Thief vs. Dishonored: The Superior Stealth Game Showdown

Which is better: Thief or Dishonored? Daniel Hindes dissects the stealth-action genre's two biggest games to find out which comes out on top.

Discussion

12 comments
Xatsuna
Xatsuna

Thief was extremely boring. I expected better from the creators of Hitman.

redder1111
redder1111

Dishonored is the winner imo. one of the best games i've ever played ...

Arkhalipso
Arkhalipso

So Dishonored is a far better Thief game than... Thief. As weird as it sounds, I agree with this.

MateykoSlam
MateykoSlam

i like how both games use ue3 but thief justifies this saying ue3 can't handle big levels. go home eidos montreal. dishonored is ten times better.

vadagar1
vadagar1

thief 1 and 2  and 3 are vastly superior to both these games

EdAl2112
EdAl2112

Nice click/flamebait article. Is this how you look for content for the next feedbackula?

Mevrick
Mevrick

Why does every feature article you made concerning these games looks like a Twilight Zone presentation episode? 

omar_q
omar_q

I want to like Thief just because the protagonist looks so cool and the atmosphere as well but from what I've heard the gameplay sucks.


Oh well. 

Smosh150
Smosh150

@omar_q  Sadly I heard the same, but the main point that really turns me off as mentioned in this video is the way that Thief holds your hand and only allows you to follow the path shown. That is a huge downfall imo and I really enjoyed how Dishonored approached its levels with a sense of player control.