastered have almost the same amount of positive critiques, though some users like DigitalCreation still note that the original game's "graphics are only slightly better."

No Caption Provided
Gallery image 1Gallery image 2Gallery image 3Gallery image 4Gallery image 5Gallery image 6Gallery image 7Gallery image 8Gallery image 9Gallery image 10Gallery image 11Gallery image 12Gallery image 13

"It's certainly not terrible, but it's lazy," DigitalCreation said. "Old bugs from the original game are still present and the graphics are only slightly better. This is the best version only because of the small graphics update."

Many players have noted that it's best played with a controller, something many PC players take issue with given the platform's added precision of keyboard and mouse.

We've contacted 2K for comment on the PC versions' issues and will keep you updated as we hear back. BioShock Infinite is unaffected by the problems mentioned above, as it did not receive a remastered edition.

The BioShock remasters came out on PC two days after the full collection released on consoles. We've tested BioShock: The Collection on PS4 and Xbox One, and they run well with infrequent frame rate drops. You can read our preview of the console version here, which called them "gorgeous monuments to a beloved series."

Got a news tip or want to contact us directly? Email news@gamespot.com

Join the conversation
There are 75 comments about this story
75 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
  • 75 results
  • 1
  • 2
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for elephantpunch
elephantpunch

No problems on my end, running the game at 3840x2160. Just got to Arcadia, its been a great return so far

Avatar image for howthegodzkill
howthegodzkill

Just installed the remaster last night. With the exception of the typically poor characters models of the time, the game looks pretty good at 4k on PC. I haven't played it in several years so I can't directly compare it. It's still visually acceptable. Thankfully, the story and the level design add a significant deterrent to any graphics issues. In other words, the game is so good it doesn't rely on the graphics like most games do, they are only a bonus.

Avatar image for jizam_kizam
Jizam_Kizam

I wish I could say I'm surprised, but it seems like almost every other pc release this last year has arrived somewhat broken.

Avatar image for bacontophat45
BaconTopHat45

@jizam_kizam: Remove PC from and replace it with AAA and then it's a very accurate. Games have had a lot of issues on all platforms this year.

But yeah it's more frequent on PC because a dev's laziness shows through very easily on a platform that the players have high standards and those standards aren't made a necessary condition to be sold by the platform owner like on console.

Avatar image for deactivated-58c1f4701508b

Now this is a fine example of genuine video game journalism as opposed to vapid clickbait (I'm looking at you, Eddie Makuch; albeit you have improved in recent months). Good video game journalism should help the reader make an informed opinion about where to spend his hard earned dollar. I was tentatively interested in the Bioshock remaster but now I think I'll pass or wait for a bargain bin sale. Thank you, Mr. Paget.

Avatar image for howthegodzkill
howthegodzkill

When devs creativity dry up and they have no games to release, they remaster.

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@howthegodzkill: The BioShock developers didn't do these remasters, nor do they exist as a studio anymore.

Avatar image for howthegodzkill
howthegodzkill

@Mogan: Oh.. that's even worse. A cover band doing a classic from a band that broke up.

Avatar image for Purpledust
Purpledust

idk but in my bioshock 1 remaster there is a FOV slider. so... yea

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@Purpledust: A slider? In mine it's just a switch. Original or expanded.

Avatar image for naryanrobinson
naryanrobinson

The laze is 90.

Avatar image for Verenti
Verenti

Whatever. They were free.

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@Verenti: Only if you owned the originals. They're still selling these to anybody else. The problems are problems, regardless of price.

Avatar image for Ripper_TV
Ripper_TV

Another "remaster" same story: same graphics, but introduces new bugs, problems and inconcistancies.

Rule of thumb: stay away from anything with a "remaster" blurp on it.

Avatar image for iammcgruber
IAmMcGruber

@Ripper_TV: On PC it was given for free to anyone who already owned it, which is where the problems are. They didn't have to pay for it, if this were on consoles and people paid $60 there'd be a much bigger outcry

Avatar image for jmangamer85
Jmangamer85

i cant evan play the first one crashes all the time it's a real shame

Avatar image for carving_a_giant
carving_a_giant

Let's be honest, the console remasters are the PC version from 2008 or whenever it came out.

I've only ever bought one remaster. Last of us. I have a rule that I don't rebuy games or movies (dvd to bluray)

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@carving_a_giant: I think the console remasters of 1 and 2 are the PC remasters of 1 and 2. Infinite on the console IS the original PC version; 2K basically said as much.

I think these are just a small, low budget project that 2K put enough marketing into for us to think it'd be something more robust.

Avatar image for Myron117
Myron117

These remasters highlight how much they are fucking over console gamers. There is little to no change on the pc version of the games so they give it to us for free as they know no one will buy these updates because they are almost none existant. Yet they happily charge console gamers for these while also not offering BC for Xbox gamers.

The definition of remaster has changed the past year, the lack of effort is staggaring and it will continue.

This is the remaster generation and the worst gen i have experienced in my gaming life.

Online
Avatar image for Myron117
Myron117

We've tested BioShock: The Collection on PS4 and Xbox One, and they run well with infrequent frame rate drops. You can read our preview of the console version here, which called them "gorgeous monuments to a beloved series."

Well maybe you should make it your responsibility to test all versions of the game before you write your damn reviews. Sites like this are the reason Batman Arkham Knight fucked PC gamers then you report like "the game is perfect and works fine! Go buy it!" Then the next day "pc versions fucked not our fault, we didnt know".

Online
Avatar image for ronthallsballs
RonThallsBalls

Steam fucking blows. They need to stop wasting time on Biocock and get to fixin' Quake 2 so it works on windows 10 machines.

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@ronthallsballs: You're telling Kroger to make Kraft mac-n-cheese taste better.

Avatar image for Myron117
Myron117

@ronthallsballs: i dont even...

Online
Avatar image for wtf_666
wtf_666

Impossible, ALL GAMES run at 120fps in 4k on PC!!

( That's what we hear all the time, how amazing and perfect PC gaming is. )

Avatar image for game4metoo
game4metoo

@wtf_666: are you getting ps4 pro?

Avatar image for R4gn4r0k
R4gn4r0k

Played about an hour of it on PC yesterday.

I also noticed a bit better textures and lighting. Perhaps that is the biggest dissapointment, not the mouse/keyboard controls, not all the bugs left intact... But the fact that they chose to rerelease this, but only making the game look 0.000001% better and calling it a day.

It's lazy, it's half assed. And if 2K had respect for their Bioshock franchise they wouldn't have done it like this.

Avatar image for slickwilly06
slickwilly06

@R4gn4r0k: And no FOV slider!! 60 FOV in 4k is claustrophobic and nausea inducing.

Avatar image for gleencross
GleenCross

These problems were expected, unfortunately. The remasters and the DLCs are the biggest scams in this industry for me. This PS4 generation had the worst first half of releases compared to every past generation. Just think about it... The Wii-U is a joke, but nintendo kickstarted this generation. The only great game released since 2012 is Witcher 3. Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, MGSV, etc... All good games, but the only one really great was Witcher 3. Sony and Microsoft announcing big releases in the E3 which will only be released 1 some even 2 years later. Not the whole 4k upscale bullshit. It is clear how flawed this generation is, the DLC and the remasters are just a bonus. We were happy and we did not know, lol The last generation was not that great either, still, it was much better than the shit we have now.

Avatar image for rglgathrawn
RGLGAThrawn

And I rest my case about how remastered games are really the industry's biggest scam. It's absurd how many games get the remastered treatment, especially those that nobody even asked for, and people still flock out to get them even though they probably already own the original. A lot aren't even 10 years old, and some, like Last of Us and the PS3 to PS4 version of FF10, weren't even 3 years old.

Avatar image for jonnybrownieboy
jonnybrownieboy

@rglgathrawn:

Remaking games from the 6th gen and below makes total sense but anything from the 7th gen is definitely not right. For example ffx and xii are justified remasters but remaking any of the xiii games would be an obvious cash grab. Devs only do it because its a cheap way to get cash but somehow still manage to f*ck it up. Case in point, the bioshock collection.

Avatar image for Wraith3
Wraith3

@jonnybrownieboy: Yes. They both still look fine. Go remaster something that needs it!

Avatar image for nervedamaged
nervedamaged

Well, the people on Steam who owned the originals don't have to pay for the updates, which is great, and I know the PS4 and XBOX One get the PC version of Infinite, but for console owners, it's a good bump up. Hope the crashed get fixed.

Avatar image for Frozzik
Frozzik

@nervedamaged: it's running at native 4k/60fps and supports KB/Mouse on consoles? 😉

Avatar image for wtf_666
wtf_666

@Frozzik: LMAO, ya ya ya...all games are 4k/60fps on PC. Surrrrrrreee.....( then why are there so many articles on how the PC versions of games are so BROKEN??? Or PC version of games aren't released on PC. )

Avatar image for Frozzik
Frozzik

@wtf_666: ok buddy. Maybe learn to take a joke....the wink kind of gave it away. Also nice to see you are one of the ignorant console fanboys on here.

Avatar image for cornbredx
cornbredx

What did ya'll think a game that was already HD was gonna look like?

I'm just glad that I still have the original. Crashing is the worst thing a video game can do.

Avatar image for Pelezinho777
Pelezinho777

<in nazi voice> My, What are odds of that?

Avatar image for darksynced
darkSYNced

It's crashed twice for me so far, and the physics seem a little off, but overall I like it, the textures, after comparing, do look a fair bit better, and the water looks great, it's pretty good, but if they don't fix the crashing soon, I'll be a little pissed, but at least it was free.

Avatar image for catsimboy
catsimboy

I got it for free by owning the games already so I'm not complaining much but I really noticed that mouse acceleration. How many games have to be released with that crap and everyone hates it before developers realize it should be OPTIONAL. People shouldn't have to jump through hoops to turn it off or have to dive into INI files or other methods to adjust the FOV.

Avatar image for ice12tray
Ice12Tray

@catsimboy: The mouse acceleration issues are the only thing I've seen so far that appear to be legitimate complaint, and I know that can be a huge issue. Most the time though, I see people complaint that the visual upgrades aren't enough even though it's free and want to review it poorly.

Avatar image for Ferric24
Ferric24

@ice12tray: PC Gamers can be so whiny (I'm one of them) the game's free if you've owned it before on steam! How can you be mad at a free game that you didn't pay anything for?

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@Ferric24: Being mad and complaining that something is broken aren't the same things. Nobody needs to be mad (this is a video game, be an adult) but if you're having problems, bringing them up online can bring them to the attention of people who might know how to fix your problem. And it might warn anybody else who wants to buy these remasters of possible issues.

Avatar image for gamefreak215jd
gamefreak215jd

@Ferric24: People ought to be mad. Its a remaster that's supposed to fix all the issues ,improve the visuals and add new content. The original Bioshock was a great game but it had loads of issues like dated visuals, 15 fps physics and broken audio. Folks were expecting all these issues to be fixed.

Avatar image for DeathCrusher91
DeathCrusher91

PS4 version also has some issues, it'll freeze often if you let the game pause for a few minutes or go to dashboard and back to the game (bioshock 1, didn't played 2 or infinite yet)

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

It's pretty rough. I played through BioShock 1 just a couple years ago, and found the visuals hadn't aged very well. The remaster does look better. The graphical improvements aren't night and day or anything, but it's enough to make it look like I remember from 2007.

The real problems are on the technical side. Sounds are off (nitro splicers are totally silent for me, audio logs sometimes stutter, some voice lines are sound strangely distant when they aren't), settings reset themselves after you relaunch the game, decals (like blood splatters) flicker when you move. None of these are all the time things for me (except those mute nitro splicers), but they're all noticeable.

If you played BioShock on the PS3 or 360, then this remaster will be a nice upgrade, because you've got further to go from your original version. But on the PC ... it's just kind of disappointing. I got these remasters for free, so that's great, but for $20? I think I'd pass unless I'd never played BioShock.

If the technical stuff gets patched up, these remasters will be fine (if not exactly amazing); until then, they're nice freebies you probably wont play all the way through.

Avatar image for R4gn4r0k
R4gn4r0k

@Mogan: Sounds are way off indeed, and should have received the remaster treatment instead of just visuals.

When I fired the Thompson SMG for the first time I knew it: nothing was changed. The bug where the thompson SMG still barely makes any noise (it's firing sound is more silent than the sound of people being hit) is still intact xD

Avatar image for Mogan
Mogan

@R4gn4r0k: It's not a complete fix, but I went into the bioshock.ini file (users/you/appdata/roaming/bioshockHD/bioshock) and set the "SpeakerMode=" line from stereo to SM_7_1, since I've got 7.1 headphones, and that's fixed a lot of the noise volume/not playing issues I had.

Oh, and after I made that change, I set the ini to read only, so the game cant change it back. : \

Avatar image for R4gn4r0k
R4gn4r0k

@Mogan: Thanks !

  • 75 results
  • 1
  • 2