Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

XCOM: Enemy Unknown Review

loading...

Game Emblems

The Good

  1. XCOM enemy unknown is great fun.

Kevin VanOrd
Posted by Kevin VanOrd, Senior Editor
on

Tension runs high in the excellent XCOM: Enemy Unknown.

A great strategy isn't foolproof, however: you still need the numbers on your side. Each offensive action has a chance to hit, and while it rarely makes sense to gamble when you've got a 1 percent chance of landing your shot, the choice isn't always that simple. Triumph can hinge on a dice roll. Your ability to maintain proper distance is the best way of maintaining supremacy, but you're still at the mercy of mathematics. You might shake your fist and curse when you miss a shot that had an 85 percent chance to hit--but you'll breathe a sigh of relief when the numbers aren't on your side, yet you land a critical hit that shifts the tide of battle. The tension of the dice roll is further drawn out by the cinematic animations that accompany the action. The camera closes in on your sniper and you hear the rifle charge. The fear rises and your heart skips. The anxiety might be relieved by the sight of a sectoid erupting in a gusher of green goo. But it might also be exacerbated by watching the laser fire miss the target, which means finding a new way of handling the danger--and the stress.

The glamorous camera angles that dramatize the successes and failures often contribute to the excitement, but the glam-cam occasionally glitches out, as do other aspects of Enemy Unknown's presentation. Along with close-ups of mean mutons beating their chests and thin men looking as if you caught them in the middle of something insidious, you get close-ups of plasma rifles clipping through walls, laser fire shooting through vehicles, and leafy bushes obscuring the entire screen in all their leafiness. A soldier might lean out from behind a wall and bug out, pointing her empty hands in one direction while her still-holstered weapon fires somewhere else. These seem like small considerations, but the game goes out of its way to look cinematic, so the visual problems really stand out. That's particularly true on the PlayStation 3, which suffers from occasional frame rate stutters in addition to these foibles.

Back at the base, in the meanwhile, you must manage a global array of countries that provide funding to the XCOM project. Their funds are important, because you use them to perform research (alien autopsies, for instance), enhance your squads (unlock another squad slot, perhaps), and purchase new facilities at your base. You view your base from a side cutaway view, ant farm style, and add facilities by excavating outward and downward. Those facilities fit into the bigger picture in a number of ways, producing engineers that you need to research upgrades in your foundry, for instance, or allowing you to place satellites over more regions of the globe.

Satellites are your way of keeping tabs on the state of the globe. Should a satellite detect a nearby UFO, you're engaged in a brief minigame in which an available interceptor attempts to take down the flying menace. Those interceptors--as well as the actions they perform, and the advanced weapons they can equip--also cost you funds, so it's well worth your while to keep different countries well protected. Should a country's populace panic, they may very well withdraw from the project, which negatively affects your monthly income. You can sell off various alien parts you earn after each battle should you need the funds, but those bits and pieces are used to both research and manufacture upgrades. You must always be aware of how your decisions impact future options. Buying titan armor for all your soldiers is tempting, for instance, but would those funds be better spent on more uniform satellite coverage, or foundry projects? There are consequences for every choice.

If you want to exercise your strategic skills outside of the core single-player experience, you can face friends and strangers online in one-versus-one matches. Players are given an equal number of points to spend on units. Soldiers can cost any number of points depending on how you equip them, while alien units are a set number of points each. There is no base management involved in multiplayer games, which are quick-and-dirty deathmatches in which the best (and sometimes, the luckiest) player wins. The matches have the same tense qualities as they do in single-player, with the added tension of not knowing your foe's play style, or the unit makeup of the opposing team.

You'll see strategies here that you won't see in the campaign. The opponent might use ghost armor to go invisible and then use the overwatch ability to spew plasma at you while you reposition yourself. Or he might buff up powerful human heavies even further by using a sectoid's mind merge. The multiplayer is enjoyable as a result, though its one-off nature doesn't have the long-lasting charms of the full-fledged campaign. You can save a go-to squad for easy use in multiplayer battles, though it's a shame you can't save more than one. Having multiple slots for various squads would be a really handy time-saver.

The limited number of multiplayer maps also takes some of the edge off of online competition, which echoes a limitation in the campaign. While you encounter a healthy number of maps when playing offline, Enemy Unknown does not feature the randomly generated maps of the game that inspired it. You eventually start to see maps repeat, which can be noticeable when you're traversing a map in Russia that you played in North America. The enemies may be in different spots, and you might begin battle from a different corner of the map, but the element of surprise isn't as strong in this game as it was in the 1994 original.

Don't be too concerned by the minor drawbacks, however. XCOM: Enemy Unknown is a wonderful and worthy strategy game with a layer of campy charm that makes the stone-faced seriousness of the game's characters all the more endearing. It's also remarkably accessible, thanks to a great interface that feels comfortable whether you're using a keyboard and mouse or have a controller in your hand. Enemy Unknown packs dense amounts of dramatic tension into each turn. And so it's time to eliminate the alien threat, commander. Select a location, build your base…and save humanity.

Kevin VanOrd
By Kevin VanOrd, Senior Editor

Kevin VanOrd is a lifelong RPG lover and violin player. When he isn't busy building PCs and composing symphonies, he watches American Dad reruns with his fat cat, Ollie.

18 comments
Runock
Runock

No issues here running on a gaming laptop. Great game, though I would have appreciated more depth like FFT for example.

tannerjdheard97
tannerjdheard97

That one part where Kevin's talking about "the luckiest" player, you can definitely tell he's been screwed over more than once with luck, :)

PCanton
PCanton

1 of the Best RPG,strategy type of game that i've ever played.

Deevova
Deevova

To say that this game is nothing like the original is a lie. Smaller in scale, yes.

 

Look comparing this game to an 8-bit classic that was made over a decade ago . . . uhmmm just don't. I even believe it's a different developer. I could be wrong on that last part but whatever.

 

Xcom looks and plays well, I highly recommend this game.  

xMAGOGxKruelgor
xMAGOGxKruelgor

Absolutely NOTHING like the original XCom which is a bad bad thing.  This game sucks.

jamenta8
jamenta8

I'm having the cut scenes stuttering too and is annoying.  Game can still be played because I am running a fairly high end rig with a quad core cpu and ATI Radeon 5850 series.  Yet - for this kind of stuttering to be occurring is almost inexcusable for a studio release of this magnitude - and I think the company owes a patch to clients who payed for this game - quickly.

 

I also suspect the framerate stuttering is not GPU related but has to do with the Windows/Direct X interface.  Thank you microsoft for your proprietary BS.

tektrader
tektrader

@jamenta8 What? If not for DirectX, every gaming company would have to create their own iteration of an interface with all of the millions of combinations of hardware out there. Dumbed-down, that would be B.S.

Dominicobaggio
Dominicobaggio

Good review. Glad I pre ordered this and dishonoured!

Leefx
Leefx

The original was amazing, I had months of fun with it, can't wait for Friday!!

i_love_juice
i_love_juice

stupid ps3 framerate issues ;/ Now I can't decide whether to get it for my PS3 or PC (on PC i have like 20-30fps, about 26-27 most of the time), what's your advice, would PS3 be still better than that? Does the framerate issue on PS3 affect gameplay or they occur only when you are watching something (character run, shoot etc) and not acutally doing anything by yourself? Doesn't it take away from the multiplayer experience when  you have limited time for move? I'd love some info about that, please!

reanor2
reanor2

 @i_love_juice

 I have stutters everywhere and as further into game as worse it gets. Its very annoying these frame rate issues. I guess game is trying to stream-load or something? Very very unpolished. Comparing to Uncharted 3 on PS3 this gam runs like CRAP. Even though its a good game the performance issues make me very sad panda. Its annoying and breaks the impression. :(

KidxGhst
KidxGhst

 @i_love_juice  From what ive played at it before i went to work a few hours ago it seemed like the stutters were just during out of gameplay elements like a hickup in a video.. Something that would be surely fixed with another patch or so.

i_love_juice
i_love_juice

 @KidxGhst  That would be great, still can't decide whether to pick it on PC or PS3, 2days left to decide since its coming to Europe on friday... I got this strange feeling when playing demo on PC that even tough it keeps ~28fps most of the time it's still not running smooth ;/ And where's that PS3 demo...

advocacy
advocacy like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

XCOM and Dishonored.  Too many games, my wallet is crying.

ajay1708
ajay1708

@advocacy Dishonored is a beast! Currently that's my favorite game. That and Metro.

never-named
never-named

 @advocacy I Am in the unenviable position of having to choose either one from them. =[

ristactionjakso
ristactionjakso

Game seems awesome. Unique on consoles. Might have to get on psn and see if there is a demo out now.

Conversation powered by Livefyre

XCOM: Enemy Unknown BoxshotEnlarge the boxshot
Not Following

    Game Stats

    • Rank:
      224 of 0
      PlayStation 3 Rank:
      51 of 2,895
      Highest Rank:
      NANot Ranked
      Followers:
      461Follow»
      Wishlists:
      125Wish It»
      • Player Reviews: 14
      • Player Ratings: 175
      • Users Now Playing: 52
    • M Rating Description

      Titles rated M (Mature) have content that may be suitable for persons ages 17 and older. Learn more

    Also on: