Yes, this game is overrated. It was a pain in the neck to beat.

User Rating: 6.5 | Yoshi's Island DS DS
So what do I say about this game? I guess I will say it had flaws. First of all, it had off-the-wall challenges that were difficult to get through because one little mistake would make you do it over again. It wasn't easy to carry balls around because I kept accidently throwing balls I had collected away while shooting. There were areas where I had to repeat over and over not because of a boss fight, but because of one little mishap. Even getting through those I would become annoyed again.
I didn't care for the regular character switches either.
There was a point in the game as I was climbing neverending vines with baby kong that seemed to lead to nowhere and then finally I found the clouds and got the heck out of there. Using baby peach (with the umbrella) was annoying because she could barely get her *ss up in the air and kept falling back downward.
The last level of the game got too complicated. I lost my motivation.
I would say this game had some good quality stuff in it, but had sloppy, sloppy gameplay.