Pros: Looks better in HD, XBL Play, New controls scheme works Cons: Game feels old
The game obviously looks better on the 360. The graphics are finally in HD. The problem is however that it's the same graphics engine that we've had for so long. The character models look fleshed out and more detailed yes, but you can still see the same flaws that you've seen previous versions of the game. The engine still uses the same move animations, which is getting rather boring. The game has some of the top talent in the WWE including some legends. The bad part about the roster is that we have 4 versions of mick foley. This is lazy development. Another problem with the roster is that its out of date. However that is a good thing, since now a days the WWE is actually lacking talent, the game has Kurt Angle.
The games sound design isn't bad. The sound track is fairly decent, and the WWE superstars lend their voices here again. The match commentary however, is simply copy and paste from last years game.
The game features all match types found in the WWE, and sports over 40 stories in season mode. The season mode obviously gives the game high replay value, however, it gets boring fast. Once you fully grasp the new game controls, you'll feel that not much has truly changed. The AI is still broken, and the superstars themselves don't fight like their TV personas.
The game also sports a franchise mode called GM mode. Minor new features here don't do it justice, as you still don't have full control over who wins or looses matches. It still seems half assed.
The CAW mode is great as usual. You have some new items to add, and if you're new, it could take a while to create the superstar you want. Vets, and pros of the series, will feel right at home.
Overall, the game isn't bad. If you've played last years rendition, you really have no need to check this one out. If you're a die hard fan though, pick it up, and beat the snot out of the McMahon brats.