For mine, this game is okay. I would definetly try before you buy

User Rating: 6 | Yoshi's Island DS DS
This review is coming from a person that has had no previous experience with any yoshi's island game. I think this game is quite dull in terms of gameplay. It has simple controls with no challenge whatsoever. You will never be stuck on this game. it has a crappy little storyline, which barely develops and is extremely uninformative. The presentation is so ugly, and I do understand that this is faithful to it's predecesors, but even so, it brought me to tears the first time i saw it. On the positive side I found the music to be pretty decent and in no way repetitive. I also found that it had some replayability just for the secret unlockable levels and basic minigames. I really disliked this game and it will put me off platformers for a while. I strongly recommend looking into this thoroughly if you are considering buying even though anyone who is reading this review has already done so. Final Comments: Nice Tunes, Keeps you playing, Crappy presentation, tiresome controls and general gameplay, and a dodgy storyline